Re: From the Archives .....

Liste des GroupesRevenir à ra drwho 
Sujet : Re: From the Archives .....
De : agamemnon (at) *nospam* hello.to.NO_SPAM (The True Doctor)
Groupes : rec.arts.drwho
Date : 23. Apr 2024, 12:42:36
Autres entêtes
Organisation : A noiseless patient Spider
Message-ID : <v086rc$1jlmd$2@dont-email.me>
References : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
User-Agent : Mozilla Thunderbird
On 21/04/2024 19:59, Blueshirt wrote:
The True Doctor wrote:
 
On 21/04/2024 01:21, Blueshirt wrote:
The Doctor wrote:
>
I go with 4 Doctors taking on Morbius!
>
You can take from that scene whatever you like... it doesn't
change the way the scene was conceived. There is no Doctor
Who bible so whatever works for you and your enjoyment of
the show is fine. We are all free to make our own
head-canon.
>
What there is are established facts. No regenerations existed
before Hartnell as stated by Hartnell in The Tenth Planet and
the 1st Doctor in The Five Doctors. What transpired in The
Brain of Morbius can only be interpreted one way, the faces
viewers did not recognise were those of Morbius, just as
Terrance Dicks states in the Target novelization.
 At the time, the kiddies didn't know that. Uncle Terrance's "The
At the time the kiddies all figured it out by themselves. When the Doctor was winning his face appeared on the screen. When you didn't recognise his face then it was obviously that of Morbius or his previous incarnations since his mind was clearly stronger.
This of course assumed that everyone watching has seen Robot or the end of Planet of the Spiders which established regeneration and the kiddies parents knew that Hartnell was the first Doctor otherwise most of the kiddies would have only recognised the faces of Tom Baker and Jon Pertwee.

Brain of Morbius" Target novel wasn't published until a year or
two later. So the BBC1 viewers of the day would have seen the
Doctor's faces on the screen go 4 -> 3 -> 2 -> 1 -> then a few
more faces... so they could easily have interpreted it as they
were the faces of the Doctor. (As intended by Phillip
Hinchcliffe.)
Terrance Dicks wrote the story and that was never his intention nor the intention of the director, since the visual symbolism implies that the person whose face is on the screen is the one who is winning, just like a camera follows the lead runner running a marathon when they near the finish line or a quiz show focuses on the contestant who is currently active or gives the right answer.
Imagine that both Time Lords had never regenerated before, since this was supposed to be a Gallyfreyan children's game. Who's face would have been displayed on the screen? Natural logic dictates that it's the face of the one who is winning. There wasn't even any sign of whinging in the facts shown on screen so clearly they were not in plain because they were losing. They were the faces of the Time Lord who was winning.

 Some children in 1976 wouldn't have been around to see any
William Hartnell episodes as a reference. We all watched Doctor
No, but my mum had watched William Hartnell before and knew he was the first actor to play the Doctor.

Who 'fresh' back then in the 1970's, with no repeat viewings,
videos or internet. A ten year old child in front of the
television in 1976 isn't going to know or care about established
"facts" that you maintain existed.
A 6 year old child in front of the TV is going to figure out from the start that the person whose face is on the screen is the one who is winning. The Doctor lost and died. All the faces after Tom Baker may as well have been those of Morbius to the uninitiated.

 Or care that the producers of a TV show can change things to
suit themselves if they want to, like our friend Mr Chibnall
chose to do with Doctor Ruth!
Stop insulting the intelligence of the audience. Even a 6 year old child knows more about story writing and can write better Doctor Who episodes than Chris Chibnall.
Doctor Who ended in 2017 since the character of the main protagonist stopped being that of the Doctor.
--
The True Doctor https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCngrZwoS0n21IRcXpKO79Lw
"To be woke is to be uninformed which is exactly the opposite of what it stands for." -William Shatner

Date Sujet#  Auteur
19 Apr 24 * From the Archives .....132Daniel70
19 Apr 24 +* Re: From the Archives .....119The True Doctor
19 Apr 24 i+* Re: From the Archives .....22The True Doctor
21 Apr 24 ii`* Re: From the Archives .....21The True Doctor
22 Apr 24 ii `* Re: From the Archives .....20Daniel70
23 Apr 24 ii  +- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
24 Apr 24 ii  `* Re: From the Archives .....18The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 ii   +* Re: From the Archives .....2Idlehands
25 Apr 24 ii   i`- Re: From the Archives .....1Idlehands
25 Apr 24 ii   `* Re: From the Archives .....15Daniel70
26 Apr 24 ii    +* Re: From the Archives .....2The True Doctor
26 Apr 24 ii    i`- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
26 Apr 24 ii    +* Re: From the Archives .....4The True Doctor
26 Apr 24 ii    i`* Re: From the Archives .....3The True Doctor
28 Apr 24 ii    i `* Re: From the Archives .....2The True Doctor
28 Apr 24 ii    i  `- Re: From the Archives .....1solar penguin
26 Apr 24 ii    +* Re: From the Archives .....4The True Doctor
26 Apr 24 ii    i+* Re: From the Archives .....2Idlehands
26 Apr 24 ii    ii`- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
26 Apr 24 ii    i`- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
26 Apr 24 ii    +- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
26 Apr 24 ii    `* Re: From the Archives .....3Daniel70
26 Apr 24 ii     `* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70
27 Apr 24 ii      `- Re: From the Archives .....1Idlehands
19 Apr 24 i+* Re: From the Archives .....2The True Doctor
20 Apr 24 ii`- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
20 Apr 24 i`* Re: From the Archives .....94The Last Doctor
20 Apr 24 i +* Re: From the Archives .....7The Last Doctor
20 Apr 24 i i`* Re: From the Archives .....6The Last Doctor
21 Apr 24 i i `* Re: From the Archives .....5The Last Doctor
21 Apr 24 i i  +- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
21 Apr 24 i i  `* Re: From the Archives .....3The Last Doctor
22 Apr 24 i i   `* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70
23 Apr 24 i i    `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
20 Apr 24 i `* Re: From the Archives .....86The True Doctor
21 Apr 24 i  +* Re: From the Archives .....6The True Doctor
22 Apr 24 i  i+- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
22 Apr 24 i  i+* Re: From the Archives .....3Daniel70
22 Apr 24 i  ii`* Re: From the Archives .....2The True Doctor
23 Apr 24 i  ii `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
22 Apr 24 i  i`- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
21 Apr 24 i  +* Re: From the Archives .....78The True Doctor
22 Apr 24 i  i+* Re: From the Archives .....16Daniel70
23 Apr 24 i  ii+- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
23 Apr 24 i  ii`* Re: From the Archives .....14The True Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  ii +* Re: From the Archives .....11The Last Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  ii i+* Re: From the Archives .....5The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  ii ii`* Re: From the Archives .....4The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  ii ii `* Re: From the Archives .....3Daniel70
25 Apr 24 i  ii ii  `* Re: From the Archives .....2solar penguin
26 Apr 24 i  ii ii   `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
24 Apr 24 i  ii i+* Re: From the Archives .....2The Last Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  ii ii`- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  ii i+- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  ii i`* Re: From the Archives .....2The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  ii i `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
24 Apr 24 i  ii +- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  ii `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
23 Apr 24 i  i`* Re: From the Archives .....61The True Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  i +* Re: From the Archives .....59The Last Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  i i`* Re: From the Archives .....58The True Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  i i +* Re: From the Archives .....47The Last Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  i i i+* Re: From the Archives .....45The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  i i ii`* Re: From the Archives .....44The Last Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  i i ii +* Re: From the Archives .....24The True Doctor
26 Apr 24 i  i i ii i`* Re: From the Archives .....23The Last Doctor
26 Apr 24 i  i i ii i `* Re: From the Archives .....22The True Doctor
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii i  `* Re: From the Archives .....21Blueshirt
28 Apr 24 i  i i ii i   `* Re: From the Archives .....20The True Doctor
28 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    +* Re: From the Archives .....6The Last Doctor
28 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    i+* Re: From the Archives .....4The True Doctor
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    ii+- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    ii`* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    ii `- Re: From the Archives .....1Idlehands
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    i`- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
28 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    +- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    `* Re: From the Archives .....12The True Doctor
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     +* Re: From the Archives .....7Idlehands
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i`* Re: From the Archives .....6The True Doctor
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i `* Re: From the Archives .....5Idlehands
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i  `* Re: From the Archives .....4The True Doctor
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i   `* Re: From the Archives .....3Idlehands
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i    `* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i     `- Re: From the Archives .....1Idlehands
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     +* Re: From the Archives .....3The True Doctor
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i`* Re: From the Archives .....2solar penguin
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i `- Re: From the Archives .....1solar penguin
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
25 Apr 24 i  i i ii `* Re: From the Archives .....19The True Doctor
26 Apr 24 i  i i ii  +* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70
26 Apr 24 i  i i ii  i`- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii  +* Re: From the Archives .....6Idlehands
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii  i+- Re: From the Archives .....1Idlehands
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii  i`* Re: From the Archives .....4Blueshirt
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii  i +* Re: From the Archives .....2Idlehands
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii  i i`- Re: From the Archives .....1%
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii  i `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii  `* Re: From the Archives .....10The True Doctor
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii   +* Re: From the Archives .....5Daniel70
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii   i`* Re: From the Archives .....4Daniel70
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii   i `* Re: From the Archives .....3Daniel70
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii   `* Re: From the Archives .....4The True Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  i i i`- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  i i `* Re: From the Archives .....10solar penguin
24 Apr 24 i  i `- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
21 Apr 24 i  `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
22 Apr 24 +* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70
23 Apr 24 +- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
27 Apr 24 +- Re: From the Archives .....1Blueshirt
30 Apr 24 +* Re: From the Archives .....5Daniel70
30 Apr 24 +- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
1 May 24 `* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal