Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?

Liste des GroupesRevenir à theory 
Sujet : Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?
De : polcott333 (at) *nospam* gmail.com (olcott)
Groupes : comp.theory
Date : 20. Jul 2024, 15:49:28
Autres entêtes
Organisation : A noiseless patient Spider
Message-ID : <v7gipo$3iu15$2@dont-email.me>
References : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
User-Agent : Mozilla Thunderbird
On 7/20/2024 4:30 AM, Mikko wrote:
On 2024-07-19 14:46:19 +0000, olcott said:
 
On 7/19/2024 4:07 AM, Mikko wrote:
On 2024-07-17 13:30:07 +0000, olcott said:
>
On 7/17/2024 2:49 AM, Mikko wrote:
On 2024-07-16 14:20:09 +0000, olcott said:
>
On 7/16/2024 3:32 AM, Mikko wrote:
On 2024-07-15 13:26:22 +0000, olcott said:
>
On 7/15/2024 3:23 AM, Mikko wrote:
On 2024-07-14 14:38:31 +0000, olcott said:
>
On 7/14/2024 3:09 AM, Mikko wrote:
On 2024-07-13 20:15:56 +0000, olcott said:
>
typedef void (*ptr)();
int HHH(ptr P);
>
void Infinite_Loop()
{
   HERE: goto HERE;
}
>
void Infinite_Recursion()
{
   Infinite_Recursion();
}
>
void DDD()
{
   HHH(DDD);
}
>
int main()
{
   HHH(Infinite_Loop);
   HHH(Infinite_Recursion);
   HHH(DDD);
}
>
Any input that must be aborted to prevent the non
termination of HHH necessarily specifies non-halting
behavior or it would never need to be aborted.
>
Everyone understands that DDD specifies a halting behaviour if HHH(DDD) does,
>
>
*You can comprehend this is a truism or fail to*
*comprehend it disagreement is necessarily incorrect*
Any input that must be aborted to prevent the non
termination of HHH necessarily specifies non-halting
behavior or it would never need to be aborted.
>
Disagreeing with the above is analogous to disagreeing
with arithmetic.
>
That the input is aborted does not mean that the input must be aborted.
>
Weasel words. This is an axiom:
Input XXX must be aborted to prevent the non-termination of HHH.
>
That is not an acceptable axiom. That you are unable to prove that
either XXX is aborted or HHH does not terminate is insufficient
reason to call it an axiom.
>
>
*Premise* (assumed to be true)
Any input that must be aborted to prevent
the non termination of HHH
>
*Logically entailed by the above premise*
necessarily specifies non-halting behavior or
it would never need to be aborted.
>
No, it is not. Both "need to be" and "must be" are different from "is".
The correct asxiom is "If the program can be executed to its halting in
a finite time then the program specifies a halting behaviour."
>
From the fact that XXX must be aborted we can conclude that XXX must be aborted.
>
Nothing that contains the word "must" is a fact.
>
>
When simulated input X stops running {if and only if}
the simulation of this input X has been aborted this
necessitates that input X specifies non-halting behavior.
>
Nothing that contains the word "necessitates" is a fact, either.
Perhaps you should learn some philosophy.
>
>
<MIT Professor Sipser agreed to ONLY these verbatim words 10/13/2022>
     If simulating halt decider H correctly simulates its input D
     until H correctly determines that its simulated D would never
     stop running unless aborted then
>
     H can abort its simulation of D and correctly report that D
     specifies a non-halting sequence of configurations.
</MIT Professor Sipser agreed to ONLY these verbatim words 10/13/2022>
>
_DDD()
[00002163] 55         push ebp      ; housekeeping
[00002164] 8bec       mov ebp,esp   ; housekeeping
[00002166] 6863210000 push 00002163 ; push DDD
[0000216b] e853f4ffff call 000015c3 ; call HHH(DDD)
[00002170] 83c404     add esp,+04
[00002173] 5d         pop ebp
[00002174] c3         ret
Size in bytes:(0018) [00002174]
>
DDD emulated by HHH according to the semantic meaning of
its x86 instructions never stops running unless aborted.
>
That Professor Sipser does not express any agreement with anything
about the syntax of facts is not relevant to our (or any) discussion
about syntax of facts.
>
>
void DDD()
{
   HHH(DDD);
}
>
int main()
{
   DDD();
}
>
<MIT Professor Sipser agreed to ONLY these verbatim words 10/13/2022>
     If simulating halt decider H correctly simulates its input D
     until H correctly determines that its simulated D would never
     stop running unless aborted then
>
     H can abort its simulation of D and correctly report that D
     specifies a non-halting sequence of configurations.
</MIT Professor Sipser agreed to ONLY these verbatim words 10/13/2022>
>
int main { DDD(); } calls HHH(DDD) that must abort the
emulation of its input or HHH, emulated DDD and executed DDD
never stop running.
 If HHH can detect that a part of the code to be emulated ie HHH itself it
may skip the emulation of itself and continue from the return. The knowledge
that HHH always terminates can be coded in HHH. Therefore the abortion is
not necessary.
 
In other words you are suggesting that HHH lies and
makes pretend that recursive emulation does not exist.
_DDD()
[00002163] 55         push ebp      ; housekeeping
[00002164] 8bec       mov ebp,esp   ; housekeeping
[00002166] 6863210000 push 00002163 ; push DDD
[0000216b] e853f4ffff call 000015c3 ; call HHH(DDD)
[00002170] 83c404     add esp,+04
[00002173] 5d         pop ebp
[00002174] c3         ret
Size in bytes:(0018) [00002174]
--
Copyright 2024 Olcott "Talent hits a target no one else can hit; Genius
hits a target no one else can see." Arthur Schopenhauer

Date Sujet#  Auteur
13 Jul 24 * Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?172olcott
13 Jul 24 +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?1Richard Damon
14 Jul 24 `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?170Mikko
14 Jul 24  `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?169olcott
14 Jul 24   +* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?154Richard Damon
15 Jul 24   i`* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?153olcott
15 Jul 24   i `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?152Richard Damon
15 Jul 24   i  `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?151olcott
15 Jul 24   i   `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?150Richard Damon
15 Jul 24   i    `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?149olcott
15 Jul 24   i     `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?148Richard Damon
15 Jul 24   i      +* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?111olcott
15 Jul 24   i      i+* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?4Richard Damon
15 Jul 24   i      ii`* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?3olcott
15 Jul 24   i      ii +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?1Fred. Zwarts
16 Jul 24   i      ii `- OLCOTT ADMITS TO LYING1Richard Damon
15 Jul 24   i      i+* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?48Fred. Zwarts
15 Jul 24   i      ii`* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?47olcott
16 Jul 24   i      ii +- OLCOTT ADMITS TO LYING FOR YEARS1Richard Damon
16 Jul 24   i      ii +* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?40olcott
16 Jul 24   i      ii i`* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?39Richard Damon
16 Jul 24   i      ii i `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?38olcott
16 Jul 24   i      ii i  +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?1joes
17 Jul 24   i      ii i  +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?1Richard Damon
17 Jul 24   i      ii i  `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?35Mikko
17 Jul 24   i      ii i   `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?34olcott
18 Jul 24   i      ii i    +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?1Richard Damon
19 Jul 24   i      ii i    `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?32Mikko
19 Jul 24   i      ii i     `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine31olcott
19 Jul 24   i      ii i      +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine1Richard Damon
19 Jul 24   i      ii i      +* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine9joes
19 Jul 24   i      ii i      i`* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine8olcott
19 Jul 24   i      ii i      i +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine1Richard Damon
20 Jul 24   i      ii i      i `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine6André G. Isaak
20 Jul 24   i      ii i      i  `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine5olcott
20 Jul 24   i      ii i      i   +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine1Richard Damon
20 Jul 24   i      ii i      i   `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine3André G. Isaak
20 Jul 24   i      ii i      i    `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine2olcott
20 Jul 24   i      ii i      i     `- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine1Richard Damon
20 Jul 24   i      ii i      `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine20Mikko
20 Jul 24   i      ii i       `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine19olcott
20 Jul 24   i      ii i        +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine1Richard Damon
20 Jul 24   i      ii i        +* Re: Self-Modifying Turing Machine3joes
20 Jul 24   i      ii i        i`* Re: Self-Modifying Turing Machine2olcott
20 Jul 24   i      ii i        i `- Re: Self-Modifying Turing Machine1Richard Damon
21 Jul 24   i      ii i        `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine14Mikko
21 Jul 24   i      ii i         `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine13olcott
21 Jul 24   i      ii i          +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine1Richard Damon
21 Jul 24   i      ii i          +* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine2joes
21 Jul 24   i      ii i          i`- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine1Richard Damon
22 Jul 24   i      ii i          `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine9Mikko
22 Jul 24   i      ii i           `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine8olcott
23 Jul 24   i      ii i            `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine7Mikko
23 Jul 24   i      ii i             `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine6olcott
24 Jul 24   i      ii i              +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine1Richard Damon
25 Jul 24   i      ii i              `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine4Mikko
25 Jul 24   i      ii i               `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine3olcott
26 Jul 24   i      ii i                +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine1Richard Damon
26 Jul 24   i      ii i                `- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Self-Modifying Turing Machine1Mikko
16 Jul 24   i      ii `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?5Fred. Zwarts
16 Jul 24   i      ii  +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?1Richard Damon
16 Jul 24   i      ii  `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?3olcott
16 Jul 24   i      ii   +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?1Fred. Zwarts
17 Jul 24   i      ii   `- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?1Richard Damon
16 Jul 24   i      i`* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?58Mikko
16 Jul 24   i      i `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?57olcott
17 Jul 24   i      i  +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?1Richard Damon
17 Jul 24   i      i  `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?55Mikko
17 Jul 24   i      i   `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?54olcott
17 Jul 24   i      i    +* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?26Fred. Zwarts
17 Jul 24   i      i    i`* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?25olcott
17 Jul 24   i      i    i +* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?23Fred. Zwarts
17 Jul 24   i      i    i i`* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?22olcott
17 Jul 24   i      i    i i +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?1joes
18 Jul 24   i      i    i i +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?1Richard Damon
18 Jul 24   i      i    i i `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?19Fred. Zwarts
18 Jul 24   i      i    i i  `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?18olcott
19 Jul 24   i      i    i i   +* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?7Fred. Zwarts
19 Jul 24   i      i    i i   i`* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?6olcott
19 Jul 24   i      i    i i   i +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?1Richard Damon
20 Jul 24   i      i    i i   i `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?4Fred. Zwarts
20 Jul 24   i      i    i i   i  `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?3olcott
20 Jul 24   i      i    i i   i   +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?1Richard Damon
20 Jul 24   i      i    i i   i   `- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?1Fred. Zwarts
19 Jul 24   i      i    i i   `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?10Mikko
19 Jul 24   i      i    i i    `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?9olcott
19 Jul 24   i      i    i i     +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?1Richard Damon
20 Jul 24   i      i    i i     +* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?4Fred. Zwarts
20 Jul 24   i      i    i i     i`* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Honest Dialogue3olcott
20 Jul 24   i      i    i i     i +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Honest Dialogue1Richard Damon
20 Jul 24   i      i    i i     i `- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Honest Dialogue1Fred. Zwarts
20 Jul 24   i      i    i i     `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?3Mikko
20 Jul 24   i      i    i i      `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Honest Dialogue2olcott
20 Jul 24   i      i    i i       `- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true? --- Honest Dialogue1Fred. Zwarts
18 Jul 24   i      i    i `- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?1Richard Damon
17 Jul 24   i      i    +* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?21joes
17 Jul 24   i      i    i`* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?20olcott
17 Jul 24   i      i    i +* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?18joes
17 Jul 24   i      i    i i`* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?17olcott
18 Jul 24   i      i    i i `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?16joes
18 Jul 24   i      i    i i  `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?15olcott
18 Jul 24   i      i    i `- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?1Richard Damon
18 Jul 24   i      i    +- Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?1Richard Damon
19 Jul 24   i      i    `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?5Mikko
15 Jul 24   i      `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?36olcott
15 Jul 24   `* Re: Who here understands that the last paragraph is Necessarily true?14Mikko

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal