Re: Radians Or Degrees?

Liste des GroupesRevenir à c arch 
Sujet : Re: Radians Or Degrees?
De : mitchalsup (at) *nospam* aol.com (MitchAlsup1)
Groupes : comp.lang.c comp.arch
Date : 20. Mar 2024, 21:26:03
Autres entêtes
Organisation : Rocksolid Light
Message-ID : <45a87cfd06631ecc5820e21b8a58fe08@www.novabbs.org>
References : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
User-Agent : Rocksolid Light
Stefan Monnier wrote:

There are groups who have shown that exactly rounded trancendental
functions are in fact achievable with maybe 3X reduced performance.
That much?  I had the impression it was significantly cheaper.
The J. M. Muller book indicates about 2× to 2.5×

The [Rlibm](https://people.cs.rutgers.edu/~sn349/rlibm/) project claims
to get much better performance (basically, in the same ballpark as
not-correctly-rounded implementations).

[ Their key insight is the idea that to get correct rounding, you
  shouldn't try to compute the best approximation of the exact result
  and then round, but you should instead try to compute any
  approximation whose rounding gives the correct result.  ]
This sounds like the "Minefield Method"

My impression was that their performance was good enough that the case
for not-correctly-rounded implementations becomes very weak.

I don't know what are/were the motivations for the people working on
exact transcendentals, but they have applications unrelated to the fact
that they're "better": the main benefit (from this here PL guy) is that
it gives them a reliable, reproducible semantics.
Bit-for-bit reproducibility makes several things much easier.
>
Consider moving an application which uses libm from machine to machine.
When libm is correctly rounded, there is no issue at all; not so other-
wise.

Exactly!
[ Or should I say "Correctly rounded!"?  ]

        Stefan

Date Sujet#  Auteur
14 Mar 24 * Re: Radians Or Degrees?53Michael S
14 Mar 24 +* Re: Radians Or Degrees?9MitchAlsup1
14 Mar 24 i+* Re: Radians Or Degrees?2MitchAlsup1
15 Mar 24 ii`- Re: Radians Or Degrees?1Terje Mathisen
14 Mar 24 i+* Re: Radians Or Degrees?5Lawrence D'Oliveiro
15 Mar 24 ii+- Re: Radians Or Degrees?1Chris M. Thomasson
15 Mar 24 ii`* Re: Radians Or Degrees?3MitchAlsup1
15 Mar 24 ii `* Re: Radians Or Degrees?2Chris M. Thomasson
15 Mar 24 ii  `- Re: Radians Or Degrees?1Chris M. Thomasson
15 Mar 24 i`- Re: Radians Or Degrees?1Michael S
15 Mar 24 +* Re: Radians Or Degrees?26Terje Mathisen
15 Mar 24 i+* Re: Radians Or Degrees?3Michael S
16 Mar 24 ii`* Re: Radians Or Degrees?2MitchAlsup1
16 Mar 24 ii `- Re: Radians Or Degrees?1Terje Mathisen
15 Mar 24 i`* Re: Radians Or Degrees?22Chris M. Thomasson
15 Mar 24 i +* Re: Radians Or Degrees?2Chris M. Thomasson
16 Mar 24 i i`- Re: Radians Or Degrees?1Chris M. Thomasson
15 Mar 24 i +* Re: Radians Or Degrees?18Keith Thompson
15 Mar 24 i i+* Re: Radians Or Degrees?5Chris M. Thomasson
15 Mar 24 i ii`* Re: Radians Or Degrees?4Chris M. Thomasson
16 Mar 24 i ii `* Re: Radians Or Degrees?3Keith Thompson
17 Mar 24 i ii  `* Re: Radians Or Degrees?2Chris M. Thomasson
18 Mar 24 i ii   `- Re: Radians Or Degrees?1Chris M. Thomasson
16 Mar 24 i i`* Re: Radians Or Degrees?12MitchAlsup1
16 Mar 24 i i `* Re: Radians Or Degrees?11Michael S
16 Mar 24 i i  `* Re: Radians Or Degrees?10MitchAlsup1
16 Mar 24 i i   +- Re: Radians Or Degrees?1Michael S
17 Mar 24 i i   `* Re: Radians Or Degrees?8Keith Thompson
17 Mar 24 i i    +* Re: Radians Or Degrees?5bart
17 Mar 24 i i    i`* Re: Radians Or Degrees?4Keith Thompson
17 Mar 24 i i    i `* Re: Radians Or Degrees?3bart
17 Mar 24 i i    i  `* Re: Radians Or Degrees?2Keith Thompson
17 Mar 24 i i    i   `- Re: Radians Or Degrees?1David Brown
17 Mar 24 i i    `* Re: Radians Or Degrees?2Michael S
17 Mar 24 i i     `- Re: Radians Or Degrees?1Michael S
16 Mar 24 i `- Re: Radians Or Degrees?1Chris M. Thomasson
18 Mar 24 `* Re: Radians Or Degrees?17Stefan Monnier
19 Mar 24  `* Re: Radians Or Degrees?16MitchAlsup1
20 Mar 24   `* Re: Radians Or Degrees?15Stefan Monnier
20 Mar 24    +* Re: Radians Or Degrees?11Michael S
20 Mar 24    i+* Re: Radians Or Degrees?6Stefan Monnier
20 Mar 24    ii`* Re: Radians Or Degrees?5MitchAlsup1
21 Mar 24    ii `* Re: Radians Or Degrees?4Terje Mathisen
21 Mar 24    ii  `* Re: Radians Or Degrees?3Michael S
21 Mar 24    ii   +- Re: Radians Or Degrees?1MitchAlsup1
23 Mar 24    ii   `- Re: Radians Or Degrees?1Terje Mathisen
20 Mar 24    i+* Re: Radians Or Degrees?2Steven G. Kargl
20 Mar 24    ii`- Re: Radians Or Degrees?1MitchAlsup1
20 Mar 24    i`* Re: Radians Or Degrees?2MitchAlsup1
21 Mar 24    i `- Re: Radians Or Degrees?1Michael S
20 Mar 24    +* Re: Radians Or Degrees?2MitchAlsup1
20 Mar 24    i`- Re: Radians Or Degrees?1Stefan Monnier
21 Mar 24    `- Re: Radians Or Degrees?1Terje Mathisen

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal