Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear

Liste des GroupesRevenir à ras written 
Sujet : Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear
De : peter (at) *nospam* tsto.co.uk (Peter Fairbrother)
Groupes : rec.arts.sf.written
Date : 29. Sep 2024, 04:53:07
Autres entêtes
Organisation : A noiseless patient Spider
Message-ID : <vdaiv4$1k3in$1@dont-email.me>
References : 1 2 3 4 5
User-Agent : Mozilla Thunderbird
On 28/09/2024 17:06, Mike Van Pelt wrote:
In article <vd7m9n$uguu$1@dont-email.me>,
Peter Fairbrother  <peter@tsto.co.uk> wrote:
On 28/09/2024 01:50, Dimensional Traveler wrote:
On 9/27/2024 3:55 PM, Mike Van Pelt wrote:
I'd love to see more work done on thorium reactors.
>
That _sounds_ like an obvious answer to I have to ask what the catch is.
>
No great catch, except that thorium reactors have been massively
over-hyped.
...
Less radioactive waste? Long-term waste is pretty much the same. Claims
for less short-term waste are ... disputable.
It's actually the opposite. 
Ah yes, my mistake here, got that the wrong way round. Too late at night, can't sleep. My apologies.
I think we'd both agree that the short-term fission product waste is pretty much the same.

In general, short term waste (the really hot stuff) is fission products; the long term
waste (weakly radioactive)** is mostly transuranics.
For the uranium cycle, yes: but for the thorium cycle the worst of the long-term waste are the actinides Pa-231 and Th-229. There are others.
Not technically transuranics, but equally nasty heavier-than-lead non-fission-product long-term wastes.
Sure thorium produces less transuranics - though not none - but the heavier transuranics/actinides produced by uranium tend to have short half-lives and get consumed while still in the reactor. The lighter actinides produced from thorium tend to have longer half-lives and once the fuel is removed from the reactor and left for a few years there are more of them left.
While the results of simulations vary depending on details of the reactor conditions, for similar conditions long-term (10^3-10^4 years) radiotoxicities generally do not vary much between uranium and thorium fuels. Sometimes uranium wins, sometimes thorium,
If the actinides are reintroduced into the reactor they can in general be destroyed. This is true for both uranium and thorium.
I have nothing against thorium vs uranium - except idiots who plan trailer-sized molten salt reactors which can't cope with a post-SCRAM meltdown and which are a huge proliferation risk and claim because it's thorium it's somehow safer, and the like, and the like, and people who go on and on about the supposed benefits of thorium.
As you can probably see, the overhyping of thorium pisses me off more than a little.
Yes, at first everyone used uranium because it made plutonium for bombs, (and also because you can't start off from just thorium, you need some uranium to get the neutrons to make the Th-233) but that was then.
At present, overall it's pretty much a wash between thorium and uranium. Supply issues favour thorium a little but not overwhelmingly, known technology and existing reprocessing and other facilities favours uranium a lot. That's it.
Theoretical safety? There's no real difference.
Molten salt reactors can/could be safer, but that's a different question. They can run on uranium or thorium.
Which is the real reason why people who want to make money don't build thorium reactors when they can build uranium ones which are known to work, if only somewhat, and are easy to license and finance.
And why people who have lots of thorium and less-strict licensing and government finance are building thorium reactors.
Peter Fairbrother

Date Sujet#  Auteur
13 Sep 24 * Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear548Don
14 Sep 24 +* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear530Paul S Person
14 Sep 24 i+* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear5Don
15 Sep 24 ii`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear4Paul S Person
16 Sep 24 ii `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear3Cryptoengineer
18 Sep 24 ii  `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear2Cryptoengineer
18 Sep 24 ii   `- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Bobbie Sellers
16 Sep 24 i+* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear521Don
16 Sep 24 ii+* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear44Lynn McGuire
16 Sep 24 iii+* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear26Don
16 Sep 24 iiii+* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear3Paul S Person
17 Sep 24 iiiii`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear2Dimensional Traveler
17 Sep 24 iiiii `- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Paul S Person
17 Sep 24 iiii`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear22Mike Van Pelt
17 Sep 24 iiii +- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Dimensional Traveler
17 Sep 24 iiii +- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Paul S Person
17 Sep 24 iiii +* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear10Cryptoengineer
17 Sep 24 iiii i+* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear4Bobbie Sellers
25 Sep 24 iiii ii`* Tom Dooley had it coming.3Mike Van Pelt
25 Sep 24 iiii ii `* Re: Tom Dooley had it coming.2Titus G
25 Sep 24 iiii ii  `- Re: Tom Dooley had it coming.1Mike Van Pelt
29 Sep 24 iiii i`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear5Don
1 Oct 24 iiii i `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear4Lynn McGuire
1 Oct 24 iiii i  `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear3Mike Van Pelt
1 Oct 24 iiii i   +- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Lynn McGuire
1 Oct 24 iiii i   `- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Bobbie Sellers
21 Sep 24 iiii `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear9Mad Hamish
25 Sep 24 iiii  +* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear3Mike Van Pelt
30 Sep 24 iiii  i`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear2Mad Hamish
30 Sep 24 iiii  i `- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Paul S Person
25 Sep 24 iiii  `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear5Paul S Person
25 Sep 24 iiii   +- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Bobbie Sellers
25 Sep 24 iiii   +- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Mike Van Pelt
26 Sep 24 iiii   +- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Scott Dorsey
26 Sep 24 iiii   `- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Dimensional Traveler
16 Sep 24 iii`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear17D
16 Sep 24 iii `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear16Paul S Person
16 Sep 24 iii  `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear15D
17 Sep 24 iii   +* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear3Paul S Person
17 Sep 24 iii   i`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear2Bobbie Sellers
18 Sep 24 iii   i `- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Paul S Person
23 Sep 24 iii   `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear11Mad Hamish
23 Sep 24 iii    +* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear8Paul S Person
24 Sep 24 iii    i`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear7Dimensional Traveler
24 Sep 24 iii    i +* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear3Bobbie Sellers
24 Sep 24 iii    i i+- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Dimensional Traveler
30 Sep 24 iii    i i`- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Mad Hamish
24 Sep 24 iii    i `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear3Paul S Person
25 Sep 24 iii    i  `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear2Dimensional Traveler
25 Sep 24 iii    i   `- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Paul S Person
23 Sep 24 iii    `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear2Bobbie Sellers
24 Sep 24 iii     `- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Paul S Person
16 Sep 24 ii+* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear474Titus G
16 Sep 24 iii+* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear2Paul S Person
19 Sep 24 iiii`- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1William Hyde
16 Sep 24 iii`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear471Don
17 Sep 24 iii +* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear4Titus G
17 Sep 24 iii i`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear3Don
18 Sep 24 iii i `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear2Titus G
18 Sep 24 iii i  `- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Don
18 Sep 24 iii +* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear461quadibloc
18 Sep 24 iii i+* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear442Lynn McGuire
18 Sep 24 iii ii+* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear34Bobbie Sellers
18 Sep 24 iii iii`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear33quadibloc
19 Sep 24 iii iii `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear32Lynn McGuire
19 Sep 24 iii iii  +* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear7Bobbie Sellers
19 Sep 24 iii iii  i+- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Cryptoengineer
19 Sep 24 iii iii  i`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear5Lynn McGuire
19 Sep 24 iii iii  i `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear4Bobbie Sellers
19 Sep 24 iii iii  i  `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear3Cryptoengineer
20 Sep 24 iii iii  i   `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear2Titus G
28 Sep 24 iii iii  i    `- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Robert Carnegie
20 Sep 24 iii iii  +- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Cryptoengineer
20 Sep 24 iii iii  +* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear17Lynn McGuire
21 Sep 24 iii iii  i+* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear6Lynn McGuire
21 Sep 24 iii iii  ii`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear5Dimensional Traveler
21 Sep 24 iii iii  ii +* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear3Scott Dorsey
25 Sep 24 iii iii  ii i`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear2Dimensional Traveler
25 Sep 24 iii iii  ii i `- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Bobbie Sellers
21 Sep 24 iii iii  ii `- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1D
21 Sep 24 iii iii  i`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear10Dimensional Traveler
21 Sep 24 iii iii  i `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear9Bobbie Sellers
22 Sep 24 iii iii  i  `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear8Cryptoengineer
22 Sep 24 iii iii  i   `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear7Bobbie Sellers
22 Sep 24 iii iii  i    +* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear5Dimensional Traveler
23 Sep 24 iii iii  i    i`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear4Paul S Person
24 Sep 24 iii iii  i    i `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear3Dimensional Traveler
24 Sep 24 iii iii  i    i  `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear2Paul S Person
24 Sep 24 iii iii  i    i   `- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Bobbie Sellers
22 Sep 24 iii iii  i    `- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Cryptoengineer
21 Sep 24 iii iii  `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear6Mad Hamish
21 Sep 24 iii iii   `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear5Scott Dorsey
24 Sep 24 iii iii    +* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear2Mad Hamish
24 Sep 24 iii iii    i`- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Scott Dorsey
25 Sep 24 iii iii    +- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Michael Benveniste
26 Sep 24 iii iii    `- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Scott Dorsey
18 Sep 24 iii ii+* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear96D
19 Sep 24 iii iii`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear95William Hyde
19 Sep 24 iii iii +* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear32Titus G
19 Sep 24 iii iii i+* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear16D
19 Sep 24 iii iii ii`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear15Paul S Person
20 Sep 24 iii iii i`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear15Titus G
19 Sep 24 iii iii +* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear60D
19 Sep 24 iii iii `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear2quadibloc
18 Sep 24 iii ii+* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear2quadibloc
18 Sep 24 iii ii+- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Cryptoengineer
18 Sep 24 iii ii`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear308D
18 Sep 24 iii i+- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Bobbie Sellers
18 Sep 24 iii i+* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear3Paul S Person
18 Sep 24 iii i`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear14Cryptoengineer
18 Sep 24 iii `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear5Paul S Person
16 Sep 24 ii`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear2WolfFan
16 Sep 24 i+- Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear1Paul S Person
28 Sep 24 i`* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear2Robert Carnegie
16 Sep 24 +* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear12quadibloc
25 Sep 24 `* Re: Whoops! The Atlantic Makes Trump Look EPIC In Cover Intended as a Smear5quadibloc

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal