Re: MODERATOR (NOT MODERATORS?) FOUND for rec.photo.moderated, comp.std.announce, comp.newprod, and comp.simulation

In <MPG.42b54d916dd18e09896f4@news.eternal-september.org> Big-8 Management Board <board@big-8.org> writes:

REPLACEMENT MODERATOR FOUND
rec.photo.moderated

The Big-8 Management Board is pleased to announce that Ivan Shmakov has
volunteered to take on moderation duties for rec.photo.moderated.

In <MPG.42b54e792ebe45e59896f5@news.eternal-september.org> Big-8 Management Board <board@big-8.org> writes:

REPLACEMENT MODERATOR FOUND
comp.std.announce

The Big-8 Management Board is pleased to announce that Ivan Shmakov has
volunteered to take on moderation duties for comp.std.announce.

In <MPG.42b54ff3bf9863519896f7@news.eternal-september.org> Big-8 Management Board <board@big-8.org> writes:

REPLACEMENT MODERATOR FOUND
comp.newprod

The Big-8 Management Board is pleased to announce that Ivan Shmakov has
volunteered to take on moderation duties for comp.newprod.

In <MPG.42b54f6af1452af69896f6@news.eternal-september.org> Big-8 Management Board <board@big-8.org> writes:

REPLACEMENT MODERATOR FOUND
comp.simulation

The Big-8 Management Board is pleased to announce that Ivan Shmakov has
volunteered to take on moderation duties for comp.simulation.

OK, so a single moderator for each newsgroup, and the same moderator
for all of these newsgroups?  I don't doubt Ivan's sincerity, good
intentions, and likely technical skills, but I thought that this was the
kind of risky moderation model that we were trying to get away from
during past Moderator Vacancy Investigations.

There may also be some lessons-learned from the analogous experiences of
Brian Edmonds in the aughts and tens (2000's and 2010's), for example.
He identified many inactive newsgroups, offered to moderate them, set up
moderation services, and offered these services to other newsgroups
(Robomod).  Some newsgroups prospered, some didn't, and when he left
Usenet, all of these newsgroups managed with his now inactive services
were left high and dry.  Some transferred to other moderation services,
some went dormant.  In the archives is some discussion over the years,
including expression of concerns about the future, whether Brian was
either biting off more than he could chew or assuming too much power
over large numbers of newsgroups, and which mostly predicted the
eventual outcome.

For newsgroup viability and longevity, should we be making an effort to
find multiple, independent, moderation teams and services across
newsgroups, ensure constituencies to populate those newsgroups with
participation, and develop contingency plans in advance should those
moderators need to be replaced?  Is four moderated newsgroups enough for
one moderator (Ian) and should we try to recruit others?

--
Paul W. Schleck
pschleck@panix.com