Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 6600

Liste des GroupesRevenir à c arch 
Sujet : Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 6600
De : mitchalsup (at) *nospam* aol.com (MitchAlsup1)
Groupes : comp.arch
Date : 26. Apr 2024, 22:01:35
Autres entêtes
Organisation : Rocksolid Light
Message-ID : <cb96602949ccc7bae484d12748f2b3c9@www.novabbs.org>
References : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
User-Agent : Rocksolid Light
Anton Ertl wrote:

mitchalsup@aol.com (MitchAlsup1) writes:
What we need is ~16-bit displacements where 82½%-91¼% are positive.

What are these funny numbers about?
In typical usages in MY 66000 ISA <only> one needs only 18 DW of
negative addressing and we have a 16-bit displacement. So, technically
it might get by at the 99% level with -32..+65500. Other usages might
need a few more on the negative end of things so 1/8..1/16 in the
negative direction, 7/8..15/16 in the positive.

Do you mean that you want number ranges like -11468..54067 (82.5%
positive) or -5734..59801 (91.25% positive)?  Which one of those?  And
why not, say -8192..57343 (87.5% positive)?
Roughly.

How does one use a frame pointer without negative displacements ??

You let it point to the lowest address you want to access.  That moves
the problem to unwinding frame pointer chains where the unwinder does
not know the frame-specific difference between the frame pointer and
the pointer of the next frame.

An alternative is to have a frame-independent difference that leaves
enough room that, say 90% (or 99%, or whatever) of the frames don't
need negative offsets from that frame.

Likewise, if you have signed displacements, and are unhappy about the
skewed usage, you can let the frame pointer point at an offset from
the pointer to the next fram such that the usage is less skewed.
Such a hassle....

- anton

Date Sujet#  Auteur
17 Apr 24 * Stealing a Great Idea from the 6600128John Savard
18 Apr 24 +* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 6600125MitchAlsup1
18 Apr 24 i`* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 6600124John Savard
18 Apr 24 i `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 6600123MitchAlsup1
19 Apr 24 i  `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 6600122John Savard
19 Apr 24 i   `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 6600121John Savard
19 Apr 24 i    `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 6600120MitchAlsup1
20 Apr 24 i     +* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66002John Savard
21 Apr 24 i     i`- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001John Savard
20 Apr 24 i     `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 6600117John Savard
20 Apr 24 i      `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 6600116John Savard
20 Apr 24 i       `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 6600115MitchAlsup1
20 Apr 24 i        +* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 6600105BGB
21 Apr 24 i        i`* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 6600104MitchAlsup1
21 Apr 24 i        i +* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660063John Savard
21 Apr 24 i        i i+* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660015John Savard
25 Apr 24 i        i ii`* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660014Lawrence D'Oliveiro
25 Apr 24 i        i ii +* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660012MitchAlsup1
25 Apr 24 i        i ii i+- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001Lawrence D'Oliveiro
30 Apr 24 i        i ii i`* Re: a bit of history, Stealing a Great Idea from the 660010John Levine
3 May 24 i        i ii i `* Re: a bit of history, Stealing a Great Idea from the 66009Anton Ertl
3 May 24 i        i ii i  +* Re: a bit of history, Stealing a Great Idea from the 66007John Levine
4 May 24 i        i ii i  i`* Re: a bit of history, Stealing a Great Idea from the 66006Thomas Koenig
4 May 24 i        i ii i  i +* Re: a bit of history, Stealing a Great Idea from the 66004John Levine
4 May 24 i        i ii i  i i`* Re: a bit of history, Stealing a Great Idea from the 66003MitchAlsup1
5 May 24 i        i ii i  i i `* Re: a bit of history, Stealing a Great Idea from the 66002Thomas Koenig
5 May 24 i        i ii i  i i  `- Re: a bit of history, Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001MitchAlsup1
28 Jul 24 i        i ii i  i `- Re: a bit of history, Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001Lawrence D'Oliveiro
3 May 24 i        i ii i  `- Re: a bit of history, Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001MitchAlsup1
25 Apr 24 i        i ii `- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001John Savard
21 Apr 24 i        i i`* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660047MitchAlsup1
23 Apr 24 i        i i +* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660045George Neuner
23 Apr 24 i        i i i`* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660044MitchAlsup1
25 Apr 24 i        i i i `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660043George Neuner
26 Apr 24 i        i i i  `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660042BGB
26 Apr 24 i        i i i   `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660041MitchAlsup1
26 Apr 24 i        i i i    +* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66002Anton Ertl
26 Apr 24 i        i i i    i`- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001MitchAlsup1
26 Apr 24 i        i i i    +* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66004BGB
26 Apr 24 i        i i i    i+* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66002MitchAlsup1
27 Apr 24 i        i i i    ii`- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001BGB
26 Apr 24 i        i i i    i`- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001MitchAlsup1
27 Apr 24 i        i i i    `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660034BGB
27 Apr 24 i        i i i     `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660033MitchAlsup1
28 Apr 24 i        i i i      `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660032BGB
28 Apr 24 i        i i i       `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660031MitchAlsup1
28 Apr 24 i        i i i        `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660030BGB
28 Apr 24 i        i i i         +* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660024BGB
28 Apr 24 i        i i i         i`* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660023BGB
28 Apr 24 i        i i i         i `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660022Thomas Koenig
28 Apr 24 i        i i i         i  `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660021BGB
28 Apr 24 i        i i i         i   `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660020BGB
28 Apr 24 i        i i i         i    +* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66002Thomas Koenig
28 Apr 24 i        i i i         i    i`- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001BGB
29 Jul 24 i        i i i         i    +* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660016Lawrence D'Oliveiro
29 Jul 24 i        i i i         i    i+* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66006BGB
30 Jul 24 i        i i i         i    ii`* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66005Lawrence D'Oliveiro
30 Jul 24 i        i i i         i    ii `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66004BGB
31 Jul 24 i        i i i         i    ii  `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66003Lawrence D'Oliveiro
31 Jul 24 i        i i i         i    ii   `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66002BGB
1 Aug 24 i        i i i         i    ii    `- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001Lawrence D'Oliveiro
29 Jul 24 i        i i i         i    i`* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66009Terje Mathisen
29 Jul 24 i        i i i         i    i `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66008MitchAlsup1
30 Jul 24 i        i i i         i    i  +- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001Lawrence D'Oliveiro
30 Jul 24 i        i i i         i    i  +* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66004Michael S
30 Jul 24 i        i i i         i    i  i`* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66003MitchAlsup1
31 Jul 24 i        i i i         i    i  i `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66002BGB
1 Aug 24 i        i i i         i    i  i  `- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001Lawrence D'Oliveiro
1 Aug 24 i        i i i         i    i  `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66002Thomas Koenig
1 Aug 24 i        i i i         i    i   `- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001MitchAlsup1
29 Jul 24 i        i i i         i    `- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001George Neuner
28 Apr 24 i        i i i         `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66005MitchAlsup1
28 Apr 24 i        i i i          `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66004BGB
29 Apr 24 i        i i i           `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66003MitchAlsup1
29 Apr 24 i        i i i            `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66002BGB
29 Apr 24 i        i i i             `- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001Thomas Koenig
29 Apr 24 i        i i `- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001Tim Rentsch
21 Apr 24 i        i `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660040BGB
21 Apr 24 i        i  `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660039MitchAlsup1
22 Apr 24 i        i   +* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66003BGB
22 Apr 24 i        i   i`* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66002MitchAlsup1
22 Apr 24 i        i   i `- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001BGB
22 Apr 24 i        i   +* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66002John Savard
22 Apr 24 i        i   i`- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001BGB
22 Apr 24 i        i   `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660033Terje Mathisen
22 Apr 24 i        i    +- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001BGB
13 Jun 24 i        i    `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660031Kent Dickey
13 Jun 24 i        i     +* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660016Stefan Monnier
13 Jun 24 i        i     i`* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660015BGB
13 Jun 24 i        i     i `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660014MitchAlsup1
14 Jun 24 i        i     i  `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660013BGB
18 Jun 24 i        i     i   `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660012MitchAlsup1
19 Jun 24 i        i     i    +* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66008BGB
19 Jun 24 i        i     i    i`* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66007MitchAlsup1
19 Jun 24 i        i     i    i +* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66005BGB
19 Jun 24 i        i     i    i i`* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66004MitchAlsup1
20 Jun 24 i        i     i    i i `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66003Thomas Koenig
20 Jun 24 i        i     i    i i  `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66002MitchAlsup1
21 Jun 24 i        i     i    i i   `- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001Thomas Koenig
20 Jun 24 i        i     i    i `- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001John Savard
19 Jun 24 i        i     i    +- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001Thomas Koenig
20 Jun 24 i        i     i    +- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001MitchAlsup1
31 Jul 24 i        i     i    `- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001Lawrence D'Oliveiro
13 Jun 24 i        i     +* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 660013MitchAlsup1
14 Jun 24 i        i     `- Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66001Terje Mathisen
22 Apr 24 i        `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66009John Savard
18 Apr 24 `* Re: Stealing a Great Idea from the 66002Lawrence D'Oliveiro

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal