Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”

Liste des GroupesRevenir à ras written 
Sujet : Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”
De : wthyde1953 (at) *nospam* gmail.com (William Hyde)
Groupes : rec.arts.sf.written
Date : 12. Oct 2024, 19:01:52
Autres entêtes
Organisation : A noiseless patient Spider
Message-ID : <veedis$8td5$1@dont-email.me>
References : 1 2 3 4
User-Agent : Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; WOW64; rv:91.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/91.0 SeaMonkey/2.53.19
Charles Packer wrote:
On 11 Oct 2024 13:24:36 -0000, Scott Dorsey wrote:
 
Charles Packer  <mailbox@cpacker.org> wrote:
A related line of thinking more congenial to SF is the following:
What would history have been like if it had been discovered, say, during
World War II that control like that could have been achieved?
>
Would Stalin have succeeded in converting Siberia to a warm and
temperate land able to grow many crops?  Or would he have decided to
leave it the way it was so he had a good place to keep gulags?
--scott
 Don't you think he would have used the capability to pester the
West? That's always seemed to be at the top of the Russian agenda,
according to history that I've read.
 
First, last, and always, Stalin was for Stalin. He did want to buff his image by spreading communism, but that was secondary, as  shown by a slogan of his time "Socialism in one Country" and his massacre of German communists in the 30s as their insistence on internationalism was inconvenient.
A war against anything like an equal power was to be avoided.  What gain could there be for Stalin, as opposed to the possible loss?
There's a connection here to Bel Riose of Foundation.  A successful general would be a threat to Stalin's power, and an unsuccessful one would lose.  So he had the most successful general of the previous war executed, just in case.
William Hyde

Date Sujet#  Auteur
8 Oct 24 * “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”45Lynn McGuire
8 Oct 24 +* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”8D
9 Oct 24 i`* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”7William Hyde
9 Oct 24 i +- Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”1James Nicoll
9 Oct 24 i `* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”5D
9 Oct 24 i  `* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”4Jay E. Morris
10 Oct 24 i   +- Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”1D
10 Oct 24 i   `* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”2Cryptoengineer
11 Oct 24 i    `- Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”1Kevrob
8 Oct 24 +- Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”1Bobbie Sellers
8 Oct 24 +- Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”1Lynn McGuire
8 Oct 24 +* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”3Christian Weisgerber
8 Oct 24 i`* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”2ted@loft.tnolan.com (Ted Nolan
9 Oct 24 i `- Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”1Don_from_AZ
9 Oct 24 +* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”7Cryptoengineer
9 Oct 24 i+- Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”1Titus G
9 Oct 24 i+- Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”1Paul S Person
9 Oct 24 i+* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”2Cryptoengineer
9 Oct 24 ii`- Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”1Lynn McGuire
11 Oct 24 i+- Re: "Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?"1Don
11 Oct 24 i`- Re: ?Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History??1Alistair Tyrrell
9 Oct 24 +* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”8Charles Packer
11 Oct 24 i`* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”7Scott Dorsey
11 Oct 24 i +- Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”1William Hyde
12 Oct 24 i `* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”5Charles Packer
12 Oct 24 i  +- Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”1Scott Dorsey
12 Oct 24 i  +* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”2Bobbie Sellers
14 Oct 24 i  i`- Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”1Kevrob
12 Oct 24 i  `- Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”1William Hyde
9 Oct 24 +* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”7Paul S Person
9 Oct 24 i+* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”2Lynn McGuire
10 Oct 24 ii`- Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”1Paul S Person
9 Oct 24 i+* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”2Lynn McGuire
10 Oct 24 ii`- Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”1Paul S Person
10 Oct 24 i`* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”2Bobbie Sellers
10 Oct 24 i `- Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”1Paul S Person
10 Oct 24 +* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”8Scott Dorsey
10 Oct 24 i`* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”7Bobbie Sellers
10 Oct 24 i `* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”6Cryptoengineer
10 Oct 24 i  `* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”5James Nicoll
10 Oct 24 i   `* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”4Cryptoengineer
10 Oct 24 i    `* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”3Bobbie Sellers
10 Oct 24 i     `* Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”2James Nicoll
11 Oct 24 i      `- Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”1Cryptoengineer
10 Oct 24 `- Re: “Did Hurricane Milton Have Help in Suddenly Becoming One of the Most Powerful Storms in History?”1Don

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal