Re: [OT] The dumb and the guilty (Was Re: How many ....)

Daniel declared:

The Last Doctor wrote on 16/4/24 12:55 am:

>
If the Biblical Jesus even existed, the only available evidence
on the YEAR of his birth is contradictory even within the
Bible and the closest guess scholars make is “somewhere
between 4 and 6 BC”.
>
Let alone the month or day of it, which is a complete unknown
as the writers of the Gospels didn’t bother to include any
such information and there are no external records to
cover it.
>

Haley's Comet (The Star from The East, maybe) was around
in 4 B.C., off the top of my head!

 Ask ten different experts what that star was, and you’ll get
at least a dozen different answers.
 (That’s assuming it even existed in the first place. Three out of
the four gospels don’t even mention it!)