Re: Persistent predators at Schoningen

On 5.10.2024. 13:17, Pandora wrote:

Persistent predators: Zooarchaeological evidence for specialized horse hunting at Schöningen 13II-4
 Open access:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhevol.2024.103590
 Highlights
 *The Schöningen “Spear Horizon” likely accumulated over a short period of time.
 *Middle Pleistocene hominins potentially occupied the Schöningen lakeshore year-round.
 *Schöningen hunters were highly selective in prey choice and prey target groups.
 *Carcass exploitation at Schöningen focused on situational needs.
 Abstract
 The Schöningen 13II-4 site is a marvel of Paleolithic archaeology. With the extraordinary preservation of complete wooden spears and butchered large mammal bones dating from the Middle Pleistocene, Schöningen maintains a prominent position in the halls of human origins worldwide. Here, we present the first analysis of the complete large mammal faunal assemblage from Schöningen 13II-4, drawing on multiple lines of zooarchaeological and taphonomic evidence to expose the full spectrum of hominin activities at the site—before, during, and after the hunt. Horse (Equus mosbachensis) remains dominate the assemblage and suggest a recurrent ambush hunting strategy along the margins of the Schöningen paleo-lake. In this regard, Schöningen 13II-4 provides the first undisputed evidence for hunting of a single prey species that can be studied from an in situ, open-air context. The Schöningen hominins likely relied on cooperative hunting strategy to target horse family groups, to the near exclusion of bachelor herds. Horse kills occurred during all seasons, implying a year-round presence of hominins on the Schöningen landscape. All portions of prey skeletons are represented in the assemblage, many complete and in semiarticulation, with little transport of skeletal parts away from the site. Butchery marks are abundant, and adult carcasses were processed more thoroughly than were juveniles. Numerous complete, unmodified bones indicated that lean meat and marrow were not always so highly prized, especially in events involving multiple kills when fat and animal hides may have received greater attention. The behaviors displayed at Schöningen continue to challenge our perceptions and models of past hominin lifeways, further cementing Schöningen's standing as the archetype for understanding hunting adaptations during the European Middle Pleistocene.
 Well, that doesn't sound like diving for shellfish.

Hm, how you think people started to eat meat? Eating bone marrow? I (and this document) wouldn't say so. Shouldn't a shellfish, salty shellfish, would be much better match?
They say that they hunted horses by ambush. 80 % of lion prey are zebras, also hunted by the way of ambush.
If they were there all year round, why would they move? This implies sedentary lifestyle.
If they preferred fat, wouldn't pigs be a better choice? Of course, here we are talking about plains, hence horses, no pigs, but if they preferred fat, this would mean that their original food would actually be pigs, and here they are hunting horses because there are no pigs on plains. And piglets can be easily eaten burnt by setting their nest on fire.