Re: Making your mind up

On 20/04/2024 14:42, *Hemidactylus* wrote:

Arkalen <arkalen@proton.me> wrote:

On 17/04/2024 12:14, Martin Harran wrote:
>
snip

>
Another aspect that strikes me is how individual minds can operate
collectively, almost as if a new mind is generated as in mob hysteria
but also in other useful ways; as a management consultant delivering
management development programmes, one of my favourite topics was
showing how collective decisions are generally better than individual
decisions. Although that has long been recognised in management and
business,  I am not aware of any attempt to study it from a science
perspective.
>

>
I read this a few days ago and thought "shhh keep your responses
relevant and focused, don't bring your latest hobbyhorse into every
conversation it's even vaguely reminiscent of" [I ask that you imagine
here Taylor Tomlinson miming the effects of antidepressants:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=47WXVTpnOyU&t=228s ]
>
But that laudable instinct wore off apparently. You know what book has
some interesting things to say about collective decision-making? "The
Evolution of Agency" by Michael Tomasello ! \o/
>
Actually one could argue it has a lot to say about decision-making in
general, it just gets at the problem from a very different angle than
the "how it works in the brain" that you seem to be talking about.
That's why I hesitated on the relevance front. But if a more high-level
discussion of how decision-making might work in its most general form,
that comes up with a very interesting perspective on the relationship of
individual humans to the collective, seems like it might interest you
it's a pretty short and (IMO) accessible book.
>

Seems your thread about the book has fallen silent.
 

Threads do that :) But I've read and very much appreciated your replies. I might have some question about what you said about the limbic system; I tried looking up what you said about LeDoux debunking it but I couldn't find something specific enough to hold my interest right at the time I was looking into it (I have fifty thousand tabs open on alkaline hydrothermal vents as it is and that's a bit more what I've been reading these past weeks).
I hope you continue posting your thoughts as you go through the book, or after you've finished.