Re: Running an editor from ANSI C

Malcolm McLean <malcolm.arthur.mclean@gmail.com> writes:

On 06/06/2024 20:54, Keith Thompson wrote:

David Brown <david.brown@hesbynett.no> writes:

On 06/06/2024 10:27, Malcolm McLean wrote:

It does work. But my compiler warns about rmpnam() being deprecated.

>
I presume you mean "tmpnam()" here.  No, it has not been deprecated -
not even in C23.  I could be wrong, but this sounds like one of MSVC's
arbitrary self-declared deprecations, using scare tactics to encourage
people to use MSVC's own functions rather than standard C functions,
thus locking you into their tools and platform.

[...]
You're right, tmpnam() is not deprecated either by ISO C or by
POSIX.
But tmpfile() is likely to be better for most purposes.  It creates
a
file and returns a FILE*.  tmpnam() returns a string pointer, and it's
possible that some other process could create a file with the same name
before the caller has a chance to create it.
(mkstemp() is more flexible, but is not defined by ISO C.)
 

I want to run nano (or vi, or ed), in a shell running a pure ansi C
program. So the way to do it is to create a file, write the text you
want edit to it, them call system("nano readme.txt"). Nano then grabs
the  cobsole, which is what you want. You then read the file to get
the edited data.
>
The shell isn't just a proof og concept. It has a practical purpose,
because it is FileSystem XML file editor. Whilst I'm playing about
putting Basic into it for fun, the real purpose is serious. And the
user must have an easy way of editing text files in the FileSystem
file.
>
But it becomes effectively a virtual computer in its own right.

OK -- but that has nothing at all to do with my post, which was about
how to generate the temporary file name.

One suggestion: rather than always using nano (which not everyone is
familiar with), try reading the $EDITOR environment variable to
determine what editor to use.  Concatenating the value of
getenv("EDITOR"), followed by a space, followed by the file name, is
likely to give you a valid command you can pass to system().  Fall back
to nano if getenv("EDITOR") returns a null pointer.

(For historical reasons, the convention is to use $VISUAL if it's set,
otherwise $EDITOR if it's set, otherwise some default.  Originally
$VISUAL typically referred to a full-screen editor like vi and $EDITOR
to a line editor like ed, to be used when full-screen editing is not
available.  That's unlikely to be relevant nowadays, and users typically
either don't set $VISUAL or set it to the same thing as $EDITOR.)

Don't do this for me; I'm not likely to use this.  But others are likely
to find it more user-friendly if they can use a chosen editor.

--
Keith Thompson (The_Other_Keith) Keith.S.Thompson+u@gmail.com
void Void(void) { Void(); } /* The recursive call of the void */