Re: Best Chopin Ballade 3

On Fri, 6 Dec 2024 9:19:07 +0000, DeepBlue wrote:

On Fri, 6 Dec 2024 8:35:09 +0000, Zionazi wrote:
>

On Thu, 5 Dec 2024 22:17:38 +0000, DeepBlue wrote:
>

On Thu, 5 Dec 2024 21:58:19 +0000, Zionazi wrote:
>

https://youtu.be/IadczKo175c?si=3CDHTFwAd37CIthd
>
Richter (DG)
>
I like this very much

>
It used to be my reference,
however there are different,
more recent views of the work
that I now find more appealing.

>
Should probably revisit some and
also listen to some more, but this is
how I felt about it yesterday evening…
>

>
Try for instance Yulianna Avdeeva:
>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k9SX_EcElII

>
Will Check it out later - you still
seem to be unsure though, otherwise
there‘d be a „superb“-Comment by
inraid in the comment section…
whats Holding You back? ;)
>

>
I am not "unsure". I like different
things at different times. Nothing
unusual, except perhaps for people
who believe taste and enjoyment are
set in stone like the Sinai tablets.

Dan… You’ve been living on Planet Earth more than 60years, yet you still
Act like an Alien (or should i rather - since it‘s quite appropriate -
like a brainfucked imbecile) all too often; I‘ve so often asked you…
read what I wrote again and try to understand where I‘m coming from…
The interactions with you have certainly been amusing, but your
narcissism (Herm is a narc as well btw) has just become Kind of boring
and tiring - You’re too predictable… You always fall back in to the same
behaviour-patterns…
There was no reason to defend yourself, yet You’re making Drama for
nothing..
It’s quite obvious your ability to emphatize with other people wasnt
developed well…
I was playfully asking why - if You’re so enamoured with her Chopin -
you wouldnt Leave a superb comment as u usually do…
Not difficult to understand, except for narcissists ofc…
Similar to how it’s Not difficult to understand that if you call Yuja
Wang‘s Schubert excellent, it doesnt make sense to add that it’s only
worth hearing once…

>
There is more than one way to perform
almost any musical work. There is no
need to rank them. Enjoy what you like,
ignore what you don't, and stop lecturing
everybody about Meowszart's operas. A
few months ago you decreed Chopin was
"entertainment". Now you are not so
sure anymore?

Cant really remember where I decried Chopin‘s work as Entertainment, I
believe You’re projecting here, as you were the one refering to Mozart‘s
music as Entertainment (in E-Mail as well I believe in this ng) — about
which I wasnt even mad, and told you thats its Great Entertainment ;D
I remember saying Cho-fucking-pin or Rach-fucking-maninoff in response
to one of your deranged comments — but that was more in jest (for which
you as a narcissist ofc don’t have any empathy ;) )
You seem to be of the people who view Taste and enjoyment to be set in
Stone like the sinai tablets
I have Changed my stance on Chopin, as I don’t think taste is set in
Stone Like the Sinai tablets
Actually one of the First cm recordings I sort of liked and bought on
itunes when I looked into cm in my early twenties were some of
Rubinstein‘s Chopin ballades - Besides Francois‘ Slow movement of ravels
g Major concerto. I believe I liked the second ballade the Most less -
and still do…
Oh and I remember Buying some of Richter‘s Ravel on itunes…

>
And operas are not "entertainment" ?!?

Why did You get triggered Dan? Why Are you evening Talking about
„Entertainment“? I didnt use the Word here… Cant live with the fact that
most people would consider Beethoven more serious music, and Chopin more
as Entertainment? ;)
Sure operas are Entertainment, just as I told you in the email- but
theyre so much more than that, especially Mozart‘s

>
Cheers