Re: Regarding assignment to struct

Liste des GroupesRevenir à l c 
Sujet : Re: Regarding assignment to struct
De : Keith.S.Thompson+u (at) *nospam* gmail.com (Keith Thompson)
Groupes : comp.lang.c
Date : 29. May 2025, 22:54:53
Autres entêtes
Organisation : None to speak of
Message-ID : <87jz5zdqvm.fsf@nosuchdomain.example.com>
References : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
User-Agent : Gnus/5.13 (Gnus v5.13)
scott@slp53.sl.home (Scott Lurndal) writes:
[...]
And sometimes, excessive use of the comma operator causes
compiler failures.
>
cfront generated the comma operator extensively, and expression trees
would grow to very large sizes.   There was a bug in PCC (for the
88100) where it would run out of temporary registers while generating
code for some cfront generated comma expressions (which were -far- from
human readable).    I had to fix the temporary register allocation
code in PCC to spill registers when the sethi-ullman number for an
expression exceeded the number of registers.
 
That was circa 1990, and I've generally not found any arguments
favoring their general use persuasive in the years since, including
Andrey's and Kaz's responses recently posted here.

So a compiler you used circa 1990 had problems with comma expressions.

That's hardly an argument against using comma operators today.

The simple fact that experienced programmers that read this usenet
newsgroup missed the comma operators in the original example speaks
volumes.

*That's* a valid argument.

--
Keith Thompson (The_Other_Keith) Keith.S.Thompson+u@gmail.com
void Void(void) { Void(); } /* The recursive call of the void */

Date Sujet#  Auteur
2 May 25 * Regarding assignment to struct99Lew Pitcher
2 May 25 +- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Keith Thompson
2 May 25 +* Re: Regarding assignment to struct13Barry Schwarz
2 May 25 i`* That depends... (Was: Regarding assignment to struct)12Kenny McCormack
3 May 25 i `* Re: That depends... (Was: Regarding assignment to struct)11Lew Pitcher
3 May 25 i  +- Re: That depends... (Was: Regarding assignment to struct)1Lawrence D'Oliveiro
3 May 25 i  +- Re: That depends... (Was: Regarding assignment to struct)1Janis Papanagnou
3 May 25 i  +* Re: That depends... (Was: Regarding assignment to struct)5Kaz Kylheku
3 May 25 i  i+* Re: That depends... (Was: Regarding assignment to struct)3Kaz Kylheku
5 May 25 i  ii`* Re: That depends... (Was: Regarding assignment to struct)2Janis Papanagnou
5 May 25 i  ii `- Re: That depends... (Was: Regarding assignment to struct)1Kaz Kylheku
4 May 25 i  i`- Re: That depends... (Was: Regarding assignment to struct)1Tim Rentsch
3 May 25 i  +- Re: That depends... (Was: Regarding assignment to struct)1James Kuyper
4 May 25 i  `* Re: That depends... (Was: Regarding assignment to struct)2Tim Rentsch
4 May 25 i   `- Re: That depends... (Was: Regarding assignment to struct)1Lew Pitcher
2 May 25 +* Re: Regarding assignment to struct2Waldek Hebisch
3 May 25 i`- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Lew Pitcher
3 May 25 +* Re: Regarding assignment to struct66Andrey Tarasevich
3 May 25 i+* Re: Regarding assignment to struct9Lawrence D'Oliveiro
4 May 25 ii`* Re: Regarding assignment to struct8Keith Thompson
4 May 25 ii `* Re: Regarding assignment to struct7James Kuyper
4 May 25 ii  +- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Kenny McCormack
4 May 25 ii  +- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1David Brown
4 May 25 ii  `* Re: Regarding assignment to struct4Keith Thompson
5 May 25 ii   +- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1James Kuyper
5 May 25 ii   +- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Keith Thompson
6 May 25 ii   `- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Tim Rentsch
3 May 25 i+- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Lawrence D'Oliveiro
4 May 25 i`* Re: Regarding assignment to struct55Tim Rentsch
5 May 25 i `* Re: Regarding assignment to struct54Andrey Tarasevich
5 May 25 i  +* Re: Regarding assignment to struct29Michael S
5 May 25 i  i+* Re: Regarding assignment to struct27Andrey Tarasevich
5 May 25 i  ii`* Re: Regarding assignment to struct26Michael S
5 May 25 i  ii +- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Tim Rentsch
5 May 25 i  ii `* Re: Regarding assignment to struct24Andrey Tarasevich
5 May 25 i  ii  +* Re: Regarding assignment to struct4Michael S
6 May 25 i  ii  i+- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Tim Rentsch
29 May13:11 i  ii  i+- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Andrey Tarasevich
29 May17:57 i  ii  i`- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1James Kuyper
5 May 25 i  ii  `* Re: Regarding assignment to struct19Keith Thompson
6 May 25 i  ii   +* Re: Regarding assignment to struct2Tim Rentsch
6 May 25 i  ii   i`- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Keith Thompson
6 May 25 i  ii   +* Re: Regarding assignment to struct3David Brown
29 May13:19 i  ii   i`* Re: Regarding assignment to struct2Andrey Tarasevich
29 May20:05 i  ii   i `- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1David Brown
6 May 25 i  ii   +* Re: Regarding assignment to struct11Waldek Hebisch
6 May 25 i  ii   i+* Re: Regarding assignment to struct7David Brown
7 May 25 i  ii   ii`* Re: Regarding assignment to struct6David Brown
29 May13:49 i  ii   ii `* Re: Regarding assignment to struct5Andrey Tarasevich
29 May15:33 i  ii   ii  +- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Janis Papanagnou
29 May20:20 i  ii   ii  `* Re: Regarding assignment to struct3David Brown
29 May22:54 i  ii   ii   +- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Keith Thompson
30 May09:50 i  ii   ii   `- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1David Brown
6 May 25 i  ii   i+- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Keith Thompson
29 May13:21 i  ii   i`* Re: Regarding assignment to struct2Andrey Tarasevich
29 May15:43 i  ii   i `- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Janis Papanagnou
29 May13:14 i  ii   `* Re: Regarding assignment to struct2Andrey Tarasevich
29 May21:56 i  ii    `- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Keith Thompson
5 May 25 i  i`- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Tim Rentsch
5 May 25 i  +* Re: Regarding assignment to struct4Keith Thompson
5 May 25 i  i`* Re: Regarding assignment to struct3Andrey Tarasevich
8 May 25 i  i `* Re: Regarding assignment to struct2Tim Rentsch
8 May 25 i  i  `- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1David Brown
5 May 25 i  +* Re: Regarding assignment to struct17Keith Thompson
5 May 25 i  i+* Re: Regarding assignment to struct6Michael S
5 May 25 i  ii+- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Kenny McCormack
5 May 25 i  ii+* Re: Regarding assignment to struct3Keith Thompson
5 May 25 i  iii`* Re: Regarding assignment to struct2Kaz Kylheku
6 May 25 i  iii `- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Tim Rentsch
6 May 25 i  ii`- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Tim Rentsch
5 May 25 i  i`* Re: Regarding assignment to struct10Tim Rentsch
5 May 25 i  i `* Re: Regarding assignment to struct9Keith Thompson
6 May 25 i  i  +* Re: Regarding assignment to struct6Nick Bowler
6 May 25 i  i  i`* Re: Regarding assignment to struct5Keith Thompson
7 May 25 i  i  i `* Re: Regarding assignment to struct4Nick Bowler
7 May 25 i  i  i  +* Re: Regarding assignment to struct2Keith Thompson
8 May 25 i  i  i  i`- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Nick Bowler
8 May 25 i  i  i  `- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Tim Rentsch
29 May13:36 i  i  `* Re: Regarding assignment to struct2Andrey Tarasevich
29 May22:36 i  i   `- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Keith Thompson
5 May 25 i  +* Re: Regarding assignment to struct2Tim Rentsch
5 May 25 i  i`- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1David Brown
12 May 25 i  `- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1NotAorB
3 May 25 +* Re: Regarding assignment to struct8David Brown
5 May 25 i`* Re: Regarding assignment to struct7Muttley
5 May 25 i +- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1David Brown
5 May 25 i `* Re: Regarding assignment to struct5Keith Thompson
6 May 25 i  +- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Muttley
6 May 25 i  +* Re: Regarding assignment to struct2David Brown
6 May 25 i  i`- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Muttley
6 May 25 i  `- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Michael S
4 May 25 +* Re: Regarding assignment to struct6Richard Damon
4 May 25 i`* Re: Regarding assignment to struct5Michael S
4 May 25 i +* Re: Regarding assignment to struct2Lawrence D'Oliveiro
4 May 25 i i`- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1David Brown
6 May 25 i +- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Tim Rentsch
12 May 25 i `- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Rosario19
4 May 25 +- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Tim Rentsch
4 May 25 `- Re: Regarding assignment to struct1Keith Thompson

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal