Lincoln's Letter to the Editor of the N,Y, Tribune

Liste des GroupesRevenir à t origins 
Sujet : Lincoln's Letter to the Editor of the N,Y, Tribune
De : rondean-noreply (at) *nospam* gmail.com (Ron Dean)
Groupes : talk.origins
Date : 22. May 2024, 01:25:38
Autres entêtes
Organisation : Public Usenet Newsgroup Access
Message-ID : <7Ya3O.2266$gKW1.1925@fx13.iad>
References : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26
User-Agent : Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 13.4; rv:91.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/91.0 SeaMonkey/2.53.18.2
I do not doubt that slavery was a cause of the US Civil War, but it was President Lincoln's expressed primary objective as he wrote to the editor of the New York Tribune was to Preserve the Union. It was the South's fear that Lincoln would free the slaves, but it appears, based on the letter he wrote  to the editor of the New York newspaper, that this was a misjudgement by the South of Lincoln and his objective.
The institution had existed f0r over 2 centuries in the South, the question is would there have
been war had the South _n0t_ succeeded? The succession of Carolina followed by the attack on Ft. Sumter started the Civil War.
I had read, believed and defended the opinion that unfair tariffs imposed on the South was the main cause of the war, but this was proven wrong, in spite of the cites on the net advocating this fraud.
Lincoln's Letter to the editor of the New York Newspaper was written 1n August 22, 1862,  ab0ut a year and a half after the start of the War between the States:
Picture
Mathew Brady Photographs of Civil War-Era Personalities and Scenes, National Archives and Records Administration
Hon. Horace Greely: Executive Mansion,
Dear Sir Washington, August 22, 1862.
I have just read yours of the 19th. addressed to myself through the New-York Tribune. If there be in it any statements, or assumptions of fact, which I may know to be erroneous, I do not, now and here, controvert them. If there be in it any inferences which I may believe to be falsely drawn, I do not now and here, argue against them. If there be perceptable in it an impatient and dictatorial tone, I waive it in deference to an old friend, whose heart I have always supposed to be right.
As to the policy I “seem to be pursuing” as you say, I have not meant to leave any one in doubt.
I would save the Union. I would save it the shortest way under the Constitution. The sooner the national authority can be restored; the nearer the Union will be “the Union as it was.” If there be those who would not save the Union, unless they could at the same time save slavery, I do not agree with them. If there be those who would not save the Union unless they could at the same time destroy slavery, I do not agree with them. _My_paramount_object_in_this_struggle_is_to_ save_ the_ Union_, and is not either to save or to destroy slavery. If I could save the Union without freeing any slave I would do it, and if I could save it by freeing all the slaves I would do it; and if I could save it by freeing some and leaving others alone I would also do that. What I do about slavery, and the colored race, I do because I believe it helps to save the Union; and what I forbear, I forbear because I do not believe it would help to save the Union. I shall do less whenever I shall believe what I am doing hurts the cause, and I shall do more whenever I shall believe doing more will help the cause. I shall try to correct errors when shown to be errors; and I shall adopt new views so fast as they shall appear to be true views.
I have here stated my purpose according to my view of official duty; and I intend no modification of my oft-expressed personal wish that all men every where could be free. Yours,
A. LINCOLN
http://lincolnandemancipation.weebly.com/letter-to-horace-greeley-1862.html

Date Sujet#  Auteur
22 Mar 24 * West Virginia creationism386RonO
22 Mar 24 `* Re: West Virginia creationism385Bob Casanova
22 Mar 24  +* Re: West Virginia creationism4Athel Cornish-Bowden
22 Mar 24  i+- Re: West Virginia creationism1Bob Casanova
23 Mar 24  i`* Re: West Virginia creationism2jillery
23 Mar 24  i `- Re: West Virginia creationism1RonO
30 Mar 24  `* Re: West Virginia creationism380Ron Dean
30 Mar 24   +* Re: West Virginia creationism370erik simpson
30 Mar 24   i`* Re: West Virginia creationism369Ron Dean
30 Mar 24   i +* Re: West Virginia creationism2Ron Dean
31 Mar 24   i i`- Re: West Virginia creationism1Ernest Major
30 Mar 24   i +- Re: West Virginia creationism1erik simpson
31 Mar 24   i +* Re: West Virginia creationism355jillery
2 Apr 24   i i`* Re: West Virginia creationism354Ron Dean
3 Apr 24   i i +* Re: West Virginia creationism252jillery
5 Apr 24   i i i+* Re: West Virginia creationism2JTEM
6 Apr 24   i i ii`- Re: West Virginia creationism1jillery
10 Apr 24   i i i`* Re: West Virginia creationism249Ron Dean
10 Apr 24   i i i `* Re: West Virginia creationism248Vincent Maycock
11 Apr 24   i i i  `* Re: West Virginia creationism247Ron Dean
12 Apr 24   i i i   `* Re: West Virginia creationism246Vincent Maycock
12 Apr 24   i i i    `* Re: West Virginia creationism245Ron Dean
12 Apr 24   i i i     +* Re: West Virginia creationism15Vincent Maycock
12 Apr 24   i i i     i+* Re: West Virginia creationism5Ron Dean
13 Apr 24   i i i     ii+* Re: West Virginia creationism3Vincent Maycock
14 Apr 24   i i i     iii`* Re: West Virginia creationism2Ron Dean
14 Apr 24   i i i     iii `- Re: West Virginia creationism1Vincent Maycock
20 Apr 24   i i i     ii`- Re: West Virginia creationism1Mark Isaak
13 Apr 24   i i i     i`* Re: West Virginia creationism9Bob Casanova
13 Apr 24   i i i     i +* Re: West Virginia creationism5Arkalen
13 Apr 24   i i i     i i`* Re: West Virginia creationism4Bob Casanova
10 May 24   i i i     i i `* Re: West Virginia creationism3Arkalen
11 May 24   i i i     i i  +- Re: West Virginia creationism1Bob Casanova
11 May 24   i i i     i i  `- Re: West Virginia creationism1jillery
14 Apr 24   i i i     i `* Re: West Virginia creationism3Ron Dean
14 Apr 24   i i i     i  `* Re: West Virginia creationism2Arkalen
15 Apr 24   i i i     i   `- Re: West Virginia creationism1Bob Casanova
13 Apr 24   i i i     `* Re: West Virginia creationism229Martin Harran
14 Apr 24   i i i      `* Re: West Virginia creationism228Ron Dean
14 Apr 24   i i i       +- Re: West Virginia creationism1Jim Jackson
17 Apr 24   i i i       +* Re: West Virginia creationism225Martin Harran
18 Apr 24   i i i       i`* Re: West Virginia creationism224Ron Dean
18 Apr 24   i i i       i +* Re: West Virginia creationism2Vincent Maycock
19 Apr 24   i i i       i i`- Re: West Virginia creationism1Athel Cornish-Bowden
22 Apr 24   i i i       i `* Re: West Virginia creationism221Martin Harran
22 Apr 24   i i i       i  `* Re: West Virginia creationism220Ron Dean
22 Apr 24   i i i       i   +* Re: West Virginia creationism199Vincent Maycock
26 Apr 24   i i i       i   i`* Re: West Virginia creationism198Ron Dean
26 Apr 24   i i i       i   i +- Re: West Virginia creationism1John Harshman
26 Apr 24   i i i       i   i +* Re: West Virginia creationism142Vincent Maycock
6 May 24   i i i       i   i i`* Re: West Virginia creationism141Ron Dean
7 May 24   i i i       i   i i `* Re: West Virginia creationism140Vincent Maycock
7 May 24   i i i       i   i i  +* Re: West Virginia creationism138Ron Dean
7 May 24   i i i       i   i i  i+* Re: West Virginia creationism136Vincent Maycock
8 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii`* Re: West Virginia creationism135Ron Dean
8 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii +* Re: West Virginia creationism5jillery
9 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii i`* Re: West Virginia creationism4Ron Dean
11 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii i `* Re: West Virginia creationism3jillery
13 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii i  `* Re: West Virginia creationism2Ron Dean
13 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii i   `- Re: West Virginia creationism1jillery
8 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii `* Re: West Virginia creationism129Vincent Maycock
8 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii  `* Re: West Virginia creationism128Ron Dean
8 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   +* Re: West Virginia creationism100Vincent Maycock
10 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i`* Re: West Virginia creationism99Ron Dean
10 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i +- Re: West Virginia creationism1John Harshman
10 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i +* Re: West Virginia creationism15Vincent Maycock
10 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i`* Re: West Virginia creationism14Ron Dean
11 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i +* Re: West Virginia creationism11Vincent Maycock
12 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i`* Re: West Virginia creationism10Ron Dean
12 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i +* Re: West Virginia creationism3Vincent Maycock
13 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i i`* Re: West Virginia creationism2Ron Dean
13 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i i `- Re: West Virginia creationism1Vincent Maycock
13 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i `* Re: West Virginia creationism6Burkhard
14 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i  +- Re: West Virginia creationism1John Harshman
14 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i  +- Re: West Virginia creationism1Athel Cornish-Bowden
14 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i  +* Re: West Virginia creationism2William Hyde
15 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i  i`- Re: West Virginia creationism1Athel Cornish-Bowden
14 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i  `- Re: West Virginia creationism1Martin Harran
11 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i `* Re: West Virginia creationism2jillery
13 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i  `- Re: West Virginia creationism1Ron Dean
10 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i +* Re: West Virginia creationism79Burkhard
10 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i+- Re: West Virginia creationism1Athel Cornish-Bowden
10 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i`* Re: West Virginia creationism77Ron Dean
11 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i +* Re: West Virginia creationism65Chris Thompson
11 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i+* Re: West Virginia creationism2John Harshman
12 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i ii`- Re: West Virginia creationism1Chris Thompson
11 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i+* Re: West Virginia creationism6William Hyde
12 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i ii+* Re: West Virginia creationism2Chris Thompson
12 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i iii`- Re: West Virginia creationism1FromTheRafters
12 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i ii`* Re: West Virginia creationism3Ernest Major
12 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i ii `* Re: West Virginia creationism2erik simpson
12 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i ii  `- Re: West Virginia creationism1Bob Casanova
12 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i`* Re: West Virginia creationism56Ron Dean
13 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i `* Re: West Virginia creationism55Chris Thompson
13 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i  +* Re: West Virginia creationism51Ron Dean
13 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i  i`* Re: West Virginia creationism50Chris Thompson
13 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i  i `* Re: West Virginia creationism49Ernest Major
14 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i  i  `* Re: West Virginia creationism48Chris Thompson
14 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i  i   `* Re: West Virginia creationism47Ernest Major
15 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i  i    `* Re: West Virginia creationism46Ron Dean
16 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i  i     `* Re: West Virginia creationism45Chris Thompson
14 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i i  `* Re: West Virginia creationism3Burkhard
12 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i +- Re: West Virginia creationism1Burkhard
14 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i i `* Re: West Virginia creationism10Martin Harran
10 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   i `* Re: West Virginia creationism3Burkhard
8 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   +* Re: West Virginia creationism14John Harshman
9 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   +- Re: West Virginia creationism1Ernest Major
13 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   +- Re: West Virginia creationism1Burkhard
14 May 24   i i i       i   i i  ii   `* Re: West Virginia creationism11Martin Harran
8 May 24   i i i       i   i i  i`- Re: West Virginia creationism1Ernest Major
8 May 24   i i i       i   i i  `- Re: West Virginia creationism1Ernest Major
26 Apr 24   i i i       i   i `* Re: West Virginia creationism54Ernest Major
23 Apr 24   i i i       i   +* Re: West Virginia creationism17jillery
25 Apr 24   i i i       i   `* Re: West Virginia creationism3Martin Harran
20 Apr 24   i i i       `- Re: West Virginia creationism1Mark Isaak
3 Apr 24   i i +- Re: West Virginia creationism1Burkhard
3 Apr 24   i i `* Re: West Virginia creationism100Ernest Major
31 Mar 24   i +* Re: West Virginia creationism4Mark Isaak
5 Apr 24   i `* Re: West Virginia creationism6Arkalen
30 Mar 24   +* Re: West Virginia creationism7Burkhard
3 Apr 24   `* Re: West Virginia creationism2Richmond

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal