Re: Hostage deal

On Thu, 20 Feb 2025 12:49:16 +0000, Zionazi wrote:

So there are quite a few Israelis (among them Ben-Gvir doing Petty
politics) and Diaspora Jews who are arguing that this hostage deal sort
of constitutes a reward for the terrorists; saying that Netanyahu
rewards the terrorists with this deal. And that actually one should
teach Hamas a lesson by Not being willing to Agree to this awful deal -
some even go as far as being willing to sacrifice the hostages for some
perceived greater good, arguing that this will save a larger number of
Jews in the Future (who do they think they are? Do they think they’re
god and able to predict the Future? Did hashem give them some sheets
giving the Numbers of the dead Jews if You Take this Deal or if you
don’t? And even if you had the Numbers — would that justify condemning
the hostages to death? I don’t think so)…
>
There is just so much wrong with this mentality; it’s like the Games
Hamas plays got to These Jews, Broke Them down and turned them into cold
calculating robots.
>
So some say; if Sinwar wasnt Released This wouldnt have happened. Well
my friends, antisemites will always want to murder Jews and how history
would have went if Israel didn’t Release him among a 1000 other hostages
for Gilad (whose life is certainly worth more than all the fakestinians
that exist on This Planet — the worth of the life of a righteous Person
is infinite. Fwiw: Cant say the Same about Hamas, Hamas-Herman, Raydolf
and Mr Andy Semite), we don’t know.
>
The mistake was not so much releasing Sinwar (or not murdering him
directly — as Walter Benjamin Said: „The death Penalty for a criminal
can be just, but Never its justification.“ we are not god, we can’t know
if it was really justified, but it can be — it is also something you
feel in your Body.

I think I actually believe that you can probably feel that it was
justified; it’s just that we don’t have the means to come up with a
jutification — this is god‘s Territory.
Also I think it’s Funny to Note, that the commandment „though shall not
kill“ too often Gets misunderstood as „You Must not kill“ - there is a
huge difference here.