Re: MAP (and variants) vs LOOP - Popular opinion observation?

Nathan Baum wrote:

Then suppose you later need the loop/map to collect some of the values
under certain conditions. You might have
 
   (loop for x in (get-list)
         for i from 0
         do (format t "~A - ~A~%" i x)
         if (test x)
         collect (foo x))

newLISP

(let (result)
  (dolist (x '(2 9 22 25 42 49 58))
    (println (format "%d - %d" $idx x))
    (when (odd? x) (push (sqrt x) result -1)))
  result)

0 - 2
1 - 9
2 - 22
3 - 25
4 - 42
5 - 49
6 - 58
(3 5 7)