On 3/9/25 10:30 AM, Sn!pe wrote:
> c186282 <
c186282@nnada.net> wrote:
>
>> On 3/8/25 3:55 PM, Dan Espen wrote:
>>>
scott@slp53.sl.home (Scott Lurndal) writes:
>>>
>>>> rbowman <
bowman@montana.com> writes:
>>>>> On Sat, 8 Mar 2025 00:21:15 -0500, c186282 wrote:
>>>>
>>>>> Relay logic was sort of fun. You were building state machines with relays,
>>>>> Eagle Signal electro-mechanical timers, limit switches, and so forth. I
>>>>> never did it but even more fascinating were some of the complex machines
>>>>> that were all cams, levers, gears, and springs except for the drive
>>>>> motor.
>>>>
>>>> I use and repair relay logic even in these digital times:
>>>>
>>>>
https://pinside.com/pinball/machine/target-pool >>>
>>> That Target Pool looks a bit like my Jacks Open.
>>>
>>> I bought the Jacks Open and realized that as a home game, scoring special
>>> just awarded credits. Since we were playing at home credits were
>>> meaningless. The game had no Extra Ball feature.
>>>
>>> I figured out what kind of relay I needed, drilled a hole between the
>>> flippers put a light there, and wired in the relay. I was always struck
>>> at how much like programming the wiring and relays were like. I still
>>> play the game.
>>
>>
>> Contemplate how similar electrics and PLUMBING are :-)
>>
>> Hmmmm ... betcha a 'hydraulic CPU' really could be made ...
>>
>> I did find something long back, the equiv of a 'hydraulic
>> transformer' - high-pressure/low-volume to low-pressure/
>> high volume. Likely the reverse is possible without too
>> much complication. An oscillator using an air-chamber,
>> the 'capacitor', and proper flow resistance to tune
>> resonance freq and ....... :-)
>>
>> If I had to explain electrics to someone from the
>> Roman empire days, I'd use plumbing analogies.
>>
>
> It's been done:
>
> <
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phillips_Machine>
That's a fascinating bit of tech ! Wonder why he
used fluids instead of electrics ? Analog electronic
computing had been around for a long time. Maybe
ya just couldn't get enough steps into a sim with
electrics before there was doom from complexity
and error-amplification ?
In any case, I think a DIGITAL CPU could also be
made. Wouldn't have to be much, like a PIC-12xxx
or something. Put it under a 100-ft square glass
floor in some big tech center/museum so everyone
can watch it do its thing (very slowly). A couple
of user inputs of course, so they can watch their
stuff flitter through the whole system. Would need
some kind of display - hydraulic serial LCD.
It'd be ultra-cool.
I think MIT built at least part of a Babbage
Difference Engine - I've seen vids of all the
little brass gears and cogs working - hypnotic.
DID see pix once of a guy who built a Z-80 inside
his house, from discrete transistors. Took up
three walls .....