Re: Memory protection between compilation units?

Liste des GroupesRevenir à cl c  
Sujet : Re: Memory protection between compilation units?
De : mateusz (at) *nospam* x.invalid (Mateusz Viste)
Groupes : comp.lang.c
Date : 12. Jun 2025, 09:28:57
Autres entêtes
Organisation : ...
Message-ID : <20250612102857.1632c026@mateusz>
References : 1
User-Agent : Claws Mail 4.2.0 (GTK 3.24.43; x86_64-suse-linux-gnu)
Thank you all for your thoughtful responses. You rightly identified
that the problem is essentially an out-of-bounds access - a symptom of
deeper code quality issues. The bug in question managed to pass unit
tests, peer review, functional tests, and it didn’t trigger any
warnings from GCC or clang, even with the strict -Weverything flag I
enforce across my teams. This underscores a fundamental truth: every
software has bugs, and some, like this one, are notoriously difficult
to locate. The bug caused a segfault about once every 10 days,
manifesting in an unrelated part of the code and sometimes days after
the out-of-bounds write occurred.

This led me to wonder how I could accelerate such crashes to simplify
debugging. In large programs, unnoticed memory corruption becomes more
probable. One strategy is to break the program into modular parts that
communicate via IPC so programs would be protected from each other
thanks to the wonders of protected mode. However, this approach
sacrifices the efficiency and simplicity of function calls. A more
elegant solution would be to leverage the MMU to isolate the memory of
each compilation unit, triggering a segfault when a unit accesses
memory outside its scope. Unfortunately, such technology does not seem
to exist yet - at least not in the Linux world (which is my target
platform).

Mateusz


Date Sujet#  Auteur
11 Jun 25 * Memory protection between compilation units?53Mateusz Viste
11 Jun 25 +* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?6Josef Möllers
12 Jun 25 i+* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?2Michael S
13 Jun 25 ii`- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1Mateusz Viste
12 Jun 25 i`* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?3Richard Heathfield
16 Jun 25 i `* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?2Rosario19
16 Jun 25 i  `- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1Richard Heathfield
11 Jun 25 +- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1Lew Pitcher
11 Jun 25 +* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?3David Brown
12 Jun 25 i`* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?2Mateusz Viste
12 Jun 25 i `- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1David Brown
11 Jun 25 +* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?3Opus
11 Jun 25 i+- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1wij
12 Jun 25 i`- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1Mateusz Viste
11 Jun 25 +- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1Kaz Kylheku
12 Jun 25 +* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?21Mateusz Viste
12 Jun 25 i`* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?20Kaz Kylheku
13 Jun 25 i +* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?2Mateusz Viste
13 Jun 25 i i`- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1Kaz Kylheku
13 Jun 25 i `* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?17pozz
13 Jun 25 i  `* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?16Mateusz Viste
13 Jun 25 i   +* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?13Michael S
13 Jun 25 i   i+* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?2Richard Heathfield
14 Jun 25 i   ii`- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1Michael S
13 Jun 25 i   i+- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1Kaz Kylheku
14 Jun 25 i   i`* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?9Mateusz Viste
15 Jun 25 i   i `* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?8Waldek Hebisch
15 Jun 25 i   i  `* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?7Mateusz Viste
16 Jun 25 i   i   `* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?6Waldek Hebisch
16 Jun 25 i   i    +* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?3Kaz Kylheku
16 Jun 25 i   i    i`* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?2Waldek Hebisch
16 Jun 25 i   i    i `- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1James Kuyper
16 Jun 25 i   i    `* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?2Tim Rentsch
16 Jun 25 i   i     `- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1Waldek Hebisch
13 Jun 25 i   +- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1Kaz Kylheku
13 Jun 25 i   `- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1wij
12 Jun 25 +* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?2Mikko
12 Jun 25 i`- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1Mateusz Viste
12 Jun 25 +* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?10Tim Rentsch
13 Jun 25 i+* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?5Bonita Montero
13 Jun 25 ii`* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?4wij
13 Jun 25 ii +- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1Bonita Montero
13 Jun 25 ii `* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?2Keith Thompson
13 Jun 25 ii  `- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1Tim Rentsch
13 Jun 25 i`* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?4Mateusz Viste
14 Jun 25 i `* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?3Tim Rentsch
14 Jun 25 i  `* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?2Mateusz Viste
1 Jul17:54 i   `- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1Tim Rentsch
13 Jun 25 +* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?3Bonita Montero
13 Jun 25 i`* Re: Memory protection between compilation units?2Mateusz Viste
13 Jun 25 i `- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1Kaz Kylheku
16 Jun 25 +- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1Mateusz Viste
21 Jun 25 `- Re: Memory protection between compilation units?1olcott

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal