Landlord fines tenant for negative reviews

In Scottsdale, a man beomes a tenants in rental housing, intending to
stay for a few months as he looks to buy. He had to leave his old house
by a specific deadline as it had sold.

The property was not in move-in condition, large black marks on the
carpeting, large holes in the walls. The management company ignored
complaints. After posting two negative reviews, he was fined $4,000.

The lease he signed includes a non-disparagement clause specific to
posting such reviews.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gUqjG7ZZZU0