Re: goto considered helpful (Was: question about linker)

Liste des GroupesRevenir à cl c  
Sujet : Re: goto considered helpful (Was: question about linker)
De : tr.17687 (at) *nospam* z991.linuxsc.com (Tim Rentsch)
Groupes : comp.lang.c
Date : 28. Dec 2024, 18:29:43
Autres entêtes
Organisation : A noiseless patient Spider
Message-ID : <861pxrd8c8.fsf@linuxsc.com>
References : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
User-Agent : Gnus/5.11 (Gnus v5.11) Emacs/22.4 (gnu/linux)
Rosario19 <Ros@invalid.invalid> writes:

On Tue, 24 Dec 2024 09:05:27 -0800, Tim Rentsch <> wrote:
>
In my view using goto should always be done on a case-by-case basis
and not under any general rule.  More specifically, when first
writing a function it should be written without using goto (which is
always possible).  If something about the code feels off, write it
another way, still without using goto.  Continue re-writing in this
way as long as the results are dissatisfying, up to perhaps four or
five versions (in some cases I have done a lot more than that).  In
many cases function bodies start off too large, and the code can be
simplified and clarified by breaking a function into several smaller
sub-functions;  doing that often removes any sense that goto is
needed.
>
in my vew
goto it is needed because all that high level language is traslated in
the end, in easy istructions that use goto

Goto is never necessary.  I have used at least three programming
languages that didn't have goto at all.  And that's not counting
unusual languages like Prolog.

Date Sujet#  Auteur
26 Nov 24 * question about linker382Thiago Adams
26 Nov 24 +* Re: question about linker16Thiago Adams
26 Nov 24 i`* Re: question about linker15Bart
26 Nov 24 i `* Re: question about linker14Thiago Adams
27 Nov 24 i  +* Re: question about linker2BGB
27 Nov 24 i  i`- Re: question about linker1Bart
27 Nov 24 i  +* Re: question about linker5David Brown
27 Nov 24 i  i`* Re: question about linker4Thiago Adams
27 Nov 24 i  i +* Re: question about linker2David Brown
27 Nov 24 i  i i`- Re: question about linker1Thiago Adams
2 Dec 24 i  i `- Re: question about linker1BGB
27 Nov 24 i  `* Re: question about linker6Michael S
27 Nov 24 i   `* Re: question about linker5Thiago Adams
27 Nov 24 i    `* Re: question about linker4Michael S
27 Nov 24 i     +- Re: question about linker1David Brown
28 Nov 24 i     +- Re: question about linker1Tim Rentsch
2 Dec 24 i     `- Re: question about linker1BGB
26 Nov 24 +* Re: question about linker20Bart
26 Nov 24 i`* Re: question about linker19Thiago Adams
26 Nov 24 i `* Re: question about linker18Bart
27 Nov 24 i  +* Re: question about linker3BGB
27 Nov 24 i  i`* Re: question about linker2fir
27 Nov 24 i  i `- Re: question about linker1BGB
27 Nov 24 i  `* Re: question about linker14Bart
27 Nov 24 i   +* Re: question about linker12Thiago Adams
27 Nov 24 i   i+- Re: question about linker1Thiago Adams
27 Nov 24 i   i`* Re: question about linker10Bart
27 Nov 24 i   i +* Re: question about linker6Bart
27 Nov 24 i   i i`* Re: question about linker5Thiago Adams
27 Nov 24 i   i i +* Re: question about linker3Thiago Adams
27 Nov 24 i   i i i`* Re: question about linker2Thiago Adams
27 Nov 24 i   i i i `- Re: question about linker1Bart
27 Nov 24 i   i i `- Re: question about linker1Bart
27 Nov 24 i   i `* Re: question about linker3Thiago Adams
27 Nov 24 i   i  `* Re: question about linker2Bart
27 Nov 24 i   i   `- Re: question about linker1Thiago Adams
28 Nov 24 i   `- Re: question about linker1Tim Rentsch
27 Nov 24 `* Re: question about linker345Waldek Hebisch
27 Nov 24  `* Re: question about linker344Thiago Adams
28 Nov 24   `* Re: question about linker343Keith Thompson
28 Nov 24    `* Re: question about linker342Thiago Adams
28 Nov 24     +* Re: question about linker337Bart
28 Nov 24     i`* Re: question about linker336Keith Thompson
29 Nov 24     i `* Re: question about linker335Bart
29 Nov 24     i  `* Re: question about linker334Keith Thompson
29 Nov 24     i   `* Re: question about linker333Bart
29 Nov 24     i    +* Re: question about linker3Keith Thompson
29 Nov 24     i    i`* Re: question about linker2Bart
29 Nov 24     i    i `- Re: question about linker1Keith Thompson
29 Nov 24     i    `* Re: question about linker329David Brown
29 Nov 24     i     `* Re: question about linker328Bart
29 Nov 24     i      +- Re: question about linker1Ike Naar
29 Nov 24     i      +* Re: question about linker325Michael S
29 Nov 24     i      i+* Re: question about linker322Bart
29 Nov 24     i      ii`* Re: question about linker321Michael S
29 Nov 24     i      ii +* Re: question about linker319David Brown
29 Nov 24     i      ii i`* Re: question about linker318Bart
29 Nov 24     i      ii i +* Re: question about linker164Keith Thompson
29 Nov 24     i      ii i i`* Re: question about linker163Bart
30 Nov 24     i      ii i i `* Re: question about linker162Keith Thompson
30 Nov 24     i      ii i i  +* Re: question about linker95Waldek Hebisch
30 Nov 24     i      ii i i  i+- Re: question about linker1Keith Thompson
30 Nov 24     i      ii i i  i+* Re: question about linker3James Kuyper
30 Nov 24     i      ii i i  ii`* Re: question about linker2Michael S
3 Dec 24     i      ii i i  ii `- Re: question about linker1Tim Rentsch
1 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i`* Re: question about linker90David Brown
1 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i +* Re: question about linker88Bart
1 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i`* Re: question about linker87David Brown
1 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i `* Re: question about linker86Bart
2 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i  `* Re: question about linker85David Brown
2 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i   `* Re: question about linker84Bart
2 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    +* Re: question about linker78David Brown
2 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    i+* Re: question about linker72Janis Papanagnou
2 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    ii+* Re: question about linker70Bart
2 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iii+* Re: question about linker68David Brown
2 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii`* Re: question about linker67Bart
3 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii `* Re: question about linker66David Brown
3 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  +* Re: question about linker53Bart
3 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i`* Re: question about linker52David Brown
3 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i `* Re: question about linker51Bart
4 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i  `* Re: question about linker50David Brown
4 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i   `* Re: question about linker49Bart
4 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i    `* Re: question about linker48David Brown
4 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     +* Re: question about linker24Bart
5 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     i`* Re: question about linker23David Brown
5 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     i +- Re: question about linker1Janis Papanagnou
5 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     i `* Re: question about linker21Bart
6 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     i  `* Re: question about linker20David Brown
6 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     i   `* Re: question about linker19Bart
6 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     i    +* Re: question about linker5Ike Naar
6 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     i    i+- Re: question about linker1Bart
7 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     i    i+- Re: question about linker1Keith Thompson
7 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     i    i`* Re: question about linker2Bart
7 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     i    i `- Re: question about linker1Keith Thompson
7 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     i    +* Re: question about linker10David Brown
7 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     i    i`* Re: question about linker9Bart
7 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     i    i `* Re: question about linker8David Brown
7 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     i    i  `* Re: question about linker7Bart
7 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     i    i   `* Re: question about linker6David Brown
7 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     i    i    `* Re: question about linker5Bart
8 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     i    i     +* Re: question about linker3Ben Bacarisse
8 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     i    i     `- Re: question about linker1David Brown
8 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     i    `* Re: question about linker3Waldek Hebisch
5 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     +* Re: question about linker15Waldek Hebisch
11 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  i     `* Re: question about linker8James Kuyper
3 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iiii  `* Re: question about linker12Bart
3 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    iii`- Re: question about linker1Janis Papanagnou
2 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    ii`- Re: question about linker1Bart
2 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    i`* Re: question about linker5Bart
4 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i i    `* Re: question about linker5Waldek Hebisch
1 Dec 24     i      ii i i  i `- Re: question about linker1Janis Papanagnou
30 Nov 24     i      ii i i  +* Re: question about linker44Bart
30 Nov 24     i      ii i i  +- Re: question about linker1Janis Papanagnou
1 Dec 24     i      ii i i  `* Re: question about linker21David Brown
30 Nov 24     i      ii i `* Re: question about linker153David Brown
5 Dec 24     i      ii `- Re: question about linker1Tim Rentsch
30 Nov 24     i      i`* Re: question about linker2Tim Rentsch
29 Nov 24     i      `- Re: question about linker1David Brown
28 Nov 24     `* Re: question about linker4Keith Thompson

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal