Re: electrical deaths

On 12/2/24 1:17 PM, Joe Gwinn wrote:

On Mon, 2 Dec 2024 11:35:41 -0800, Joerg <news@analogconsultants.com>
wrote:
 

On 12/1/24 9:59 AM, Joe Gwinn wrote:

On Sat, 30 Nov 2024 14:24:11 -0800, Joerg <news@analogconsultants.com>
wrote:
>

On 11/26/24 6:53 PM, john larkin wrote:

https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Age-adjusted-mortality-rates-from-electrical-injuries-per-1-million-population-European_fig1_221916189
>
The US (0.63 PPM) is probably low partly because we have mostly 120
volt gadgets. I usually wire boxes hot, and get tickled now and then,
no big deal.
>
Some countries are astounding.
>

>
Twice the line voltage makes a difference. Also, some countries such as
Germany have non-polarized wall outlets which was a clear mistake on the
part of the standards guys. Think toasters and forks.

>
We have polarized line plugs in the US, but the wiring old and new
isn't consistent, or becomes so over time.  And so people often
intentionally defeat the polarization.
>
Part of the problem is that for many small appliances, the plug was
bigger than the appliance.  Probably more expensive too.
>
Anyway, my instinct is that not polarizing plugs and sockets is more
realistic, as it forces manufacturers to pass safety regardless of hoe
things are plugged in.
>

>
Polarization can save the day with toasters and similar appliances. Then
you can make sure that neutral comes in at the top end of the meanders.
In the US, 99+ percent of cases will not have line and neutral reversed.

 I think that the 99+ percent is quite optimistic, especially on older
buildings.  Back when I was an apartment-dweller, ran into all manner
of trouble, to the point that one of the first things I did in a new
apartment, was to turn the power off and opened all electric boxes,
and straighten out the "carpenter wiring", much of this being
dangerous.
 

Not too optimistic, I think. The home inspector we used was a seasoned guy and he said outlets where line and neutral are reversed were very rare. He made it a habit of testing them all.

War Story One:  In the 1970s in Washington, DC, my boss was having
considerable problems with the lights in his newish house in the
suburbs.  For instance, when he turned one light on, an unrelated
light would go off.  I said it sounded like some kind of grounding
problem.  Eventually he invited me to dinner in his house, and bring
your voltmeter.  Which I did.  It turned out that the solid copper
wires at every electrical device (wall switch, outlet, light, et al)
were loose - the electrician (or his assistant had forgotten to
tighten all the terminal screws down.  (Stranded wire was not used
then.)  So boss called the builder to have all those neglected
terminal screws tightened properly.  He was lucky that there wasn't a
fire.
 

That's a serious blunder by a contractor. In Germany we had mandatory road-worthiness checks for cars every two years. I think they still do. The inspector came up from underneath my dad's car with a pale face. "Sir, come down here, you've got to see this". The four connector bolts of a universal joint in the steering column were in there alright but the mechanic had forgotten to put any of the nuts on them, let alone tighten anything. They were just rattling around in their holes without nuts. My dad was one of the guys who floored it on autobahns, 120mph and more. That could have resulted in a horrific accident.

War Story Two.  Ten years later, in Baltimore, MD, some friends
complained that their kitchen light (in the center of the ceiling)
flickered, and mentioned that when they used the sink in the washroom
off the kitchen, sparks fell from underneath that sink.  I didn't
believe them at first, but they persisted.  It turned out that the
building (which was quite old) still had some old knob-and-tube
wiring.  The plumbers had recently replaced the drain pipe from the
bathroom above the washroom with a new copper pipe, and had barged
through the existing knob-and-tube wiring, breaking the return path,
but accidentally making the drain pipe live.  The current made it from
the copper drain pipe to the existing cast iron drain through the
hardware on the washroom sink.  Stopgap was to firmly ground the drain
pipe.  I assume the owner of the building had words with the plumber,
and got an electrician.  Anyway, nobody was hurt, and nothing burnt
down.
 I have many such stories, but this will do for now.
 And I bet that Europe also has its heart-stopping stories.
 

Over there it's often willful neglect. I sat at a pcinic table of a campground in Italy, having some wine with the owner. The lights flickered and a loud phzzzzt was heard, sparks flew. The overhead cable to the freezer at the (very far away) end of that line was arcing. "I think we should turn this off and run an extension cord" ... "Nah, happens a lot, it'll hang on for a while. I'll fix this tomorrow. Or the day after".

Joe Gwinn
 PS:  I do prefer the Euro-style closed terminals that work for
stranded and solid wire.  They are allowed in the US, but not all that
common outside of industrial sites.  One big advantage is that they
take far less volume than wire-nuts and the like.
 

Yes but unfortunately most of them contain just a screw and not a pressure plate. You are supposed to use ferrules on stranded wire but hardly anyone does.
--
Regards, Joerg
http://www.analogconsultants.com/