Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary

Liste des GroupesRevenir à t origins 
Sujet : Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary
De : me (at) *nospam* yahoo.com (Athel Cornish-Bowden)
Groupes : talk.origins
Date : 19. May 2024, 15:47:54
Autres entêtes
Organisation : University of Ediacara
Message-ID : <lauhouFhaioU1@mid.individual.net>
References : 1 2 3 4 5
User-Agent : Unison/2.2
On 2024-05-19 07:45:14 +0000, Martin Harran said:
[ … ]

If a documentary were to be made about Darwin and did not refer to the
fact that some people [1] claim that he was racist and eugenicist,
even an encouragement to Naziism, would you regard that as
hagiography?
 [1] Some people NOT including me.
When has anyone not ignorant of the reality claimed that? Or anyone knowing the reality but lying about it? The creationist Denyse O'Leary has claimed this on the basis that the full title of The Origin of Species includes the words "favoured races". She claimed this despite knowing perfectly well that Darwin was not talking about human races, but about animal varieties. We wouldn't use "races" in that sense today, but that's irrelevant.
So, to answer your question, no, I don't think that a Darwin documentary is obliged  to mention what idiots and liars have said.
And no, I woudn't call it a hagiography.
--
Athel -- French and British, living in Marseilles for 37 years; mainly in England until 1987.

Date Sujet#  Auteur
18 May 24 * Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary75Martin Harran
18 May 24 +* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary73*Hemidactylus*
18 May 24 i+* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary65erik simpson
18 May 24 ii+- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1*Hemidactylus*
19 May 24 ii+* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary55DB Cates
19 May 24 iii`* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary54Martin Harran
19 May 24 iii +* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary2*Hemidactylus*
20 May 24 iii i`- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1Martin Harran
19 May 24 iii +* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary2Athel Cornish-Bowden
19 May 24 iii i`- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1Martin Harran
19 May 24 iii `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary49DB Cates
20 May 24 iii  `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary48Martin Harran
21 May 24 iii   `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary47DB Cates
23 May 24 iii    `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary46Martin Harran
23 May 24 iii     +* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary44*Hemidactylus*
23 May 24 iii     i+- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1Martin Harran
23 May 24 iii     i`* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary42Martin Harran
23 May 24 iii     i `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary41*Hemidactylus*
23 May 24 iii     i  `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary40Martin Harran
24 May 24 iii     i   +* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary38*Hemidactylus*
27 May 24 iii     i   i+* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary36Martin Harran
27 May 24 iii     i   ii`* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary35*Hemidactylus*
27 May 24 iii     i   ii +* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary32erik simpson
27 May 24 iii     i   ii i+* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary3DB Cates
27 May 24 iii     i   ii ii+- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1erik simpson
29 May 24 iii     i   ii ii`- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1*Hemidactylus*
27 May 24 iii     i   ii i`* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary28*Hemidactylus*
27 May 24 iii     i   ii i +* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary7erik simpson
29 May 24 iii     i   ii i i`* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary6Martin Harran
29 May 24 iii     i   ii i i +* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary2erik simpson
30 May 24 iii     i   ii i i i`- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1Martin Harran
29 May 24 iii     i   ii i i `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary3*Hemidactylus*
30 May 24 iii     i   ii i i  `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary2Martin Harran
31 May 24 iii     i   ii i i   `- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1*Hemidactylus*
30 May 24 iii     i   ii i `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary20Martin Harran
30 May 24 iii     i   ii i  `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary19*Hemidactylus*
31 May 24 iii     i   ii i   `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary18Martin Harran
1 Jun 24 iii     i   ii i    `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary17*Hemidactylus*
1 Jun 24 iii     i   ii i     `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary16Martin Harran
1 Jun 24 iii     i   ii i      +* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary11*Hemidactylus*
2 Jun 24 iii     i   ii i      i`* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary10Martin Harran
2 Jun 24 iii     i   ii i      i `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary9*Hemidactylus*
2 Jun 24 iii     i   ii i      i  `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary8Martin Harran
2 Jun 24 iii     i   ii i      i   `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary7*Hemidactylus*
4 Jun 24 iii     i   ii i      i    `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary6Martin Harran
4 Jun 24 iii     i   ii i      i     `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary5*Hemidactylus*
4 Jun 24 iii     i   ii i      i      `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary4Martin Harran
5 Jun 24 iii     i   ii i      i       `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary3*Hemidactylus*
5 Jun 24 iii     i   ii i      i        `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary2Martin Harran
6 Jun 24 iii     i   ii i      i         `- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1Athel Cornish-Bowden
2 Jun 24 iii     i   ii i      `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary4Mark Isaak
2 Jun 24 iii     i   ii i       +- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1Martin Harran
2 Jun 24 iii     i   ii i       `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary2Martin Harran
2 Jun 24 iii     i   ii i        `- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1*Hemidactylus*
30 May 24 iii     i   ii +- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1Martin Harran
2 Jun 24 iii     i   ii `- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1Martin Harran
27 May 24 iii     i   i`- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1Martin Harran
24 May 24 iii     i   `- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1jillery
24 May 24 iii     `- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1DB Cates
19 May 24 ii`* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary8J. J. Lodder
19 May 24 ii `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary7erik simpson
20 May 24 ii  +* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary4Kerr-Mudd, John
20 May 24 ii  i+* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary2erik simpson
20 May 24 ii  ii`- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1J. J. Lodder
21 May 24 ii  i`- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1John Harshman
21 May 24 ii  `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary2Martin Harran
21 May 24 ii   `- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1Kerr-Mudd, John
19 May 24 i`* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary7Martin Harran
19 May 24 i `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary6*Hemidactylus*
19 May 24 i  `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary5Martin Harran
19 May 24 i   `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary4*Hemidactylus*
19 May 24 i    `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary3Martin Harran
19 May 24 i     `* Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary2*Hemidactylus*
20 May 24 i      `- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1Martin Harran
6 Jun 24 `- Re: Teilhard de Chardin - new documentary1Martin Harran

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal