Re: Fans Are COMPLETELY GIVING UP ON Doctor Who- Here's Why.

On 23/05/2025 20:21, The Last Doctor wrote:

On 23/05/2025 19:51, Blueshirt wrote:

The True Doctor wrote:
>

On 23/05/2025 18:35, solar penguin wrote:

Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:

The True Doctor wrote:

They can do it in 15 seconds in the opening scene. Clara

wakes up from a bad dream and Peter Capaldi walks out of
the shower.  Even better still they can also undo the
female Master by having Danny Pink walk out of the
shower and Peter Capaldi is in the downstairs too
looking after their son Orson.

Interesting that Aggy thinks of a female Master as something

else to fix. Looks like he’s accidentally giving away his
real problems modern Doctor Who there.

>
Time Lords cannot regenerate into different genders otherwise
if they were pregnant it would kill the foetus or there would
be no way for it to be born, which would also result in its
death.

>
You say "cannot" but the TV show says otherwise, as it's
happened and been seen to happen on-screen... so the TV show
takes priority over your opinion. So, there's no such thing as
cannot when IT DID!!!

 Aggie has no imagination.
He cannot get his head around the notion that Time Lords are not human, so
the idea that they might have different solutions for biological conundrums
from being restricted to human concerns is beyond him.

It's not my job for find solutions for biological conundrums. It's the job of the writer. Where is the solution in the writing for what happens if a pregnantly Time Lady regenerates into a man?

It shows in other ways too: he can't get over the notion that the Doctor is
not the actor - for instance when he insists that Nigerians would not
accept the Doctor alas one of their own because Ncuti is a Scotsman of
Rwandan roots.

His own Rwandan ancestors would not accept him as proven by the fact that they forced his parents to flee the country so what would Nigerians accept him?

 He can't accept changes to the lore of Who because he can't get his head
round simple facts of life - for instance when he says that the Timeless
Child can't be right because Clara saw all the Doctors in Name of the
Doctor and there were no pre Hartnell ones.
Well, of course there weren't: they hadn't been filmed or conceived of yet.

What? The pre-Hartnell incarnations of the Timeless Child monster calling themselves the Doctor were all supposed to be part of his time-stream. Why didn't Clara see any of them? Why didn't Matt Smith know about any of them? Why didn't the Church of the Papal Mainframe know about them either? Why did Clara need to beg the Time Lords for a new set of regeneration cycles if the Doctor was immortal? Why did he say he was given a second cycle when he regenerated into Capaldi?

Clara didn't record any future Doctors either - not even Capaldi, and he'd
already been cast! But no other future Doctors, because they weren't yet
filmed or conceived of.

The future hadn't happened yet in the Doctor's time stream but the past had. Clara was only sent back into the Doctor's past. There are no incarnations before Hartnell.

Aggie really has no business criticising science fiction and fantasy - and
Doctor Who is fantasy and has been in part for 60 years - when he can't
step beyond mundane barriers like thinking aliens aren't human, or
characters are not their actors, or that TV shows can't take account of
twists and turns that haven't been written yet.
 

You can't get yourself past the requirement of both fantasy and science-fiction requiring coherent world building in order to justify their existence. Logical rules need to be followed and they can never be changed otherwise the writing becomes pure unbelievable bullshit and their can be no suspension of disbelief. The rules can never contradict existing scientific and biological facts.
Pregnant Time Ladies cannot change gender otherwise the foetus would never be able to be born and would die. Unless a credible and believable explanation is given by the writer then the scientific laws in the real world will always come first.
The moon is not a egg which houses a space dragon. It can't crack, lose 99% of its mass and then suddenly regain it out of nothing. People inside a falling space shuttle even if it's falling towards the moon all experience weightlessness. They don't get thrown to the ground as if the forced of gravity increased because they were falling.
Anything that breaks real world scientific laws without plausible scientific explanation cannot be considered to be cannon. It's nothing more than degenerate fan fic.
--
The True Doctor https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCngrZwoS0n21IRcXpKO79Lw
"To be woke is to be uninformed which is exactly the opposite of what it stands for." -William Shatner