Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven

Liste des GroupesRevenir à rmc recordings 
Sujet : Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven
De : marcs12212 (at) *nospam* gmail.com (Zionazi)
Groupes : rec.music.classical.recordings
Date : 15. Nov 2024, 10:26:20
Autres entêtes
Organisation : novaBBS
Message-ID : <91de000c5e09bc1ed122864e04490e9b@www.novabbs.com>
References : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
User-Agent : Rocksolid Light
Hmmm… I said many wrong and stupid things about Beethoven… he’s still my
second fav composer after all… but there are things in his music i
really dislike (but there are also things in the music of Brahms I
extremely dislike — especially talking about their greatest works here)…
say movement nr 4 of symphony 5, or first movement pc 5, and most or
many of his sonatas - especially the later ones… or say the god awful
scherzo of Brahms 4th symphony… or the alphorn part in his first
symphony - and I’m not a huge fan of the Beethoven 9 sounding part…
Yeah I was being stupid — mostly anyways
But I feel in general I prefer early/early-mid Beethoven except for some
output of his later work…
And okay… there are things that Mozart did that don’t feel right — say
the Jupiter symphony or quintet for glass harmonica (in the latter I
have problems with the instrument in use I think) but they are still fun
in some way and don’t turn me completely off as Beethoven 5 4th movement
does (it still has very sublime and beautiful moments, but most of it is
shyte) or Brahms 4 scherzo…
I mean the idea of connecting two movements as Beethoven did in 5 is
nice and all… but how god awful does the beginning of the 4th movement
sound?… like completely unreflected - in some ways maybe even cheap…

Date Sujet#  Auteur
15 Nov 24 * Yeah i think im done with beethoven50Zionazi
15 Nov 24 +* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven43Zionazi
15 Nov 24 i+* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven40Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii`* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven39Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven38Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii  `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven37DeepBlue
15 Nov 24 ii   `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven36Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii    `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven35Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii     `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven34Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii      `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven33Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii       `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven32Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii        `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven31Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii         `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven30Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii          `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven29Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii           `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven28Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii            `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven27Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii             +- Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven1Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii             `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven25DeepBlue
15 Nov 24 ii              `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven24Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii               `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven23Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii                `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven22Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii                 `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven21Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii                  `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven20Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii                   `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven19Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii                    +* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven15Zionazi
15 Nov 24 ii                    i`* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven14Zionazi
16 Nov 24 ii                    i `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven13Zionazi
16 Nov 24 ii                    i  `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven12Zionazi
16 Nov 24 ii                    i   `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven11Zionazi
16 Nov 24 ii                    i    `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven10Zionazi
16 Nov 24 ii                    i     `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven9Zionazi
16 Nov 24 ii                    i      `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven8Zionazi
16 Nov 24 ii                    i       `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven7Zionazi
16 Nov 24 ii                    i        `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven6Zionazi
16 Nov 24 ii                    i         `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven5Zionazi
17 Nov 24 ii                    i          `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven4Zionazi
17 Nov 24 ii                    i           `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven3Zionazi
17 Nov 24 ii                    i            `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven2Zionazi
17 Nov 24 ii                    i             `- Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven1Zionazi
20 Nov 24 ii                    `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven3DeepBlue
22 Nov 24 ii                     `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven2Zionazi
22 Nov 24 ii                      `- Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven1DeepBlue
20 Nov 24 i`* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven2DeepBlue
22 Nov 24 i `- Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven1Zionazi
18 Nov 24 +* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven3DeepBlue
20 Nov 24 i`* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven2Zionazi
20 Nov 24 i `- Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven1Zionazi
20 Nov 24 `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven3DeepBlue
22 Nov 24  `* Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven2Zionazi
22 Nov 24   `- Re: Yeah i think im done with beethoven1Zionazi

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal