Liste des Groupes | Revenir à ras fandom |
On 3/25/24 2:18 PM, Scott Dorsey wrote:Regardless of nigglined edge cases, the point remains. Russia hasMad Hamish <newsunspammelaws@iinet.unspamme.net.au> wrote:As I noted elsewhere, the good news is that all this resulted in a lot of publicity for the book, which could well reach a wider audience than if it *had* won the Hugo.On 5 Mar 2024 01:35:28 -0000, kludge@panix.com (Scott Dorsey) wrote:>
>So, I am reading Rebecca Kuang's _Babel_ to see just what it was that the>
Hugo Committee may have objected to, and I find it extremely pro-Chinese.
It is strongly against British imperialism and against the Opium War, and
the Chinese government of the time may not have been very strong but was
determined.
I think I've heard that the issue isn't the current work but that
she's written stuff critical of China in the past.
Which would be even WORSE because it would be punishing her for "reforming"
and finally writing something less critical.
>
Whatever it was, it was sure a mess.
--scott
Date | Sujet | # | Auteur | |
25 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 49 | Mad Hamish | |
25 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 48 | Scott Dorsey | |
26 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 47 | Evelyn C. Leeper | |
27 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 46 | Cryptoengineer | |
27 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 1 | Tim Merrigan | |
27 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 41 | Tim Illingworth | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 24 | Keith F. Lynch | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 19 | Scott Dorsey | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 8 | Keith F. Lynch | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 7 | Scott Dorsey | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 1 | Dimensional Traveler | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 5 | Keith F. Lynch | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 1 | Gary McGath | |
29 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 3 | Scott Dorsey | |
29 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 2 | Tim Merrigan | |
30 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 1 | Scott Dorsey | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 10 | Dimensional Traveler | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 9 | Paul S Person | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 3 | Dimensional Traveler | |
29 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 2 | Paul S Person | |
30 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 1 | Dimensional Traveler | |
29 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 5 | Gary McGath | |
29 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 1 | Cryptoengineer | |
29 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 3 | Paul S Person | |
30 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 1 | Dimensional Traveler | |
30 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 1 | Scott Dorsey | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 4 | Cryptoengineer | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 3 | Gary McGath | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 2 | Keith F. Lynch | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 1 | Cryptoengineer | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 12 | Cryptoengineer | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 11 | D | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 7 | Gary McGath | |
4 Apr 24 | Re: Babel | 6 | Jeff Urs | |
4 Apr 24 | Re: Babel | 3 | Keith F. Lynch | |
4 Apr 24 | Re: Babel | 2 | Paul S Person | |
4 Apr 24 | Re: Babel | 1 | D | |
5 Apr 24 | Re: Babel | 2 | John Dallman | |
5 Apr 24 | Re: Babel | 1 | D | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 3 | Chris Buckley | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 2 | ted@loft.tnolan.com (Ted Nolan | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 1 | D | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 4 | Paul S Person | |
28 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 1 | Dimensional Traveler | |
29 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 2 | Gary McGath | |
29 Mar 24 | Re: Babel | 1 | Paul S Person | |
2 Apr 24 | Re: Babel | 3 | Dorothy J Heydt | |
22 Apr 24 | Re: Babel | 2 | BCFD 36 | |
22 Apr 24 | Re: Babel | 1 | Dorothy J Heydt |
Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.