Re: Babel

Liste des GroupesRevenir à ras written 
Sujet : Re: Babel
De : newsunspammelaws (at) *nospam* iinet.unspamme.net.au (Mad Hamish)
Groupes : rec.arts.sf.written rec.arts.sf.fandom
Date : 25. Mar 2024, 00:40:22
Autres entêtes
Organisation : A noiseless patient Spider
Message-ID : <rde10jldh1c4c7r34c38jsf44eb8gfrctq@4ax.com>
References : 1
User-Agent : ForteAgent/7.20.32.1218
On 5 Mar 2024 01:35:28 -0000, kludge@panix.com (Scott Dorsey) wrote:

So, I am reading Rebecca Kuang's _Babel_ to see just what it was that the
Hugo Committee may have objected to, and I find it extremely pro-Chinese.
It is strongly against British imperialism and against the Opium War, and
the Chinese government of the time may not have been very strong but was
determined. 

I think I've heard that the issue isn't the current work but that
she's written stuff critical of China in the past.
>
If her previous works were anti-Chinese, I don't know.  But this seems
sufficiently against that that I would expect it would more than make up
for that.
>
This book, I might add, is also very well written and extremely entertaining
and was just a great read that thoroughly deserved a Hugo.  If it had been
on the ballot I would have voted for it.  Is there hope for a Nebula maybe?
There were some odd technical problems which all could have been accounted
for by the differences between our universe and theirs but which did seem a
little glaring.  But it was still great.
--scott

Date Sujet#  Auteur
25 Mar 24 * Re: Babel48Mad Hamish
25 Mar 24 `* Re: Babel47Scott Dorsey
26 Mar 24  `* Re: Babel46Evelyn C. Leeper
27 Mar 24   `* Re: Babel45Cryptoengineer
27 Mar 24    +- Re: Babel1Tim Merrigan
27 Mar 24    +* Re: Babel40Tim Illingworth
28 Mar 24    i+* Re: Babel24Keith F. Lynch
28 Mar 24    ii+* Re: Babel19Scott Dorsey
28 Mar 24    iii+* Re: Babel8Keith F. Lynch
28 Mar 24    iiii`* Re: Babel7Scott Dorsey
28 Mar 24    iiii +- Re: Babel1Dimensional Traveler
28 Mar 24    iiii `* Re: Babel5Keith F. Lynch
28 Mar 24    iiii  +- Re: Babel1Gary McGath
29 Mar 24    iiii  `* Re: Babel3Scott Dorsey
29 Mar 24    iiii   `* Re: Babel2Tim Merrigan
30 Mar 24    iiii    `- Re: Babel1Scott Dorsey
28 Mar 24    iii`* Re: Babel10Dimensional Traveler
28 Mar 24    iii `* Re: Babel9Paul S Person
28 Mar 24    iii  +* Re: Babel3Dimensional Traveler
29 Mar 24    iii  i`* Re: Babel2Paul S Person
30 Mar 24    iii  i `- Re: Babel1Dimensional Traveler
29 Mar 24    iii  `* Re: Babel5Gary McGath
29 Mar 24    iii   +- Re: Babel1Cryptoengineer
29 Mar 24    iii   `* Re: Babel3Paul S Person
30 Mar 24    iii    +- Re: Babel1Dimensional Traveler
30 Mar 24    iii    `- Re: Babel1Scott Dorsey
28 Mar 24    ii`* Re: Babel4Cryptoengineer
28 Mar 24    ii `* Re: Babel3Gary McGath
28 Mar 24    ii  `* Re: Babel2Keith F. Lynch
28 Mar 24    ii   `- Re: Babel1Cryptoengineer
28 Mar 24    i+* Re: Babel11Cryptoengineer
28 Mar 24    ii`* Re: Babel10D
28 Mar 24    ii +* Re: Babel5Gary McGath
4 Apr 24    ii i`* Re: Babel4Jeff Urs
4 Apr 24    ii i `* Re: Babel3Keith F. Lynch
4 Apr 24    ii i  `* Re: Babel2Paul S Person
4 Apr 24    ii i   `- Re: Babel1D
28 Mar 24    ii `* Re: Babel4Chris Buckley
28 Mar 24    ii  `* Re: Babel3ted@loft.tnolan.com (Ted Nolan
28 Mar 24    ii   +- Re: Babel1D
29 Mar 24    ii   `- Re: Babel1Mike Spencer
28 Mar 24    i`* Re: Babel4Paul S Person
28 Mar 24    i +- Re: Babel1Dimensional Traveler
29 Mar 24    i `* Re: Babel2Gary McGath
29 Mar 24    i  `- Re: Babel1Paul S Person
2 Apr 24    `* Re: Babel3Dorothy J Heydt
22 Apr 24     `* Re: Babel2BCFD 36
22 Apr 24      `- Re: Babel1Dorothy J Heydt

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal