Re: Books Banned in Utah.

Liste des GroupesRevenir à ras written 
Sujet : Re: Books Banned in Utah.
De : kludge (at) *nospam* panix.com (Scott Dorsey)
Groupes : rec.arts.sf.written
Date : 16. Aug 2024, 01:44:01
Autres entêtes
Organisation : Former users of Netcom shell (1989-2000)
Message-ID : <v9m7ch$qpn$1@panix2.panix.com>
References : 1 2 3 4
Paul S Person  <psperson@old.netcom.invalid> wrote:
On 15 Aug 2024 00:13:27 -0000, kludge@panix.com (Scott Dorsey) wrote:
Paul S Person  <psperson@old.netcom.invalid> wrote:
>
And what /conceivable/ "context" could make, say, /Lady Chatterley's
Lover/ acceptable to 4th graders? Apart from putting it in the Adult
Section and keeping the kids confined to the Kiddie Section, of
course.
>
I read it in fifth grade and I liked it personally.  I would never have
read it, though, if it hadn't been locked up.  Sex stuff aside, it's a =
good
story with interesting characters.
>
And when you turned it in, did you have
>
'a brief chat along the lines of... "did you enjoy the=20
book? Ah, great, if so, check out these guys some time"' ?=20
>
That is, was context (as defined by Scott Dorsey) provided?

Oh no!  It wasn't provided by a librarian with appropriate commentary!
I stole it.

Is there /any/ "context", other than being locked up, that would make
it appropriate to fifth graders?

If anything, I thought it provided a lot of context to how adults don't
always get along.
--scott
--
"C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis."

Date Sujet#  Auteur
7 Aug 24 * Books Banned in Utah.157Titus G
7 Aug 24 +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.130ted@loft.tnolan.com (Ted Nolan
8 Aug 24 i+* Re: Books Banned in Utah.21Lynn McGuire
8 Aug 24 ii`* Re: Books Banned in Utah.20Dimensional Traveler
8 Aug 24 ii +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.6ted@loft.tnolan.com (Ted Nolan
8 Aug 24 ii i+* Re: Books Banned in Utah.4Titus G
8 Aug 24 ii ii`* Re: Books Banned in Utah.3ted@loft.tnolan.com (Ted Nolan
8 Aug 24 ii ii `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Titus G
8 Aug 24 ii ii  `- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
8 Aug 24 ii i`- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
8 Aug 24 ii +- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Scott Dorsey
8 Aug 24 ii +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.10D
8 Aug 24 ii i`* Re: Books Banned in Utah.9Paul S Person
8 Aug 24 ii i +- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1D
9 Aug 24 ii i `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.7Dimensional Traveler
9 Aug 24 ii i  `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.6Paul S Person
9 Aug 24 ii i   `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.5William Hyde
10 Aug 24 ii i    +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Bobbie Sellers
10 Aug 24 ii i    i`- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
21 Aug 24 ii i    `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Robert Carnegie
21 Aug 24 ii i     `- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
13 Aug 24 ii `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Paul S Person
21 Aug 24 ii  `- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Robert Carnegie
8 Aug 24 i+* Re: Books Banned in Utah.4Dimensional Traveler
13 Aug 24 ii+- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1D
13 Aug 24 ii`* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2James Nicoll
13 Aug 24 ii `- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
8 Aug 24 i+- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Titus G
8 Aug 24 i+* Re: Books Banned in Utah.81Mike Van Pelt
8 Aug 24 ii+- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Dimensional Traveler
8 Aug 24 ii+* Re: Books Banned in Utah.14Scott Dorsey
13 Aug 24 iii+* Re: Books Banned in Utah.7D
13 Aug 24 iiii`* Re: Books Banned in Utah.6Paul S Person
13 Aug 24 iiii +- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1D
14 Aug 24 iiii +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.3D
20 Aug 24 iiii i+- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1D
21 Aug 24 iiii i`- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Scott Dorsey
21 Aug 24 iiii `- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Robert Carnegie
13 Aug 24 iii`* Re: Books Banned in Utah.6Paul S Person
13 Aug 24 iii +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2D
21 Aug 24 iii i`- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Robert Carnegie
15 Aug 24 iii `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.3Scott Dorsey
15 Aug 24 iii  `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Paul S Person
16 Aug 24 iii   `- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Scott Dorsey
8 Aug 24 ii`* Re: Books Banned in Utah.65Paul S Person
9 Aug 24 ii +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Scott Dorsey
13 Aug 24 ii i`- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
11 Aug 24 ii +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.58Mike Van Pelt
11 Aug 24 ii i+- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Titus G
11 Aug 24 ii i`* Re: Books Banned in Utah.56Paul S Person
13 Aug 24 ii i `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.55Mike Van Pelt
14 Aug 24 ii i  `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.54Paul S Person
14 Aug 24 ii i   `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.53Mike Van Pelt
15 Aug 24 ii i    `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.52Paul S Person
15 Aug 24 ii i     +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Robert Woodward
16 Aug 24 ii i     i`- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
20 Aug 24 ii i     +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Paul S Person
20 Aug 24 ii i     i`- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Mike Van Pelt
20 Aug 24 ii i     +* Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.46Bobbie Sellers
21 Aug 24 ii i     i+* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Cryptoengineer
21 Aug 24 ii i     ii`- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Bobbie Sellers
21 Aug 24 ii i     i`* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.43Paul S Person
21 Aug 24 ii i     i +- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Bobbie Sellers
21 Aug 24 ii i     i +* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.31Cryptoengineer
22 Aug 24 ii i     i i+* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.26Cryptoengineer
22 Aug 24 ii i     i ii+* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.11James Nicoll
22 Aug 24 ii i     i iii+- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Cryptoengineer
22 Aug 24 ii i     i iii`* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.9Cryptoengineer
22 Aug 24 ii i     i iii +- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1James Nicoll
22 Aug 24 ii i     i iii +* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.6Cryptoengineer
23 Aug 24 ii i     i iii i+* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.3James Nicoll
24 Aug 24 ii i     i iii ii`* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Bobbie Sellers
24 Aug 24 ii i     i iii ii `- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
23 Aug 24 ii i     i iii i`* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Paul S Person
24 Aug 24 ii i     i iii i `- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Bobbie Sellers
23 Aug 24 ii i     i iii `- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Scott Dorsey
22 Aug 24 ii i     i ii+* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Bobbie Sellers
22 Aug 24 ii i     i iii`- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Cryptoengineer
22 Aug 24 ii i     i ii+* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.9Scott Dorsey
22 Aug 24 ii i     i iii+* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.4Cryptoengineer
23 Aug 24 ii i     i iiii`* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.3D
24 Aug 24 ii i     i iiii `* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Bobbie Sellers
25 Aug 24 ii i     i iiii  `- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Cryptoengineer
22 Aug 24 ii i     i iii`* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.4James Nicoll
22 Aug 24 ii i     i iii +- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1James Nicoll
23 Aug 24 ii i     i iii +- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Scott Dorsey
23 Aug 24 ii i     i iii `- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
22 Aug 24 ii i     i ii+- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Cryptoengineer
31 Aug 24 ii i     i ii`* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Cryptoengineer
31 Aug 24 ii i     i ii `- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1James Nicoll
22 Aug 24 ii i     i i+- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
31 Aug 24 ii i     i i+- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
3 Sep 24 ii i     i i`* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.2Mike Van Pelt
3 Sep 24 ii i     i i `- Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
21 Aug 24 ii i     i `* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.10Bobbie Sellers
22 Aug 24 ii i     i  `* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.9Paul S Person
22 Aug 24 ii i     i   `* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.8William Hyde
23 Aug 24 ii i     i    `* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.7Paul S Person
24 Aug 24 ii i     i     `* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.6William Hyde
24 Aug 24 ii i     i      `* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.5Paul S Person
25 Aug 24 ii i     i       `* Re: Politics OT-Re: Books Banned in Utah.4William Hyde
20 Aug 24 ii i     `- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1William Hyde
13 Aug 24 ii +- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1D
13 Aug 24 ii `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.3Paul S Person
8 Aug 24 i+- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1D
8 Aug 24 i`* Re: Books Banned in Utah.21D
8 Aug 24 +- Re: Books Banned in Utah.1Paul S Person
9 Aug 24 +* Re: Books Banned in Utah.5Daniel Goldsmith
10 Aug 24 `* Re: Books Banned in Utah.20Charles Packer

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal