Re: WAYLTL 2025!

On Wed, 15 Jan 2025 21:00:07 +0000, cheregi wrote:

On Wed, 15 Jan 2025 8:13:39 +0000, DeepBlue wrote:
>

As to CPE's "influence" on other compawsers, give us
a break! One hears Chopin's influence in the music of
all the composers who followed him. One doesn't even
hear CPE's "influence" in Schubert or in Schumann!

>
Well it's not ME making the claim that CPE was a key
influence on the Romantics.

If it is not your own opinion why waste bandwidth
parroting someone else's? Remember this ng is about
RECORDINGS, not about COMPAWSERS. For the latter
there is rec.music.classical.

I'm just responding to what seems to me to be
"common knowledge" I've picked up from various
sources.

Since no one other than yourself published such
"common knowledge" in this ng, to whom are you
"responding"?

Feel free to disagree, but there's no need to
shoot the messenger...

No one is "shooting" the messenger, just pointing
out this topic is for another ng.

Are you a musicologist perchance? Just curious .....

>
Absolutely not. The musicologists I've read wouldn't
be caught dead making such grandiose claims as I do
about the causal relationships between economics and
aesthetics.

Dude (or dudette): this ng is about RECORDINGS of
classical music. It is not about economics or about
aesthetics in general, or about the relationship
between them.
Can you please stay on topic?
Thx