Sujet : Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond
De : cr88192 (at) *nospam* gmail.com (BGB)
Groupes : comp.archDate : 07. May 2024, 04:32:53
Autres entêtes
Organisation : A noiseless patient Spider
Message-ID : <v1c3so$3195m$1@dont-email.me>
References : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
User-Agent : Mozilla Thunderbird
On 5/6/2024 7:53 PM, MitchAlsup1 wrote:
BGB wrote:
On 5/6/2024 2:11 PM, MitchAlsup1 wrote:
Lawrence D'Oliveiro wrote:
>
On Sun, 5 May 2024 20:50:51 -0500, BGB wrote:
>
Say, RISC-V:
Says yes to DIV and MOD;
Says yes to 4-register floating-point multiple-accumulate; Say no to
register-indexed Load/Store.
Me: This is not a good balance...
>
Multiply-accumulate is at least as much about reducing rounding error as about speed.
>
It is also an IEEE 754-2008+ requirement.
And... I have a version that just sort of works well enough to make RV64G work, but is sort of a fail on the other fronts:
Using it is slower than separate ops;
It produces a double-rounded result.
Also, well, the FMUL isn't super accurate either.
So, it fails IEEE 754-accuracy requirements.
FMUL is implemented in a way where it only generates the high-half of the multiply, which makes the FPU cheaper, but:
Does not give strict 0.5ULP rounding.
Also failing EEE 754-accuracy requirements.
Yes, but then again, I make no claim that it is IEEE-754 conformant, merely that it uses the same formats, and is "good enough" for most stuff one needs an FPU for.
Some combination of factors leads to the inability of Newton-Raphson to fully converge, possibly either due to omitting the low-order multiplier results, or the carry-propagation limitation for rounding (if the rounding would result in more than 8 bits of carry, it is skipped).
Newton-Raphson is dependent on getting the bits right so that its
interpolation (between iterations) converges properly.
Yeah, it gets "most of the way" and then usually gets stuck at the last 4 bits or so.
For most uses though, this is OK, as one has the other 48 bits which are still generally correct.
Not likely to do proper FMA, as this would make a Binary64 FPU too expensive (and, doing Binary64 poorly is still preferable for most uses to not doing it at all).
And yet, every other non FPGA implementation achieves those requirements.
It really seams that your medium is influencing your architecture,
rather than the other way around.
Possibly.
Many other FPGA based soft-core processors either lack an FPU, implement single-precision only (such as MicroBlaze), or make similar compromises.
One of the exceptions here is SWeRV (RV32GC), but it also eats a considerable number of LUTs and runs at a fairly low clock speed, though unclear how much of this is due to the FPU, or to other factors.
Granted, not entirely sure how the 8087 managed to do all the stuff that it did. Since, it seems like an 80s ASIC would be more cramped than a modern Artix-7.
Mostly it was simply slow.
Hmm...
A slow FPU is much less useful for most things than an inaccurate FPU.
OTOH, probably couldn't exactly do floating point in software all that quickly on an 8088 or 8086. I guess that mostly just leaves fixed point and similar.
....
Date | Sujet | # | | Auteur |
1 May 24 | Byte Addressability And Beyond | 590 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
1 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 431 | | John Levine |
1 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 409 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
1 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 3 | | John Levine |
1 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | John Levine |
1 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
1 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Michael S |
1 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 404 | | John Levine |
2 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 382 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
2 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 4 | | John Levine |
2 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 3 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
2 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 2 | | John Levine |
5 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
2 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 367 | | John Savard |
2 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 2 | | MitchAlsup1 |
11 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | John Savard |
4 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 364 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
8 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 363 | | John Savard |
8 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 2 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
10 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | David Brown |
8 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 360 | | MitchAlsup1 |
8 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 359 | | John Levine |
8 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 357 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
9 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 356 | | John Levine |
10 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 354 | | David Brown |
10 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 353 | | Anton Ertl |
11 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 352 | | David Brown |
11 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 351 | | Anton Ertl |
11 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 158 | | David Brown |
11 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Anton Ertl |
27 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 156 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
27 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 155 | | John Levine |
27 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 154 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
27 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 153 | | John Levine |
27 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 149 | | John Levine |
27 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | MitchAlsup1 |
28 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 147 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
28 May 24 | Re: encoding conversion, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | John Levine |
28 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 145 | | Thomas Koenig |
29 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 137 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
29 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 136 | | Anton Ertl |
29 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 12 | | Stefan Monnier |
29 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 10 | | Stefan Monnier |
29 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 3 | | John Levine |
30 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 2 | | George Neuner |
4 Jun 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | George Neuner |
30 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 6 | | Anton Ertl |
4 Jun 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
4 Jun 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 4 | | Stefan Monnier |
7 Jun 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Terje Mathisen |
7 Jun 24 | Re: Character non-equivalence, was Byte Addressability And Beyond | 2 | | John Levine |
9 Jun 24 | Re: Character non-equivalence, was Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
30 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
30 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 117 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
30 May 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 66 | | John Levine |
30 May 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Stephen Fuld |
30 May 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 22 | | Anton Ertl |
30 May 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 21 | | Thomas Koenig |
30 May 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 8 | | Michael S |
30 May 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Thomas Koenig |
30 May 24 | Re: IBM architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 5 | | John Levine |
30 May 24 | Re: IBM architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 2 | | Michael S |
30 May 24 | Re: IBM architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | John Levine |
30 May 24 | Re: IBM architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 2 | | Thomas Koenig |
30 May 24 | Re: IBM architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | John Levine |
30 May 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Anton Ertl |
30 May 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 3 | | Anton Ertl |
30 May 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | John Levine |
30 May 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Thomas Koenig |
31 May 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 5 | | Terje Mathisen |
1 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 4 | | Thomas Koenig |
1 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 3 | | Anton Ertl |
2 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 2 | | John Levine |
4 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Stefan Monnier |
4 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 4 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
4 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | MitchAlsup1 |
4 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Lynn Wheeler |
4 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Stefan Monnier |
31 May 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 42 | | John Savard |
31 May 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 41 | | John Levine |
1 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 31 | | John Savard |
1 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 20 | | Thomas Koenig |
2 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 6 | | John Savard |
2 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 5 | | Thomas Koenig |
2 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 3 | | John Levine |
3 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 2 | | OrangeFish |
3 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | John Levine |
4 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
4 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 13 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
5 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 12 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
5 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
6 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 10 | | George Neuner |
6 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 6 | | John Levine |
7 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 4 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
7 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 3 | | Stephen Fuld |
7 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 2 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
7 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Stephen Fuld |
7 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Terje Mathisen |
6 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Lynn Wheeler |
6 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | OrangeFish |
7 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
2 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 10 | | John Dallman |
2 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Michael S |
2 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | John Dallman |
4 Jun 24 | Re: architectural goals, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 7 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
30 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 49 | | Stephen Fuld |
30 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Anton Ertl |
30 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 2 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
30 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 4 | | Terje Mathisen |
30 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 7 | | Terje Mathisen |
28 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 3 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
12 May 24 | Re: python text, Byte Addressability And Beyond | 14 | | John Levine |
12 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 178 | | Thomas Koenig |
27 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
8 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | Michael S |
2 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 10 | | MitchAlsup1 |
2 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 3 | | Michael S |
2 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 18 | | Anton Ertl |
1 May 24 | Byte Order (was: Byte Addressability And Beyond) | 4 | | Anton Ertl |
1 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 17 | | Stefan Monnier |
1 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 40 | | MitchAlsup1 |
1 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 15 | | Thomas Koenig |
1 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 3 | | Michael S |
2 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 4 | | Lawrence D'Oliveiro |
3 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 75 | | Anton Ertl |
5 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 20 | | John Savard |
5 May 24 | Re: Byte Addressability And Beyond | 1 | | John Savard |