Re: Paying to avoid cookeies?

On Wed, 14 Aug 2024 10:22:17 +0100, JAB <noway@nochance.com> wrote:

Well at least it's computer related, so I read something that the online
version of The Daily Express newspaper have introduced a model that
allows you either to read it for free but then you must accept being
tracked with cookies or pay a subscription of £2 per-month to avoid
them. There have been some comments about whether that's allowed under
GDPR (the UK is still signed up although I'm surprised our last
government didn't scrap it as party of EU meddling*) and why on earth
would any pay to read that awful rag**?
>
Putting those aside my first thought was that's ridiculous but my second
thought was why is it if you're getting a service for free then is it
really that unreasonable to make you pay for it indirectly in the same
way you can pay not to see ad's. So yeh why not although maybe it's a
sign of things to come?

It is a completely illegal request however. The GDPR (of which the UK
remains a signatory and have accepted as law, even if they have
withdrawn from the EU) says that the choice offered end-users must be
freely given, and must be given without any significant drawbacks. "No
cookies == no see website" is in clear violation. It doesn't matter if
there is a "you can pay to avoid cookies" option either. The only real
exception is for 1st-party cookies (e.g., cookies set by the website
you are actually visiting) used for 'essential' purposes such as
log-in or keeping track of what page you're viewing. The GPDR very
specifically bars so-called "cookie walls" where you can't see the
site's content unless you allow all the cookies.

What those websites are doing is blatantly against the GDPR and if
they are doing business in EU or the UK, they can be held accountable
for this violation. Fines are harsh too; €20 million Euro or 4% of
yearly worldwide revenue, whichever is higher. Feel free to submit a
complaint to ICO (the UK data protection agency) https://ico.org.uk/
or CNIL (for the rest of the EU) https://www.cnil.fr/en/home if you
happen to reside in either of those two regions (sorry 'Merkins,
you're shit outta luck, since there are no privacy protection laws for
you!)