Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly

Liste des GroupesRevenir à c theory 
Sujet : Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly
De : F.Zwarts (at) *nospam* HetNet.nl (Fred. Zwarts)
Groupes : comp.theory
Date : 31. Jul 2024, 09:56:38
Autres entêtes
Organisation : A noiseless patient Spider
Message-ID : <v8cu86$1gbu7$6@dont-email.me>
References : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
User-Agent : Mozilla Thunderbird
Op 30.jul.2024 om 23:13 schreef olcott:
On 7/30/2024 4:07 PM, joes wrote:
Am Tue, 30 Jul 2024 15:05:54 -0500 schrieb olcott:
On 7/30/2024 1:48 PM, Fred. Zwarts wrote:
Op 30.jul.2024 om 17:14 schreef olcott:
On 7/30/2024 9:51 AM, Fred. Zwarts wrote:
Op 30.jul.2024 om 16:21 schreef olcott:
On 7/30/2024 1:52 AM, Mikko wrote:
On 2024-07-29 14:07:53 +0000, olcott said:
>
HHH(Infinite_Recursion) and HHH(DDD) show the same non-halting
behavior pattern in their derived execution traces of their
inputs.
Hard to believe as their behaviour is so different and you don't
say what pattern the see.
>
*Its all in the part that you erased*
>
We all see the differences between these two.
>
They both correctly predict behavior that must be aborted to prevent
the infinite execution of the simulating halt decider.
>
Except that the prediction for the second one is wrong. The simulation
of an aborting and halting function, like HHH, does not need to be
aborted.
I proved otherwise. When the abort code is commented out then it keeps
repeating again and again, thus conclusively proving that is must be
aborted or HHH never halts.
But the abort is not commented out in the running code!
>
 I modified the original code by commenting out
the abort and it does endlessly repeat just like
HHH correctly predicted.
 
So you proved that it can only produce a correct prediction for another input: the HHH that does not halt.
But when it must predict the behaviour of HHH that aborts and halts, it fails.
You think that is correct, because you are still dreaming of that other HHH that does not halt. Dreams are no substitute for logic proofs.

Date Sujet#  Auteur
29 Jul 24 * Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see...78olcott
29 Jul 24 +* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see...5Fred. Zwarts
29 Jul 24 i`* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see...4olcott
29 Jul 24 i `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see...3Fred. Zwarts
29 Jul 24 i  `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see...2olcott
30 Jul 24 i   `- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see...1Fred. Zwarts
30 Jul 24 +- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... DDD will HALT if HHH answers1Richard Damon
30 Jul 24 `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see...71Mikko
30 Jul 24  `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see...70olcott
30 Jul 24   +* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see...57Fred. Zwarts
30 Jul 24   i`* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly56olcott
30 Jul 24   i `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly55Fred. Zwarts
30 Jul 24   i  `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly54olcott
30 Jul 24   i   +* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly51joes
30 Jul 24   i   i`* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly50olcott
31 Jul 24   i   i +* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly25Mad Hamish
31 Jul 24   i   i i`* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly24olcott
1 Aug 24   i   i i `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly23wij
1 Aug 24   i   i i  `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly22olcott
1 Aug 24   i   i i   +* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly7wij
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i+* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly2olcott
1 Aug 24   i   i i   ii`- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly1wij
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i`* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly4Mikko
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly3olcott
2 Aug 24   i   i i   i  +- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict *IN*correctly1Richard Damon
2 Aug 24   i   i i   i  `- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly1Mikko
1 Aug 24   i   i i   +* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly11Fred. Zwarts
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i`* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly10olcott
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i +* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly7Fred. Zwarts
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i i`* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly6olcott
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i i +- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly1Fred. Zwarts
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i i `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly4joes
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i i  `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly3olcott
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i i   `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly2joes
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i i    `- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly1olcott
2 Aug 24   i   i i   i +- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict INcorrectly1Richard Damon
2 Aug 24   i   i i   i `- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly1Mikko
1 Aug 24   i   i i   `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly is to say Halting,3Richard Damon
1 Aug 24   i   i i    `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly is to say Halting,2olcott
2 Aug 24   i   i i     `- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly is to say Halting,1Richard Damon
31 Jul 24   i   i +- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly1Richard Damon
31 Jul 24   i   i +* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly22joes
31 Jul 24   i   i i`* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly21olcott
31 Jul 24   i   i i +- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict INcorrectly1Richard Damon
31 Jul 24   i   i i `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly19joes
31 Jul 24   i   i i  `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly18olcott
31 Jul 24   i   i i   +* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly16joes
31 Jul 24   i   i i   i`* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly15olcott
31 Jul 24   i   i i   i `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly14Fred. Zwarts
31 Jul 24   i   i i   i  `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly13olcott
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i   +* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly7joes
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i   i`* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly6olcott
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i   i `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly5Fred. Zwarts
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i   i  `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly4olcott
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i   i   `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly3Fred. Zwarts
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i   i    `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly2olcott
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i   i     `- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly1Fred. Zwarts
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i   `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly5Fred. Zwarts
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i    `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly4olcott
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i     `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly3Fred. Zwarts
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i      `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly2olcott
1 Aug 24   i   i i   i       `- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly1Fred. Zwarts
1 Aug 24   i   i i   `- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... H predicts INcorrectly1Richard Damon
31 Jul 24   i   i `- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly1Fred. Zwarts
31 Jul 24   i   +- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict INcorrectly1Richard Damon
31 Jul 24   i   `- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... predict correctly1Fred. Zwarts
31 Jul 24   +- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see...1Richard Damon
31 Jul 24   `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see...11Mikko
31 Jul 24    +* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see...4Mikko
31 Jul 24    i`* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see...3olcott
1 Aug 24    i +- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... The H incorrectly decides on the input.1Richard Damon
2 Aug 24    i `- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see...1Mikko
31 Jul 24    `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see...6olcott
1 Aug 24     +- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see... H predicts incorrectly1Richard Damon
2 Aug 24     `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see...4Mikko
2 Aug 24      `* Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see...3olcott
2 Aug 24       +- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see...1Richard Damon
3 Aug 24       `- Re: Any honest person that knows the x86 language can see...1Mikko

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal