Re: The Lemonade Treatment

Liste des GroupesRevenir à ra drwho 
Sujet : Re: The Lemonade Treatment
De : mouth (at) *nospam* onlegs.org (Agent Jakanov)
Groupes : rec.arts.drwho
Date : 16. Mar 2024, 22:41:20
Autres entêtes
Organisation : TWA
Message-ID : <ut505f$32t95$1@dont-email.me>
References : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
User-Agent : Xnews/5.04.25
"Blueshirt" <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote in news:xn0ojegjy43nyxt003
@reader.xsnews.nl:

Mickmane wrote:
 
On 16.03.24, Blueshirt  <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
Agent Jakanov wrote:
 
Regeneration crises are almost a tradition in Doctor Who.
At least they tried to do something different with it, even
if the execution was lacking.
 
Well, it certainly was different to what other Doctors went
through post-regeneration.
 
Now, if the Fifth Doctor had strangled Adric...
 
Why strangle Adric?
 
Why not? He was more annoying than Peri and JNT thought that was
a good idea!

What's the motivation for it, from the writing standpoint?  In the case
of Peri, the Doctor was subconsciously aware that she was indirectly
responsible for his previous incarnation's death, and he was triggered
by her name, which alluded to a supernatural being in Persian mythology
which was at one time "evil".

Also, it would have saved time and money on having to arrange a
space freighter to crash in to Earth just to get rid of him! :-)

So strangled all the way to death?  The idea of the Doctor going all the
way with Adric is just... wrong.

That said, it was implied in the very first episode An Unearthly Child
that Barbara and Ian feared he was child abuser.





Date Sujet#  Auteur
13 Mar 24 * The Lemonade Treatment45Agent Jakanov
13 Mar 24 +- Re: The Lemonade Treatment1Daniel65
13 Mar 24 +- Re: The Lemonade Treatment1Mich
13 Mar 24 +* Re: The Lemonade Treatment32Mickmane
14 Mar 24 i+* Re: The Lemonade Treatment28Mickmane
15 Mar 24 ii+* Re: The Lemonade Treatment25Agent Jakanov
16 Mar 24 iii`* Re: The Lemonade Treatment24Agent Jakanov
16 Mar 24 iii +* Re: The Lemonade Treatment9Agent Jakanov
16 Mar 24 iii i+* Re: The Lemonade Treatment2Blueshirt
16 Mar 24 iii ii`- Re: The Lemonade Treatment1Agent Jakanov
16 Mar 24 iii i`* Re: The Lemonade Treatment6Agent Jakanov
16 Mar 24 iii i `* Re: The Lemonade Treatment5Agent Jakanov
16 Mar 24 iii i  +- Re: The Lemonade Treatment1Agent Jakanov
17 Mar 24 iii i  `* Re: The Lemonade Treatment3Daniel65
17 Mar 24 iii i   `* Re: The Lemonade Treatment2Daniel65
18 Mar 24 iii i    `- Re: The Lemonade Treatment1Daniel65
16 Mar 24 iii `* Re: The Lemonade Treatment14Blueshirt
16 Mar 24 iii  +- Re: The Lemonade Treatment1Agent Jakanov
16 Mar 24 iii  +- Re: The Lemonade Treatment1Agent Jakanov
16 Mar 24 iii  `* Re: The Lemonade Treatment11Mickmane
16 Mar 24 iii   +* Re: The Lemonade Treatment2Agent Jakanov
18 Mar 24 iii   i`- Re: The Lemonade Treatment1Daniel65
17 Mar 24 iii   +- Re: The Lemonade Treatment1Daniel65
17 Mar 24 iii   `* Re: The Lemonade Treatment7Mickmane
18 Mar 24 iii    +* Re: The Lemonade Treatment3Daniel65
19 Mar 24 iii    i`* Re: The Lemonade Treatment2Daniel65
20 Mar 24 iii    i `- Re: The Lemonade Treatment1Daniel65
18 Mar 24 iii    `* Re: The Lemonade Treatment3Mickmane
19 Mar 24 iii     `* Re: The Lemonade Treatment2Blueshirt
19 Mar 24 iii      `- Re: The Lemonade Treatment1The Last Doctor
16 Mar 24 ii`* Re: The Lemonade Treatment2Mickmane
16 Mar 24 ii `- Re: The Lemonade Treatment1Agent Jakanov
15 Mar 24 i`* Re: The Lemonade Treatment3Agent Jakanov
16 Mar 24 i +- Re: The Lemonade Treatment1Agent Jakanov
16 Mar 24 i `- Re: The Lemonade Treatment1Mickmane
15 Mar 24 +- Re: The Lemonade Treatment1Agent Jakanov
18 Mar 24 `* Re: The Lemonade Treatment9The Last Doctor
18 Mar 24  +* Re: The Lemonade Treatment2Daniel65
19 Mar 24  i`- Re: The Lemonade Treatment1Daniel65
18 Mar 24  `* Re: The Lemonade Treatment6The Last Doctor
19 Mar 24   +- Re: The Lemonade Treatment1The Last Doctor
19 Mar 24   `* Re: The Lemonade Treatment4Daniel65
19 Mar 24    `* Re: The Lemonade Treatment3The Last Doctor
19 Mar 24     +- Re: The Lemonade Treatment1The Last Doctor
20 Mar 24     `- Re: The Lemonade Treatment1Daniel65

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal