Re: Making your mind up

Liste des GroupesRevenir à t origins 
Sujet : Re: Making your mind up
De : cates_db (at) *nospam* hotmail.com (DB Cates)
Groupes : talk.origins
Date : 02. May 2024, 20:04:53
Autres entêtes
Organisation : University of Ediacara
Message-ID : <v10o4k$ani4$3@solani.org>
References : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
User-Agent : Mozilla Thunderbird
On 2024-05-02 12:46 PM, Bob Casanova wrote:
On Thu, 2 May 2024 12:34:10 -0500, the following appeared in
talk.origins, posted by DB Cates <cates_db@hotmail.com>:
 
On 2024-04-29 8:45 PM, Bob Casanova wrote:
On Mon, 29 Apr 2024 17:49:21 -0500, the following appeared
in talk.origins, posted by DB Cates <cates_db@hotmail.com>:
>
On 2024-04-29 11:53 AM, Bob Casanova wrote:
On Mon, 29 Apr 2024 09:12:08 -0700, the following appeared
in talk.origins, posted by Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net>:
>
On 4/28/24 10:32 AM, Bob Casanova wrote:
On Sat, 27 Apr 2024 16:50:12 -0700, the following appeared
in talk.origins, posted by Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net>:
>
On 4/26/24 4:27 PM, Bob Casanova wrote:
On Fri, 26 Apr 2024 09:32:27 -0700, the following appeared
in talk.origins, posted by Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net>:
[...]
>
I get the feeling that predetermination means, to you, that if I am
predetermined to choose to buy this house (say), then no matter what I
think, or even if I don't think at all, I will end up deciding to buy
that house. I could move to Tibet, scramble my brain with acid, and
spend all my conscious time playing Candy Crush, and still, in a day or
two, the though will come to me, "I need to buy that house."
>
That's not how predeterminism works. In a predetermined world, I find
myself in need or want of a house, contact a realtor who shows me
available listings; I visit those houses which are in good price range
and neighborhoods; probably I am influenced by external factors such as
the amount of traffic I had to fight through to get there or how hungry
I am at the time. The good and bad points of the different houses being
fed into my mind, I eliminate some obvious non-candidates, and let my
gut guide me to the best of the remaining.
>
That is predetermination at work.  Note that it appears, to all
observers, exactly the same as non-predetermination. That's why the Free
Will issue has never been resolved.
>
So, if I'm understanding that correctly, there is no
difference between determinism and non-determinism (or if
you prefer, determination and non-determination), and
therefore "free will" is a bugaboo which is not accepted
although its implications are?
>
No detectable difference between the two. And I should have added "free
will" is also wrapped up in religious, personal angst, and equivocation
issues, which also contribute to making it a bugaboo.
>
OK. I'd point out that the fact that the concept of free
will is "wrapped up in religious, personal angst, and
equivocation issues" doesn't make it false.
>
My position is not that it is false, but that it is effectively meaningless.
>
And that one
possible reason why there's no detectable difference is that
we have no way to detect the operation of free will in
itself.
>
I have given some thought to how, even in theory and with advanced
technology, one might detect free will, and I have come up empty. Some
Star-Trek-like parallel universe thought experiments could conceivably
determine whether the universe was deterministic or not, but even if
not, that only rules out determinism, not the lack of free will.
>
Yep. I've done the same, although not in any great depth,
and come to the same conclusion; the closest I've come is
something like, "Well, the probabilistic nature of base
reality *seems* to leave room for something resembling
choice, but as for testing it...".
>
Hmm, what could this "something resembling choice" be, other than
something 'outside' reality (ie supernatural) that somehow (magic?)
overrides the "probabilistic nature of base reality"?
>
You might want to re-read what I actually wrote, which was
not that anything is "outside reality". Reality, at base, is
probabilistic, not "clockwork".
>
Note: I was asking a question about *my* viewpoint concerning "something
resembling choice" given "probabilistic nature of base reality", not
ascribing that viewpoint to you.
>
I misinterpreted your post; my bad.
No problem.
>
My understanding of the "probabilistic nature of base reality" is that
some subatomic events are truly random and can have, over the long term,
gross effects and very occasionally immediate gross effects.
>
Usually more the former than the latter, but yes, I believe
that is correct.
>
How does
this allow for "something resembling choice"?
>
It would mean that the universe is not, as Newton believed
and as Planck disproved, "clockwork". And this in turn means
(to me, at least) that events are not strictly the result of
prior events; i.e., not fully deterministic. So if free will
(or choice, if you prefer) and strict determinism are the
only possibilities then free will, while restricted, is
possible.
How does that possible random variation resemble 'free will' in any way? What would be the restriction?
>
It's sometimes amusing to
discuss such things as determinism vs. free will, or the
number of angels which can occupy a pin point, but it
becomes boring fairly quickly due to the lack of any way,
even conceptually, to determine the answer. Which, as I
noted below, brings it down to a matter of belief in the
validity of personal experience.
>
My, somewhat vague and evolving, view is that it feels like I experience
'qualia' and 'make choices' between alternatives and that I am not
special, so others who report the same are not philosophical zombies
deterministically lying to me. It is a 'real thing'. I see two
possibilities. There is some unknown, evidenced phenomenon unrelated to
known physics somehow related to some minimal level of complexity of
life (dualism/free will) or a, actual activity unknown, manifestation of
physical brain activity (determinism). What leads me to believe the
second is more likely is the indirect evidence. Alteration of brain
activity (physical damage, drugs,etc) causes changes in peoples'
reported qualia and changes in (historically expected) personality and
range of choices made. This is usually observable with major changes to
the brain producing major changes in personality and/or range of
choices.but I think it not an unreasonable extrapolation to minor
changes in the brain (caused by minor changes in the environment) to
cause minor changes in experience/choices due to the same mechanisms.
>
Your friend George is picking new wallpaper for his living room. Knowing
your friend and his living room, you think he will likely pick something
off white with a small floral motif in blue.
You visit and see he chose pale yellow with thin blue striping. You are
not surprised by this and on discussing it with him he states he was
considering something like what you were thinking but this one really
struck him when he saw it in the store.
Or
You visit him and see he chose a vibrant, primary coloured geometric
zig-zag pattern. You think 'was he on drugs? / dropped on his head?' not
'hmm, how unusual'.
>
So, what is the sourcr of the phenomena we often descibe as 'dualiy'
and/or 'free will? We may never know but my personal belief, based on
the evidence I have, is that it is almost certainly due to some kind of
phyical activity, most likely in the brain (in humans and our close
relatives).
>
Testimony, of course, is irrelevant, since it may
itself be deterministic. I do see the problem, which comes
down to whether to accept of the validity of personal
experience. I happen to choose (there's that word again...)
to do so.
>
--
>
--
--
--
Don Cates ("he's a cunning rascal" PN)

Date Sujet#  Auteur
5 Apr 24 * Making your mind up169Martin Harran
5 Apr 24 +* Re: Making your mind up6Arkalen
6 Apr 24 i`* Re: Making your mind up5Martin Harran
6 Apr 24 i `* Re: Making your mind up4Arkalen
9 Apr 24 i  `* Re: Making your mind up3Martin Harran
9 Apr 24 i   `* Re: Making your mind up2Arkalen
10 Apr 24 i    `- Re: Making your mind up1Martin Harran
5 Apr 24 +* Re: Making your mind up161DB Cates
6 Apr 24 i`* Re: Making your mind up160Martin Harran
6 Apr 24 i +* Re: Making your mind up90LDagget
7 Apr 24 i i+- Re: Making your mind up1DB Cates
7 Apr 24 i i`* Re: Making your mind up88Martin Harran
7 Apr 24 i i +- Re: Making your mind up1DB Cates
8 Apr 24 i i +* Re: Making your mind up10Arkalen
9 Apr 24 i i i`* Re: Making your mind up9Martin Harran
9 Apr 24 i i i +* Re: Making your mind up2Arkalen
10 Apr 24 i i i i`- Re: Making your mind up1Martin Harran
9 Apr 24 i i i `* Re: Making your mind up6DB Cates
9 Apr 24 i i i  `* Re: Making your mind up5Martin Harran
9 Apr 24 i i i   `* Re: Making your mind up4DB Cates
10 Apr 24 i i i    `* Re: Making your mind up3Martin Harran
10 Apr 24 i i i     `* Re: Making your mind up2DB Cates
11 Apr 24 i i i      `- Re: Making your mind up1Martin Harran
19 Apr 24 i i `* Re: Making your mind up76Mark Isaak
19 Apr 24 i i  +- Re: Making your mind up1FromTheRafters
19 Apr 24 i i  +* Re: Making your mind up5Arkalen
20 Apr 24 i i  i`* Re: Making your mind up4DB Cates
20 Apr 24 i i  i `* Re: Making your mind up3Arkalen
21 Apr 24 i i  i  +- Re: Making your mind up1*Hemidactylus*
22 Apr 24 i i  i  `- Re: Making your mind up1Martin Harran
22 Apr 24 i i  `* Re: Making your mind up69Martin Harran
24 Apr 24 i i   `* Re: Making your mind up68Mark Isaak
26 Apr 24 i i    `* Re: Making your mind up67Martin Harran
26 Apr 24 i i     +* Re: Making your mind up8Ernest Major
27 Apr 24 i i     i`* Re: Making your mind up7Martin Harran
27 Apr 24 i i     i `* Re: Making your mind up6Arkalen
2 May 24 i i     i  `* Re: Making your mind up5Martin Harran
2 May 24 i i     i   +* Re: Making your mind up3Arkalen
14 May 24 i i     i   i`* Re: Making your mind up2Martin Harran
21 May 24 i i     i   i `- Re: Making your mind up1Arkalen
2 May 24 i i     i   `- Re: Making your mind up1DB Cates
26 Apr 24 i i     `* Re: Making your mind up58Mark Isaak
27 Apr 24 i i      +* Re: Making your mind up42Bob Casanova
28 Apr 24 i i      i`* Re: Making your mind up41Mark Isaak
28 Apr 24 i i      i +* Re: Making your mind up2Martin Harran
29 Apr 24 i i      i i`- Re: Making your mind up1Mark Isaak
28 Apr 24 i i      i `* Re: Making your mind up38Bob Casanova
29 Apr 24 i i      i  +* Re: Making your mind up3*Hemidactylus*
4 May 24 i i      i  i`* Re: Making your mind up2*Hemidactylus*
4 May 24 i i      i  i `- Re: Making your mind up1Bob Casanova
29 Apr 24 i i      i  `* Re: Making your mind up34Mark Isaak
29 Apr 24 i i      i   +* Re: Making your mind up26Bob Casanova
30 Apr 24 i i      i   i+* Re: Making your mind up24DB Cates
30 Apr 24 i i      i   ii`* Re: Making your mind up23Bob Casanova
2 May 24 i i      i   ii `* Re: Making your mind up22DB Cates
2 May 24 i i      i   ii  `* Re: Making your mind up21Bob Casanova
2 May 24 i i      i   ii   `* Re: Making your mind up20DB Cates
3 May 24 i i      i   ii    +* Re: Making your mind up16Bob Casanova
3 May 24 i i      i   ii    i`* Re: Making your mind up15*Hemidactylus*
3 May 24 i i      i   ii    i `* Re: Making your mind up14Bob Casanova
3 May 24 i i      i   ii    i  +* Re: Making your mind up9Arkalen
3 May 24 i i      i   ii    i  i+* Re: Making your mind up5LDagget
3 May 24 i i      i   ii    i  ii+- Re: Making your mind up1Arkalen
4 May 24 i i      i   ii    i  ii+* Re: Making your mind up2DB Cates
4 May 24 i i      i   ii    i  iii`- Re: Making your mind up1*Hemidactylus*
4 May 24 i i      i   ii    i  ii`- Re: Making your mind up1*Hemidactylus*
4 May 24 i i      i   ii    i  i`* Re: Making your mind up3Bob Casanova
4 May 24 i i      i   ii    i  i `* Re: Making your mind up2Arkalen
4 May 24 i i      i   ii    i  i  `- Re: Making your mind up1Bob Casanova
3 May 24 i i      i   ii    i  `* Re: Making your mind up4*Hemidactylus*
4 May 24 i i      i   ii    i   `* Re: Making your mind up3Bob Casanova
4 May 24 i i      i   ii    i    `* Re: Making your mind up2*Hemidactylus*
4 May 24 i i      i   ii    i     `- Re: Making your mind up1Bob Casanova
3 May 24 i i      i   ii    `* Re: Making your mind up3Martin Harran
4 May 24 i i      i   ii     `* Re: Making your mind up2DB Cates
14 May 24 i i      i   ii      `- Re: Making your mind up1Martin Harran
30 Apr 24 i i      i   i`- Re: Making your mind up1Arkalen
29 Apr 24 i i      i   `* Re: Making your mind up7*Hemidactylus*
29 Apr 24 i i      i    `* Re: Making your mind up6Bob Casanova
29 Apr 24 i i      i     +* Re: Making your mind up2erik simpson
30 Apr 24 i i      i     i`- Re: Making your mind up1Bob Casanova
29 Apr 24 i i      i     +- Re: Making your mind up1*Hemidactylus*
30 Apr 24 i i      i     `* Re: Making your mind up2Martin Harran
30 Apr 24 i i      i      `- Re: Making your mind up1Bob Casanova
27 Apr 24 i i      `* Re: Making your mind up15Martin Harran
29 Apr 24 i i       `* Re: Making your mind up14Mark Isaak
30 Apr 24 i i        +* Re: Making your mind up3Arkalen
30 Apr 24 i i        i`* Re: Making your mind up2Martin Harran
4 May 24 i i        i `- Re: Making your mind up1Arkalen
30 Apr 24 i i        `* Re: Making your mind up10Martin Harran
1 May 24 i i         `* Re: Making your mind up9Mark Isaak
1 May 24 i i          +* Re: Making your mind up7Martin Harran
2 May 24 i i          i`* Re: Making your mind up6Mark Isaak
2 May 24 i i          i +- Re: Making your mind up1LDagget
2 May 24 i i          i `* Re: Making your mind up4Arkalen
2 May 24 i i          i  +* Re: Making your mind up2Mark Isaak
2 May 24 i i          i  i`- Re: Making your mind up1Arkalen
2 May 24 i i          i  `- Re: Making your mind up1DB Cates
2 May 24 i i          `- Re: Making your mind up1Arkalen
7 Apr 24 i `* Re: Making your mind up69DB Cates
7 Apr 24 i  `* Re: Making your mind up68Martin Harran
19 Apr 24 `- Re: Making your mind up1Mark Isaak

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal