Re: From the Archives .....

Liste des GroupesRevenir à ra drwho 
Sujet : Re: From the Archives .....
De : agamemnon (at) *nospam* hello.to.NO_SPAM (The True Doctor)
Groupes : rec.arts.drwho
Date : 27. Apr 2024, 02:42:04
Autres entêtes
Organisation : A noiseless patient Spider
Message-ID : <v0hl5d$met$3@dont-email.me>
References : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
User-Agent : Mozilla Thunderbird
On 26/04/2024 12:35, Blueshirt wrote:
The True Doctor wrote:
 
On 25/04/2024 15:01, Blueshirt wrote:
>
Doctor Who history features a pre-First Doctor incarnation
now, and right or wrong - or until it's rewritten by another
Doctor Who showrunner at some stage in the future - that is
the way it is.
>
There are no incarnations of the Doctor before Hartnell.
 Apart from the one that appeared in Doctor Who recently of
course.
No. Doctor Who ended in 2017. There are no incarnations of the Doctor before Hartnell.

 I know it must hurt, but unfortunately it is part of the show.
 
No it isn't. Doctor Who ended in 2017.

Don't shoot the messenger!
 
Doctor Ruth/The Fugitive Doctor exists in episodes of Doctor
Who as broadcast on BBC1 and has her own range of Big Finish
audio adventures coming next year, licensed and approved by
the BBC.
>
Big Finish is not canon and neither is Doctor Ruth, unless you
mean the psychologist.
>
Officially non-canon.
 There is no official Doctor Who canon. So therefore there can be
Yes there is. William Hartnell is the first Doctor and there are no incarnations of the Doctor before him. This is canon set and reinforced by The Unearthly Child, The Tenth Planet, Power of the Daleks, The War Games, Spearhead from Space, The Three Doctors, Planet of the Spiders, Robot, The Brain of Morbius, The Deadly Assassin, The Underworld, The Invasion of Time, The Keeper of Traken, Logopolis, Mawdrin Undead, The Five Doctors, The Caves of Androzani, Time and the Rani, the TVM, The Family of Blood, The Next Doctor, The End of Time, The Eleventh Hour, almost every single episode featuring the 11th Doctor onwards, The Name of the Doctor, The Night of the Doctor, The Day of the Doctor, The Time of the Doctor, Listen, and Twice Upon A Time.

no official non-canon. BUT, if there was such a thing as Doctor
Who canon, the Fugitive Doctor would be considered part of it!
No they wouldn't as they would contradict all the above episodes and ask for belief in a totally unbelievably conspiracy theory which erases all Doctor Who continuity entirely and replaces it with something completely different. No one in their right mind would believe such a thing, just like no one in this group accepted War of the Daleks except John Peel who write it, and the retcon of the entire series required by the Timeless Child monster is infinitely worse beyond measure.

As the people who do claim there is a canon usually mean what is
seen on-screen in an episode of Doctor Who.
 
The ones claiming incarnations before Hartnell are
hallucinating and smoking opium.
 Or they have watched Doctor Who in recent years and seen a
pre-Hartnell incarnation.
There has never been a pre-Hartnell incarnation. William Hartnell is the First and Original Doctor as stated in The Five Doctors and is implicit in all of the above stories I named.

 
No one in their right mind could be stupid enough to believe a
totally insane conspiracy theory that completely erases the
character of the Doctor and replaces him with a monster based
on Doomsday.
 Well, it is a bit weird and definitely poorly conceived but the
simple fact is, it's there.
It's degenerate fan fiction and nothing to do with real Doctor Who.
Doctor Who ended in 2017.

  
And now with the bigeneration bullshit attached to it it's
become even more incredulous, unbelievable,
 But you can believe in an alien that can change his face, his
Nothing wrong with that. Anyone could change their face with plastic surgery, even before Doctor Who was even concieved.

gender, his skin colour, can travel around time and space in a
The latter two are not canon. We have never seen the Doctor change his gender ever, not his skin colour. The only thing we have seen is Romana changing into a humanoid lizard, and that may have been her dressed in a lizard costume when the Doctor asked her to change clothing rather than a regeneration, since the change was never shown on screen.

blue wooden box...that's bigger on the outside, and fights
Nothing wrong with that. Disbelief can easily be suspended for that.

pepper-pots on wheels (with men inside) to save the universe?!
 
They're an alien life from inside an armed and armoured travel machine. Suspension of disbelief does not require everything we know and have learned about the character of the Doctor and his history to be thrown out of the window to accept the existence of Daleks.

WELL THAT'S ALRIGHT THEN!
A deranged conspiracy theory that requires that everything we know about the character of the Doctor, his entire history and past, his family, his relationships, his adventures, and his origin and entire status as a Time Lord, to be totally erased from our minds and replaced with something completely different pertaining to the character of a degenerate monster from another dimension created from a systematically abused child is not alright then.
--
The True Doctor https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCngrZwoS0n21IRcXpKO79Lw
"To be woke is to be uninformed which is exactly the opposite of what it stands for." -William Shatner

Date Sujet#  Auteur
19 Apr 24 * From the Archives .....132Daniel70
19 Apr 24 +* Re: From the Archives .....119The True Doctor
19 Apr 24 i+* Re: From the Archives .....22The True Doctor
21 Apr 24 ii`* Re: From the Archives .....21The True Doctor
22 Apr 24 ii `* Re: From the Archives .....20Daniel70
23 Apr 24 ii  +- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
24 Apr 24 ii  `* Re: From the Archives .....18The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 ii   +* Re: From the Archives .....2Idlehands
25 Apr 24 ii   i`- Re: From the Archives .....1Idlehands
25 Apr 24 ii   `* Re: From the Archives .....15Daniel70
26 Apr 24 ii    +* Re: From the Archives .....2The True Doctor
26 Apr 24 ii    i`- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
26 Apr 24 ii    +* Re: From the Archives .....4The True Doctor
26 Apr 24 ii    i`* Re: From the Archives .....3The True Doctor
28 Apr 24 ii    i `* Re: From the Archives .....2The True Doctor
28 Apr 24 ii    i  `- Re: From the Archives .....1solar penguin
26 Apr 24 ii    +* Re: From the Archives .....4The True Doctor
26 Apr 24 ii    i+* Re: From the Archives .....2Idlehands
26 Apr 24 ii    ii`- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
26 Apr 24 ii    i`- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
26 Apr 24 ii    +- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
26 Apr 24 ii    `* Re: From the Archives .....3Daniel70
26 Apr 24 ii     `* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70
27 Apr 24 ii      `- Re: From the Archives .....1Idlehands
19 Apr 24 i+* Re: From the Archives .....2The True Doctor
20 Apr 24 ii`- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
20 Apr 24 i`* Re: From the Archives .....94The Last Doctor
20 Apr 24 i +* Re: From the Archives .....7The Last Doctor
20 Apr 24 i i`* Re: From the Archives .....6The Last Doctor
21 Apr 24 i i `* Re: From the Archives .....5The Last Doctor
21 Apr 24 i i  +- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
21 Apr 24 i i  `* Re: From the Archives .....3The Last Doctor
22 Apr 24 i i   `* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70
23 Apr 24 i i    `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
20 Apr 24 i `* Re: From the Archives .....86The True Doctor
21 Apr 24 i  +* Re: From the Archives .....6The True Doctor
22 Apr 24 i  i+- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
22 Apr 24 i  i+* Re: From the Archives .....3Daniel70
22 Apr 24 i  ii`* Re: From the Archives .....2The True Doctor
23 Apr 24 i  ii `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
22 Apr 24 i  i`- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
21 Apr 24 i  +* Re: From the Archives .....78The True Doctor
22 Apr 24 i  i+* Re: From the Archives .....16Daniel70
23 Apr 24 i  ii+- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
23 Apr 24 i  ii`* Re: From the Archives .....14The True Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  ii +* Re: From the Archives .....11The Last Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  ii i+* Re: From the Archives .....5The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  ii ii`* Re: From the Archives .....4The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  ii ii `* Re: From the Archives .....3Daniel70
25 Apr 24 i  ii ii  `* Re: From the Archives .....2solar penguin
26 Apr 24 i  ii ii   `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
24 Apr 24 i  ii i+* Re: From the Archives .....2The Last Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  ii ii`- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  ii i+- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  ii i`* Re: From the Archives .....2The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  ii i `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
24 Apr 24 i  ii +- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  ii `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
23 Apr 24 i  i`* Re: From the Archives .....61The True Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  i +* Re: From the Archives .....59The Last Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  i i`* Re: From the Archives .....58The True Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  i i +* Re: From the Archives .....47The Last Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  i i i+* Re: From the Archives .....45The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  i i ii`* Re: From the Archives .....44The Last Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  i i ii +* Re: From the Archives .....24The True Doctor
26 Apr 24 i  i i ii i`* Re: From the Archives .....23The Last Doctor
26 Apr 24 i  i i ii i `* Re: From the Archives .....22The True Doctor
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii i  `* Re: From the Archives .....21Blueshirt
28 Apr 24 i  i i ii i   `* Re: From the Archives .....20The True Doctor
28 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    +* Re: From the Archives .....6The Last Doctor
28 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    i+* Re: From the Archives .....4The True Doctor
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    ii+- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    ii`* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    ii `- Re: From the Archives .....1Idlehands
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    i`- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
28 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    +- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    `* Re: From the Archives .....12The True Doctor
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     +* Re: From the Archives .....7Idlehands
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i`* Re: From the Archives .....6The True Doctor
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i `* Re: From the Archives .....5Idlehands
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i  `* Re: From the Archives .....4The True Doctor
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i   `* Re: From the Archives .....3Idlehands
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i    `* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i     `- Re: From the Archives .....1Idlehands
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     +* Re: From the Archives .....3The True Doctor
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i`* Re: From the Archives .....2solar penguin
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i `- Re: From the Archives .....1solar penguin
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
25 Apr 24 i  i i ii `* Re: From the Archives .....19The True Doctor
26 Apr 24 i  i i ii  +* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70
26 Apr 24 i  i i ii  i`- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii  +* Re: From the Archives .....6Idlehands
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii  i+- Re: From the Archives .....1Idlehands
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii  i`* Re: From the Archives .....4Blueshirt
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii  i +* Re: From the Archives .....2Idlehands
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii  i i`- Re: From the Archives .....1%
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii  i `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii  `* Re: From the Archives .....10The True Doctor
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii   +* Re: From the Archives .....5Daniel70
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii   i`* Re: From the Archives .....4Daniel70
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii   i `* Re: From the Archives .....3Daniel70
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii   `* Re: From the Archives .....4The True Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  i i i`- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  i i `* Re: From the Archives .....10solar penguin
24 Apr 24 i  i `- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
21 Apr 24 i  `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
22 Apr 24 +* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70
23 Apr 24 +- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
27 Apr 24 +- Re: From the Archives .....1Blueshirt
30 Apr 24 +* Re: From the Archives .....5Daniel70
30 Apr 24 +- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
1 May 24 `* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal