Re: How to Make Cisterns

Liste des GroupesRevenir à r puzzles 
Sujet : Re: How to Make Cisterns
De : richard (at) *nospam* cogsci.ed.ac.uk (Richard Tobin)
Groupes : rec.puzzles
Date : 03. May 2025, 16:49:41
Autres entêtes
Organisation : Language Technology Group, University of Edinburgh
Message-ID : <vv5dul$2l5ol$1@artemis.inf.ed.ac.uk>
References : 1 2
User-Agent : trn 4.0-test76 (Apr 2, 2001)
In article <n7dc1khosulkq2113b729l11n94bodmhls@4ax.com>,
Charlie Roberts  <croberts@gmail.com> wrote:
.... Spoiler alert .....
>
>
>
>
>
>
>










>
>
>
Not sure I get what exactly is the problem here, and being
uncomfortable with numbers, I went about it as follows.
>
Let the side of the initial sheet be a. Now cut out the sqaures of
side x from the four corners and fold up the sticky bits. You have
an open cistern of side a-2x and height x. The volume is
>
 V(x) = x(a-2x)^2
>
dV/dx = 0 gives
>
 a - 2x = 0 or a -  6x = 0
>
The first answer is cute as with x = a/2 leaves with a zero
area base and,  naturally, a volume of zero.
>
The second answer gives x = a/6

Yes

or a volume of a^3/9.

You forgot to square the (a-2x)

-- Richard

Date Sujet#  Auteur
3 May 25 * How to Make Cisterns18David Entwistle
3 May 25 +* Re: How to Make Cisterns9Richard Heathfield
3 May 25 i+* Re: How to Make Cisterns7David Entwistle
3 May 25 ii`* Re: How to Make Cisterns6Richard Heathfield
3 May 25 ii `* Re: How to Make Cisterns5Richard Tobin
3 May 25 ii  `* Re: How to Make Cisterns4Richard Heathfield
3 May 25 ii   `* Re: How to Make Cisterns3Richard Heathfield
3 May 25 ii    +- Re: How to Make Cisterns1David Entwistle
3 May 25 ii    `- Re: How to Make Cisterns1Richard Tobin
3 May 25 i`- Re: How to Make Cisterns1Richard Tobin
3 May 25 +- Re: How to Make Cisterns1Richard Tobin
3 May 25 +- Re: How to Make Cisterns1Richard Tobin
4 May 25 +- Re: How to Make Cisterns1Richard Tobin
4 May 25 +- Re: How to Make Cisterns1David Entwistle
4 May 25 +- Re: How to Make Cisterns1Carl G.
7 May 25 `* Re: How to Make Cisterns3David Entwistle
7 May 25  `* Re: How to Make Cisterns2David Entwistle
9 May 25   `- Re: How to Make Cisterns1Mark Brader

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal