The error in Jan von Platos presentation (Re: Minimal Logics in the 2020's: A Meteoric Rise)

Liste des GroupesRevenir à cl prolog 
Sujet : The error in Jan von Platos presentation (Re: Minimal Logics in the 2020's: A Meteoric Rise)
De : janburse (at) *nospam* fastmail.fm (Mild Shock)
Groupes : comp.lang.prolog
Date : 13. Jul 2024, 10:33:07
Autres entêtes
Message-ID : <v6te42$j8a9$2@solani.org>
References : 1 2 3
User-Agent : Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64; rv:91.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/91.0 SeaMonkey/2.53.18.2
The sad news is, the book is only
worth some fire wood.
Plato (p. 83 of Elements of Logical Reasoning
Interestingly the book uses non-classical
logic, since it says:
 > Sequent calculus offers a good possibility for
 > exhaustive proof search in propositional logic:
 > We can check through all the possibilities for
 > malking a derivation. If none of them worked,
 > i.e., if each had at least one branch in which
 > no rule applied and no initial sequent was reached,
 > the given sequent is underivable. The
 > symbol |/-, is used for underivability.
And then it has unprovable:
c. |/- A v ~A
d. |/- ~~A => A
But mostlikely the book has a blind spot, some
serious errors, or totally unfounded claims, since
for example with such a calculus, the unprovability
of Peirce’s Law cannot be shown so easily.
Exhaustive proof search will usually not terminate.
There are some terminating calculi, like Dyckhoffs
LJT, but a naive calculus based on Gentzens take
will not terminate.

Date Sujet#  Auteur
4 Jul 24 * Minimal Logics in the 2020's: A Meteoric Rise (Was: The road to Artificial Intelligence)22Mild Shock
5 Jul 24 +* The curse of Negri & Plato (Was: Minimal Logics in the 2020's: A Meteoric Rise)3Mild Shock
5 Jul 24 i`* Re: The curse of Negri & Plato (Was: Minimal Logics in the 2020's: A Meteoric Rise)2Mild Shock
13 Jul 24 i `- Euklid: Am I a joke to you? (Re: The curse of Negri & Plato)1Mild Shock
5 Jul 24 +* Re: Minimal Logics in the 2020's: A Meteoric Rise (Was: The road to Artificial Intelligence)3Mild Shock
7 Jul 24 i`* Re: Minimal Logics in the 2020's: A Meteoric Rise (Was: The road to Artificial Intelligence)2Mild Shock
7 Jul 24 i `- Re: Minimal Logics in the 2020's: A Meteoric Rise (Was: The road to Artificial Intelligence)1Mild Shock
12 Jul 24 +* French Philosophy in 2024 (Was: Minimal Logics in the 2020's: A Meteoric Rise)4Mild Shock
12 Jul 24 i`* Re: French Philosophy in 2024 (Was: Minimal Logics in the 2020's: A Meteoric Rise)3Mild Shock
12 Jul 24 i +- Corona isn't over 2024 (Was: French Philosophy in 2024)1Mild Shock
12 Jul 24 i `- Re: Corona isn't over 2024 (Was: French Philosophy in 2024)1Mild Shock
13 Jul 24 +* The error in Jan von Platos presentation (Re: Minimal Logics in the 2020's: A Meteoric Rise)4Mild Shock
13 Jul 24 i`* Re: The error in Jan von Platos presentation (Re: Minimal Logics in the 2020's: A Meteoric Rise)3Mild Shock
14 Jul 24 i `* Re: The error in Jan von Platos presentation (Re: Minimal Logics in the 2020's: A Meteoric Rise)2Mild Shock
14 Jul 24 i  `- Re: The error in Jan von Platos presentation (Re: Minimal Logics in the 2020's: A Meteoric Rise)1Mild Shock
22 Jul 24 +- Distinction between Computation & Derivation (Was: Minimal Logics in the 2020's: A Meteoric Rise)1Mild Shock
31 Jul 24 +* Prolegomena by Rappaport (Re: Minimal Logics in the 2020's: A Meteoric Rise (Was: The road to Artificial Intelligence))5Mild Shock
3 Aug 24 i`* 2nd Cognitive Turn ~~> no Bayesian Brain (Re: Prolegomena by Rappaport)4Mild Shock
3 Aug 24 i `* Ok I made a joke, sorry (e: 2nd Cognitive Turn ~~> no Bayesian Brain)3Mild Shock
3 Aug 24 i  `* Re: Ok I made a joke, sorry (e: 2nd Cognitive Turn ~~> no Bayesian Brain)2Mild Shock
4 Aug 24 i   `- bullshit bullshit bullshit (Re: Ok I made a joke, sorry)1Mild Shock
4 Aug 24 `- The two rules (Was: Minimal Logics in the 2020's: A Meteoric Rise)1Mild Shock

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal