Re: Most disappointing films.

Liste des GroupesRevenir à ras written 
Sujet : Re: Most disappointing films.
De : dtravel (at) *nospam* sonic.net (Dimensional Traveler)
Groupes : rec.arts.sf.written
Date : 20. Feb 2025, 02:55:03
Autres entêtes
Organisation : A noiseless patient Spider
Message-ID : <vp621j$2hj41$1@dont-email.me>
References : 1 2 3 4 5
User-Agent : Mozilla Thunderbird
On 2/19/2025 9:52 AM, Paul S Person wrote:
On Tue, 18 Feb 2025 13:06:58 -0500, William Hyde
<wthyde1953@gmail.com> wrote:
 
Ted Nolan <tednolan> wrote:
 <snippo>
 
Rogue One is pretty good.
>
I don't subscribe to the SF channel, but they were on for free over the
holidays and I taped a pile of Star Wars films.  So I was able to watch
Rogue one last night, and agree that it is better than most of the
others.  Not a disappointment.
>
But it was just jam-packed with stupidity, which can work with a light
hearted space opera like Empire, but not in this case.  It's nice that
the moral landscape of the characters is more complex, but that requires
a concomitant improvement in plotting to have any real effect.
>
Still, I enjoyed the first half of the movie.  The second half I found
to be dreadful.
 Yes, it /does/ rather resemble The Last Act of Hamlet, doesn't it.
Kind of a downer, especially the first time one sees it.
 It came up in my daily rotation on Monday. I enjoyed it, as I always
do. So much that I didn't even /notice/ any "stupidity".
 
I didn't realize that there's an actor out there whose entire career
seems to be as zombie Peter Cushing.
 As has been pointed out, this was CGI. As such, it's not half bad.
 The real question is how did they get the Princess Leia from Episode
IV back on-screen at the end? More (and perhaps better) CGI? A double?
A ton of makeup?
CGI.
--
I've done good in this world. Now I'm tired and just want to be a cranky dirty old man.

Date Sujet#  Auteur
17 Feb 25 * Most disappointing films.59William Hyde
17 Feb 25 +* Re: Most disappointing films.48D
17 Feb 25 i+* Re: Most disappointing films.3William Hyde
18 Feb 25 ii+- Re: Most disappointing films.1D
7 Mar 25 ii`- Re: Most disappointing films.1WolfFan
18 Feb 25 i`* Re: Most disappointing films.44ted@loft.tnolan.com (Ted Nolan
18 Feb 25 i +* Re: Most disappointing films.31D
19 Feb 25 i i+* Re: Most disappointing films.28Lynn McGuire
19 Feb 25 i ii+* Re: Most disappointing films.3D
20 Feb 25 i iii`* Re: Most disappointing films.2Cryptoengineer
20 Feb 25 i iii `- Re: Most disappointing films.1D
5 Mar 25 i ii+* Re: Most disappointing films.22Paul S Person
6 Mar 25 i iii+* Re: Most disappointing films.15Cryptoengineer
6 Mar 25 i iiii+- Re: Most disappointing films.1D
6 Mar 25 i iiii`* Re: Most disappointing films.13Paul S Person
6 Mar 25 i iiii +* Re: Most disappointing films.8D
7 Mar 25 i iiii i`* Re: Most disappointing films.7Paul S Person
7 Mar 25 i iiii i `* Re: Most disappointing films.6D
7 Mar 25 i iiii i  +* Re: Most disappointing films.3Titus G
8 Mar 25 i iiii i  i+- Re: Most disappointing films.1D
14 Mar 25 i iiii i  i`- Re: Most disappointing films.1Robert Carnegie
8 Mar 25 i iiii i  `* Re: Most disappointing films.2William Hyde
8 Mar 25 i iiii i   `- Re: Most disappointing films.1D
7 Mar 25 i iiii `* Re: Most disappointing films.4Cryptoengineer
8 Mar 25 i iiii  `* Re: Most disappointing films.3Paul S Person
19 Mar 25 i iiii   `* Re: Most disappointing films.2Robert Carnegie
19 Mar 25 i iiii    `- Re: Most disappointing films.1Paul S Person
6 Mar 25 i iii+* Re: Most disappointing films.4Dimensional Traveler
6 Mar 25 i iiii+* Re: Most disappointing films.2Lynn McGuire
6 Mar 25 i iiiii`- Re: Most disappointing films.1Dimensional Traveler
6 Mar 25 i iiii`- Re: Most disappointing films.1Paul S Person
14 Mar 25 i iii`* Re: Most disappointing films.2Robert Carnegie
15 Mar 25 i iii `- Re: Most disappointing films.1Paul S Person
8 Mar 25 i ii`* Re: Most disappointing films.2WolfFan
8 Mar 25 i ii `- Re: Most disappointing films.1Paul S Person
8 Mar 25 i i`* Re: Most disappointing films.2WolfFan
8 Mar 25 i i `- Re: Most disappointing films.1D
18 Feb 25 i +* Re: Most disappointing films.7William Hyde
18 Feb 25 i i+- Re: Most disappointing films.1ted@loft.tnolan.com (Ted Nolan
19 Feb 25 i i+- Re: Most disappointing films.1Jay Morris
19 Feb 25 i i+* Re: Most disappointing films.3Paul S Person
20 Feb 25 i ii+- Re: Most disappointing films.1Dimensional Traveler
20 Feb 25 i ii`- Re: Most disappointing films.1Lynn McGuire
8 Mar 25 i i`- Re: Most disappointing films.1WolfFan
8 Mar 25 i `* Re: Most disappointing films.5Paul S Person
8 Mar 25 i  `* Re: Most disappointing films.4D
9 Mar 25 i   `* Re: Most disappointing films.3Paul S Person
9 Mar 25 i    `* Re: Most disappointing films.2Robert Woodward
9 Mar 25 i     `- Re: Most disappointing films.1Dimensional Traveler
18 Feb 25 +* Re: Most disappointing films.5Bice
18 Feb 25 i+* Re: Most disappointing films.2Scott Dorsey
18 Feb 25 ii`- Re: Most disappointing films.1Tony Nance
18 Feb 25 i+- Re: Most disappointing films.1Paul S Person
20 Feb 25 i`- Re: Most disappointing films.1Cryptoengineer
4 Mar 25 `* Re: Most disappointing films.5Mike Van Pelt
4 Mar 25  `* Re: Most disappointing films.4Cryptoengineer
4 Mar 25   `* Re: Most disappointing films.3Paul S Person
8 Mar 25    `* Re: Most disappointing films.2Mike Van Pelt
9 Mar 25     `- Re: Most disappointing films.1Paul S Person

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal