Re: Books Banned in Utah.

Liste des GroupesRevenir à ras written 
Sujet : Re: Books Banned in Utah.
De : petertrei (at) *nospam* gmail.com (Cryptoengineer)
Groupes : rec.arts.sf.written
Date : 10. Aug 2024, 19:05:19
Autres entêtes
Organisation : A noiseless patient Spider
Message-ID : <v98a4v$rka8$1@dont-email.me>
References : 1 2 3
User-Agent : Mozilla Thunderbird
On 8/10/2024 11:40 AM, Paul S Person wrote:
On Fri, 9 Aug 2024 18:27:49 -0000 (UTC), Daniel Goldsmith
<dgold@dgold.invalid> wrote:
 
On 2024-08-07, Titus G <noone@nowhere.com> wrote:
Utah has banned 13 books, including Oryx and Crake by Margaret Atwood
which basically claims that large corporations are not to be trusted
with science.
I do not know any of the other authors but Sarah J. Maas writes Fantasy.
James Nichol will be delighted that women are being recognised with
twelve of the thirteen books being written by women.
>
Thanks for posting that message.
>
The responses are why I, and others, no longer participate here.
>
If I want to read far-right bigotry, I'll open a Heinlein.
 Too bad it is misleading.
 They banned 13 books /from the school libraries/, not from Utah. I
consider the decision idiotic pandering to semi-fascist ultra-Maga
weirdos, BTW. Decisions based on content rather than, say, reading
level, are inherently dubious.
 Most of the discussion here has been about the right to do so. Which
in Seattle, bluest of the blue, has existed since at least the 1950s.
There are about 3 million publications in the US each year. Libraries
have neither unlimited budgets, nor unlimited shelf space.
There *has* to be a selection process for what gets included.
The current list of books banned from Utah school libraries may be
a ludicrous example of adult fears, but to say no books can be excluded
for any reason is a non-starter. *Most* have to be excluded, else every
school library would be as large as the Library of Congress.
pt

Date Sujet#  Auteur
7 Aug 24 * Books Banned in Utah.157Titus G
7 Aug 24 +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.130ted@loft.tnolan.com (Ted Nolan
8 Aug 24 i+* Re: Books Banned in Utah.21Lynn McGuire
8 Aug 24 ii`* Re: Books Banned in Utah.20Dimensional Traveler
8 Aug 24 ii +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.6ted@loft.tnolan.com (Ted Nolan
8 Aug 24 ii i+* Re: Books Banned in Utah.4Titus G
8 Aug 24 ii ii`* Re: Books Banned in Utah.3ted@loft.tnolan.com (Ted Nolan
8 Aug 24 ii ii `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Titus G
8 Aug 24 ii ii  `- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
8 Aug 24 ii i`- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
8 Aug 24 ii +- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Scott Dorsey
8 Aug 24 ii +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.10D
8 Aug 24 ii i`* Re: Books Banned in Utah.9Paul S Person
8 Aug 24 ii i +- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1D
9 Aug 24 ii i `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.7Dimensional Traveler
9 Aug 24 ii i  `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.6Paul S Person
9 Aug 24 ii i   `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.5William Hyde
10 Aug 24 ii i    +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Bobbie Sellers
10 Aug 24 ii i    i`- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
21 Aug 24 ii i    `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Robert Carnegie
21 Aug 24 ii i     `- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
13 Aug 24 ii `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Paul S Person
21 Aug 24 ii  `- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Robert Carnegie
8 Aug 24 i+* Re: Books Banned in Utah.4Dimensional Traveler
13 Aug 24 ii+- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1D
13 Aug 24 ii`* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2James Nicoll
13 Aug 24 ii `- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
8 Aug 24 i+- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Titus G
8 Aug 24 i+* Re: Books Banned in Utah.81Mike Van Pelt
8 Aug 24 ii+- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Dimensional Traveler
8 Aug 24 ii+* Re: Books Banned in Utah.14Scott Dorsey
13 Aug 24 iii+* Re: Books Banned in Utah.7D
13 Aug 24 iiii`* Re: Books Banned in Utah.6Paul S Person
13 Aug 24 iiii +- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1D
14 Aug 24 iiii +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.3D
20 Aug 24 iiii i+- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1D
21 Aug 24 iiii i`- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Scott Dorsey
21 Aug 24 iiii `- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Robert Carnegie
13 Aug 24 iii`* Re: Books Banned in Utah.6Paul S Person
13 Aug 24 iii +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2D
21 Aug 24 iii i`- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Robert Carnegie
15 Aug 24 iii `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.3Scott Dorsey
15 Aug 24 iii  `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Paul S Person
16 Aug 24 iii   `- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Scott Dorsey
8 Aug 24 ii`* Re: Books Banned in Utah.65Paul S Person
9 Aug 24 ii +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Scott Dorsey
13 Aug 24 ii i`- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
11 Aug 24 ii +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.58Mike Van Pelt
11 Aug 24 ii i+- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Titus G
11 Aug 24 ii i`* Re: Books Banned in Utah.56Paul S Person
13 Aug 24 ii i `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.55Mike Van Pelt
14 Aug 24 ii i  `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.54Paul S Person
14 Aug 24 ii i   `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.53Mike Van Pelt
15 Aug 24 ii i    `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.52Paul S Person
15 Aug 24 ii i     +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Robert Woodward
16 Aug 24 ii i     i`- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
20 Aug 24 ii i     +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Paul S Person
20 Aug 24 ii i     i`- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Mike Van Pelt
20 Aug 24 ii i     +* Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.46Bobbie Sellers
21 Aug 24 ii i     i+* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Cryptoengineer
21 Aug 24 ii i     ii`- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Bobbie Sellers
21 Aug 24 ii i     i`* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.43Paul S Person
21 Aug 24 ii i     i +- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Bobbie Sellers
21 Aug 24 ii i     i +* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.31Cryptoengineer
22 Aug 24 ii i     i i+* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.26Cryptoengineer
22 Aug 24 ii i     i ii+* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.11James Nicoll
22 Aug 24 ii i     i iii+- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Cryptoengineer
22 Aug 24 ii i     i iii`* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.9Cryptoengineer
22 Aug 24 ii i     i iii +- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1James Nicoll
22 Aug 24 ii i     i iii +* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.6Cryptoengineer
23 Aug 24 ii i     i iii i+* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.3James Nicoll
24 Aug 24 ii i     i iii ii`* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Bobbie Sellers
24 Aug 24 ii i     i iii ii `- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
23 Aug 24 ii i     i iii i`* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Paul S Person
24 Aug 24 ii i     i iii i `- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Bobbie Sellers
23 Aug 24 ii i     i iii `- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Scott Dorsey
22 Aug 24 ii i     i ii+* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Bobbie Sellers
22 Aug 24 ii i     i iii`- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Cryptoengineer
22 Aug 24 ii i     i ii+* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.9Scott Dorsey
22 Aug 24 ii i     i iii+* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.4Cryptoengineer
23 Aug 24 ii i     i iiii`* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.3D
24 Aug 24 ii i     i iiii `* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Bobbie Sellers
25 Aug 24 ii i     i iiii  `- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Cryptoengineer
22 Aug 24 ii i     i iii`* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.4James Nicoll
22 Aug 24 ii i     i iii +- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1James Nicoll
23 Aug 24 ii i     i iii +- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Scott Dorsey
23 Aug 24 ii i     i iii `- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
22 Aug 24 ii i     i ii+- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Cryptoengineer
31 Aug 24 ii i     i ii`* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Cryptoengineer
31 Aug 24 ii i     i ii `- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1James Nicoll
22 Aug 24 ii i     i i+- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
31 Aug 24 ii i     i i+- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
3 Sep 24 ii i     i i`* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Mike Van Pelt
3 Sep 24 ii i     i i `- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
21 Aug 24 ii i     i `* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.10Bobbie Sellers
22 Aug 24 ii i     i  `* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.9Paul S Person
22 Aug 24 ii i     i   `* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.8William Hyde
23 Aug 24 ii i     i    `* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.7Paul S Person
24 Aug 24 ii i     i     `* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.6William Hyde
24 Aug 24 ii i     i      `* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.5Paul S Person
25 Aug 24 ii i     i       `* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.4William Hyde
20 Aug 24 ii i     `- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1William Hyde
13 Aug 24 ii +- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1D
13 Aug 24 ii `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.3Paul S Person
8 Aug 24 i+- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1D
8 Aug 24 i`* Re: Books Banned in Utah.21D
8 Aug 24 +- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
9 Aug 24 +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.5Daniel Goldsmith
10 Aug 24 `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.20Charles Packer

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal