Re: From the Archives .....

Liste des Groupes 
Sujet : Re: From the Archives .....
De : agamemnon (at) *nospam* hello.to.NO_SPAM (The True Doctor)
Groupes : rec.arts.drwho
Date : 23. Apr 2024, 13:02:55
Autres entêtes
Organisation : A noiseless patient Spider
Message-ID : <v0881g$1ju4d$2@dont-email.me>
References : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
User-Agent : Mozilla Thunderbird
On 22/04/2024 11:40, Daniel70 wrote:
The True Doctor wrote on 21/4/24 10:45 am:
On 21/04/2024 01:21, Blueshirt wrote:
The Doctor wrote:
In article <xn0okt4k1cdpbe1000@post.eweka.nl>,
Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
The True Doctor wrote:
>
Morbius is winning the game because his faces are on the
screen indicating that the more past regenerations you have
had the stronger your mind becomes in the game. Hinchcliffe
didn't write the story, it was Dicks.
>
Robert Holmes re-wrote the script as you well know and it was
the intent of the Production team of that story that those
were the faces of the Doctor. When you watched "The Brain of
Morbius" as a child, that was the intent behind that scene.
This is a simple fact that has been mentioned many times
over the years by members of the production team (whose
faces they actually were) and it is easily researched.
>
Terrance Dicks - like some fans - did not like the idea of
pre-Hartnell Doctors, so revised it in his novelisation. So
yes, in the Target novel they are the faces of Morbius.
>
There has been plenty of interviews with Uncle Terrance over
the years where he explained why he changed it. But him not
liking the idea of pre-Hartnell Doctors is the short
version! He was aware of the original intent behind that
scene in the episode though and has often talked about it.
>
I go with 4 Doctors taking on Morbius!
>
You can take from that scene whatever you like... it doesn't
change the way the scene was conceived. There is no Doctor Who
bible so whatever works for you and your enjoyment of the show
is fine. We are all free to make our own head-canon.
>
What there is are established facts. No regenerations existed before Hartnell as stated by Hartnell in The Tenth Planet and the 1st Doctor in The Five Doctors.
 Hey, Aggy, in "An Unearthly Child" or any of the other William Hartnell Episodes, did DoctorBill state that he was the First Incarnation of The Doctor or that he could, in fact, regenerate (pick a number, any number) of times at all?? Did he mention that ability at any time during his reign??
It was implied from the very beginning that the character Hartnell played was like any other human, other than the fact that he was a fugitive from another world, as was his biological grand daughter Susan.

 Or was this "ability" ONLY mentioned AFTER Bill Hartnell had left??
His possession of ability to perform bodily renewal is stated by Hartnell in at the end of The Tenth Planet, as is the fact that he did not know if it would work since he'd never had to perform it before, just before he is shown to rejuvenate himself. Troughton was intended to be a de-aged version of Hartnell.
When Troughton is interrogated by the Time Lords at the end of The War Games no past forms of the Doctor are shown except those of Troughton and Hartnell. In The Three Doctors it is also demonstrated that there are were only ever 3 incarnations of the Doctor at this time, and Hartnell was the earliest. Same goes for The Five Doctors. Same goes for the Doctor's memories in The Family of Blood. Same goes for The Eleventh Hour. Same goes for Listen. Same goes for Twice Upon A Time.
--
The True Doctor https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCngrZwoS0n21IRcXpKO79Lw
"To be woke is to be uninformed which is exactly the opposite of what it stands for." -William Shatner

Date Sujet#  Auteur
19 Apr 24 * From the Archives .....132Daniel70
19 Apr 24 +* Re: From the Archives .....119The True Doctor
19 Apr 24 i+* Re: From the Archives .....22The True Doctor
21 Apr 24 ii`* Re: From the Archives .....21The True Doctor
22 Apr 24 ii `* Re: From the Archives .....20Daniel70
23 Apr 24 ii  +- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
24 Apr 24 ii  `* Re: From the Archives .....18The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 ii   +* Re: From the Archives .....2Idlehands
25 Apr 24 ii   i`- Re: From the Archives .....1Idlehands
25 Apr 24 ii   `* Re: From the Archives .....15Daniel70
26 Apr 24 ii    +* Re: From the Archives .....2The True Doctor
26 Apr 24 ii    i`- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
26 Apr 24 ii    +* Re: From the Archives .....4The True Doctor
26 Apr 24 ii    i`* Re: From the Archives .....3The True Doctor
28 Apr 24 ii    i `* Re: From the Archives .....2The True Doctor
28 Apr 24 ii    i  `- Re: From the Archives .....1solar penguin
26 Apr 24 ii    +* Re: From the Archives .....4The True Doctor
26 Apr 24 ii    i+* Re: From the Archives .....2Idlehands
26 Apr 24 ii    ii`- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
26 Apr 24 ii    i`- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
26 Apr 24 ii    +- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
26 Apr 24 ii    `* Re: From the Archives .....3Daniel70
26 Apr 24 ii     `* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70
27 Apr 24 ii      `- Re: From the Archives .....1Idlehands
19 Apr 24 i+* Re: From the Archives .....2The True Doctor
20 Apr 24 ii`- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
20 Apr 24 i`* Re: From the Archives .....94The Last Doctor
20 Apr 24 i +* Re: From the Archives .....7The Last Doctor
20 Apr 24 i i`* Re: From the Archives .....6The Last Doctor
21 Apr 24 i i `* Re: From the Archives .....5The Last Doctor
21 Apr 24 i i  +- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
21 Apr 24 i i  `* Re: From the Archives .....3The Last Doctor
22 Apr 24 i i   `* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70
23 Apr 24 i i    `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
20 Apr 24 i `* Re: From the Archives .....86The True Doctor
21 Apr 24 i  +* Re: From the Archives .....6The True Doctor
22 Apr 24 i  i+- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
22 Apr 24 i  i+* Re: From the Archives .....3Daniel70
22 Apr 24 i  ii`* Re: From the Archives .....2The True Doctor
23 Apr 24 i  ii `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
22 Apr 24 i  i`- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
21 Apr 24 i  +* Re: From the Archives .....78The True Doctor
22 Apr 24 i  i+* Re: From the Archives .....16Daniel70
23 Apr 24 i  ii+- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
23 Apr 24 i  ii`* Re: From the Archives .....14The True Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  ii +* Re: From the Archives .....11The Last Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  ii i+* Re: From the Archives .....5The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  ii ii`* Re: From the Archives .....4The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  ii ii `* Re: From the Archives .....3Daniel70
25 Apr 24 i  ii ii  `* Re: From the Archives .....2solar penguin
26 Apr 24 i  ii ii   `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
24 Apr 24 i  ii i+* Re: From the Archives .....2The Last Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  ii ii`- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  ii i+- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  ii i`* Re: From the Archives .....2The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  ii i `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
24 Apr 24 i  ii +- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  ii `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
23 Apr 24 i  i`* Re: From the Archives .....61The True Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  i +* Re: From the Archives .....59The Last Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  i i`* Re: From the Archives .....58The True Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  i i +* Re: From the Archives .....47The Last Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  i i i+* Re: From the Archives .....45The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  i i ii`* Re: From the Archives .....44The Last Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  i i ii +* Re: From the Archives .....24The True Doctor
26 Apr 24 i  i i ii i`* Re: From the Archives .....23The Last Doctor
26 Apr 24 i  i i ii i `* Re: From the Archives .....22The True Doctor
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii i  `* Re: From the Archives .....21Blueshirt
28 Apr 24 i  i i ii i   `* Re: From the Archives .....20The True Doctor
28 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    +* Re: From the Archives .....6The Last Doctor
28 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    i+* Re: From the Archives .....4The True Doctor
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    ii+- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    ii`* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    ii `- Re: From the Archives .....1Idlehands
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    i`- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
28 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    +- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii i    `* Re: From the Archives .....12The True Doctor
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     +* Re: From the Archives .....7Idlehands
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i`* Re: From the Archives .....6The True Doctor
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i `* Re: From the Archives .....5Idlehands
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i  `* Re: From the Archives .....4The True Doctor
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i   `* Re: From the Archives .....3Idlehands
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i    `* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i     `- Re: From the Archives .....1Idlehands
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     +* Re: From the Archives .....3The True Doctor
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i`* Re: From the Archives .....2solar penguin
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     i `- Re: From the Archives .....1solar penguin
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii i     `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
25 Apr 24 i  i i ii `* Re: From the Archives .....19The True Doctor
26 Apr 24 i  i i ii  +* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70
26 Apr 24 i  i i ii  i`- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii  +* Re: From the Archives .....6Idlehands
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii  i+- Re: From the Archives .....1Idlehands
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii  i`* Re: From the Archives .....4Blueshirt
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii  i +* Re: From the Archives .....2Idlehands
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii  i i`- Re: From the Archives .....1%
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii  i `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii  `* Re: From the Archives .....10The True Doctor
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii   +* Re: From the Archives .....5Daniel70
29 Apr 24 i  i i ii   i`* Re: From the Archives .....4Daniel70
30 Apr 24 i  i i ii   i `* Re: From the Archives .....3Daniel70
27 Apr 24 i  i i ii   `* Re: From the Archives .....4The True Doctor
24 Apr 24 i  i i i`- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
25 Apr 24 i  i i `* Re: From the Archives .....10solar penguin
24 Apr 24 i  i `- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
21 Apr 24 i  `- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
22 Apr 24 +* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70
23 Apr 24 +- Re: From the Archives .....1The True Doctor
27 Apr 24 +- Re: From the Archives .....1Blueshirt
30 Apr 24 +* Re: From the Archives .....5Daniel70
30 Apr 24 +- Re: From the Archives .....1Daniel70
1 May 24 `* Re: From the Archives .....2Daniel70

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal