Re: 1st RfD: Mass-deletion of moderated groups without a moderator

On Mon, 10 Feb 2025 08:09:45 -0500, Marco Moock wrote:

On 09.02.2025 22:13 Uhr noel wrote:
 

That's not to say other news servers, in particular the closed,
posting_registration_reqd and paid servers have not honored the
rmgroups, as I obviously can't test them, nor all open read access
servers.
 
Tested: rec.arts.comics.info / rec.radio.broadcasting /
rec.arts.comics.reviews

 
Can you give the names of the servers that didn't process the messages?

What, so you can use it as a backdoor method to have them remove the
groups? Did you consider that I'm not the only server operator who
disagrees with the way you are handling this and have set control
rmgroups for big8 to Log/Email only?

We've already seen groups with recent articles you cant see because your
server has no articles that you want to get rid of, and its not our job
to check and dispute every group, its the big8 board members job to use
multiple sources to verify these things.

if it is a groupname foo dot moderated - then fair enough, but anything
else, I made my position clear on, just unmoderate them, you chose not to
and issued rmgroup cmsg's.

There are not too many known open access servers around so its not hard
to see who thy are, my script has no logins to provate servers, it can
see what anyone else can.

There was some discussion about verification failure for those messages,
so there might be a technical issue.

uhu. Or they disagree with the decisions being made.