Re: What the Constitution, Supreme Court say about 'due process' for Trump deportees:

On 6/4/2025 8:32 PM, AMuzi wrote:

On 6/4/2025 7:15 PM, zen cycle wrote:

On 6/4/2025 7:46 PM, AMuzi wrote:

On 6/4/2025 6:12 PM, zen cycle wrote:

On 6/4/2025 5:52 PM, AMuzi wrote:

On 6/4/2025 2:53 PM, Zen Cycle wrote:

On 6/4/2025 9:43 AM, AMuzi wrote:

On 6/4/2025 4:30 AM, zen cycle wrote:

On 6/3/2025 5:03 PM, AMuzi wrote:

On 6/3/2025 3:10 PM, Zen Cycle wrote:

On 6/3/2025 11:36 AM, Frank Krygowski wrote:

On 6/3/2025 8:59 AM, AMuzi wrote:

>
There was a false statement inserted into a filing in re Kilmar Abrego Garcia that he had been deported in error. The Justice Department employee who added that was fired the next morning and the filing emended...

>
Got a citation or other evidence for that claim? And what did the courts say about this issue? And where is Mr. Garcia now?

>
Right, The government narrative kept changing, coming up with different excuses, right down to trump retweeting a photo shopped (fake) image of Mr. Garcia with gang tattoos. Once they were unable to convince anyone with any brains that he had no criminal past, they brought out a domestic abuse complaint from ten years ago - complete bullshit as well.
>

>

As Monday morning's NYT for example, whose front page did not cover the immolation of live US citizens, including a Holocaust survivor, in Boulder by an illegal jihadi screaming 'free palestine.' Deemed not interesting enough by editorial staff.

>
I don't get a print edition of NYT; but your complaint seems to be that eight people getting various degrees of burns did not get enough attention, despite it being on every news outlet. It looks to me like NYT has since done many articles on the incident and its implications. Are you trying to say NYT does sufficiently protest antisemitism?
>
And BTW, what happened was despicable. As you know, I'm firmly against attempts to harm or kill groups of innocent people. But "immolation of live US citizens" is more than a little exaggerated. It usually means burning to death. I gather only one person out of the eight was seriously burned.
>
There's no excuse for the attack, but you can slightly relax your grip on your own pearls!
>

>
>

At his previous 2019 hearing, after his deportation order, the removal was stayed as the judge found that his MS-13 gang membership put him at risk in his old neighborhood controlled by a competing gang.
>
(details are messy as he had lived both in El Salvador and in Guatemala)
>
https://tennesseestar.com/news/immigration- judges-2019- order- found- kilmar-abrego-garcia- subject-to-removal-by- deportation- but- granted- withholding-of-removal-to- guatemala-though- referencing- el-salvador/ tpappert/2025/04/22/
>
The prior administration also denied assistance to Tennessee State Patrol in 2022 when they stopped him in the car of a known trafficker with a load of smuggled illegals while speeding with no valid license. FBI directed TSP to not detain him.
>
https://tennesseestar.com/justice/tennessee-highway- patrol- confirms- biden-era-fbi-told-officers-to- release- kilmar- abrego- garcia- during-2022- traffic- stop-despite- speeding- and-license- violations- to/ tpappert/2025/04/17/
>

  Uncorroborated allegations.."sources said"...."two (unnamed) judges determined he is likely to be a member of the Central American gang, Mara Salvatrucha"....iow, more trump ICE/DOJ lies to cover their assess.

>
>
The judge who, in 2019, stayed deportation to Guatemala _due to his gang affiliation_ wrote his decision. It was not appealed.
>

>
Got a link? I couldn't find anything except trump DOJ heresay.
>

>
Cited above, it's in the header of the first link, "granted withholding of removal to guatemala though referencing el salvador"

>
um...no.
>
The named judge in that article - Judge David M. Jones - made absolutely no determination of any gang affiliation. Judge Jones order is linked in the article so you can read it yourself. (here for convenience https:// drive.google.com/ file/ d/1V_yaacfwjS6i02eeCaHoPh64tGvySkVO/)
>
Regarding any alleged gang affiliation, The link you provided has no more information than "two [unnamed] judges determined he is likely to be a member of the Central American gang, Mara Salvatrucha".
>
It's heresay, and there has been no evidence produced by anyone that Mr. Garcia had any gang affiliation. More trump DOJ bullshit.
>

>

>

>
Fair enough, not proved beyond reasonable doubt.
>
Here's a question. If you wanted to smuggle eight aliens from the southern border to Maryland, would you make the arrangements with a known MS-13 smuggler, who owned the car in question at the Tennessee traffic stop, or your local Boy Scout troop?
>

  Here's a question, Where do you see any information that any of the seven people in the car (excluding garcia) were illegal and that the car was owned by a known smuggler?
>
>
>

 Apparently you did not find the whole sorry tale as interesting as did I.

It's a massive amount of time, effort, and energy wasted on one individual with a legal right to remain in the US. The trump ICE jack-booted thugs are concentrated on removing those with criminal records (Garcia has none), picking low hanging fruit (people who pose no threat and are in fact productive members of their communities) rather than apprehending those that are indeed true threats.

 https://tennesseestar.com/justice/doj-reportedly-gave-limited-immunity- to-human-smuggler-who-owned-van-driven-by-kilmar-abrego-garcia-for- details-on-2022-trip/tpappert/2025/05/06/

As with all of these Tennesee Star reports, lot's of editorial allegation with no facts to back them up, e.g.:
"This analysis between troopers came shortly before one of the troopers divulged the cash found on Abrego Garcia’s person....“He’s got $1,400 cash in his pocket in an envelope,” said the trooper. “Probably payments.”"
That statement is no where in the video.
"“If he gets arrested, you’re not gonna have any choice but to just dump them out beside the interstate,” the trooper claimed."
That statement is no where in the video
and then your claim:

 The twist is that FBI directly and immediately advised TSP officers at the scene to not interfere with Mr Abrego Garcia.

That 'information' is no where in that link or video, and only made as an unsubstantiated claim in other TS links.
Be any of that as it may, The issue of transporting people for money is not by _any_ definition "human smuggling".
You'll note the TS had the due diligence to posted the entire order from Judge Jones' stay-in-us order via a link, yet for some reason has no other information on "two judges found him likely to be affiliated with MS13" other than that unsubstantiated claim (made in several of their stories).
That was information spoon-fed to the TS by the administration, which if true would be rather easy to validate.
This is similar to the case of the Milford MA high school student detained by ICE. After the arrest, ICE said it was his father they were looking for becasue:
"Federal immigration authorities said he "has a habit of reckless driving at speeds in excess of 100 miles per hour through residential areas endangering Massachusetts residents."
At least in Massachusetts, you don't get to walk free if you pulled over doing 100 in a residential area, let alone if you make a "habit" of it (I should know, my license was suspended once in the 80's for doing 50 in a 25).
If it were true, it would be easy enough to verify. IOW - just more made up bullshit from trump ICE to cover their asses.

 Good luck with that if you're ever stopped by State Patrol.

I'll try to remember that the next time I get paid to drive people across state lines for money.