Re: Making your mind up

On 05/04/2024 18:05, Martin Harran wrote:

There was quite an interesting discussion a few weeks ago on Free Will
vs Determinism but it died a death, at least in part due to the
departure of some contributors to the Land Beyond GG. I'd like to take
up some of the issues again if anyone is interested.
 One point made by Hemidactylus that didn't get developed any further
was the way that we sometimes give a lot of time and effort into
making a decision - he gave the example of buying a car. It's also
common for someone to want to "sleep it on it" before making a
decision where the decision is important but it is not clear what
decision is best. If a decision is essentially predetermined then what
is the point of that time and effort or sleeping on it?
 Tied in with that is our ability to change our minds after we have
made a decision - has determinism some convoluted way of working that
predetermines what way we will make a decision but also predetermins
that we will change it?
 A reminder that in the Libet experiments so beloved of determinists,
there was no precursor activity found in regard to making *major*
decisions or changing one's mind so how does that fit in?
 

I don't know if it's exactly the Libet experiments (I suspect so, from context) but I thought Anil Seth's "Being You" had some good points about free will. In terms of those experiments specifically he suggested they weren't necessarily identifying a *decision* being made so much as *the brain priming for action* - and even more specifically that the brain might have cycles going where, whichever decision is made, it will only *prompt action* at specific points in the cycle, and it's those cycles the experiments were seeing.
In terms of making your mind up I think it's even more obvious that actions can't be completely involuntary when you consider not just "sleeping on it" (where you could figure you end up making the decision you would have made anyway, which is definitely a thing that happens) but *gathering information*. While there are some decisions we hash out at length while finally making a decision one could argue we were going to make the whole time, there are also some where that's definitely not the case because the final decision depends on information we didn't have at the beginning of the process.