Den 27.06.2025 05:47, skrev Bertitaylor:
On Thu, 26 Jun 2025 13:23:35 +0000, Paul.B.Andersen wrote:
Den 26.06.2025 09:15, skrev bertitaylor:
On Wed, 25 Jun 2025 17:30:27 +0000, Jim Pennino wrote:
>
In sci.physics Bertitaylor <bertietaylor@myyahoo.com> wrote:
On Mon, 23 Jun 2025 18:54:15 +0000, Paul.B.Andersen wrote:
>
Can you please explain Arindam's theory?
>
Where does the radiated energy come from?
>
Deuterium fission.
>
>
Deuterium is stable, does not undergo radioactive decay, and thus cannot
undergo fission, crackpot.
>
Fool, we are not talking about deuterium on Earth, decaying naturally.
Things are different in the Sun's atmosphere. Lots of heat, radiation,
charged particles, very dense there.
>
And no deuterium is decaying, but a lot of deuterium nuclei are fused
to Helium.
>
It is deuterium fission which provides the energy for the hydrogen bombs
on Earth.
>
Good grief, what a gigantic blunder!
Yes it was the most gigantic blunder to think that fusion at all
happens.
>
One question:
What created the elements you and I and everything around us consist of?
The Devine Arindam?
>
It obviously is _fusion_ of H and T in a hydrogen bomb.
Very not obviously. The fission of the deuterium nucleus (two protons
held by one electron) creates extraordinary force creating great
energies as produced by the stars.
A nucleus consisting of two protons and one electron? :-D
But let's consider this a typo.
Deuterium (D) is an isotope of hydrogen.
It has an extra neutron in its nucleus. D is stable and never decays.
But let's play along:
Fission of D can only mean that a neutron is ejected from the nucleus.
So the question is:
Why should this create an extraordinary great energy?
Let's first look at fission of a heavier element, namely Uranium-235.
When a Uranium-235 nucleus is hit by a neutron, it may split
into a Barium-141 nucleus and a Krypton-92 nucleus and three neutrons.
So why do this fission create an extraordinary great energy?
It's actually very simple.
The Ba-141 nucleus contains 56 protons and 85 neutrons
The Kr-92 nucleus contains 36 protons and 56 neutrons
The electrostatic repulsion between the nuclei is very strong,
and in 1939 Lise Meitner calculated that the nuclei will repel
each other and should gain a total kinetic energy in the order
of 200 MeV. The rest is history.
Lise Meitner was the mother of the atomic bomb.
The proton and the neutron in D do not repel each other,
so no energy is released if you somehow could split the nucleus.
Quite the contrary, you would have to use energy to split it.
Your "Deuterium fission" is idiotic nonsense.
--------------------------------------------
BTW, this reaction also confirms E = mc²
1n + U-235 → Ba-141 + Kr-92 + 3n
The atomic weight of these are:
Left side:
1n 1.008664 u
U-235 235.0439299 u
-------------------
236.0525939 u
Right side:
Ba-141 140.914412 u
Kr-92 91.926156 u
3n 3.025992 u
---------------------
235.866560 u
Lost mass: m = 0.1860339 u
"u" is "unified atomic mass unit", 1 u = 931.5 MeV
E = mc² ≈ 174 MeV
Which is of the same order of magnitude as calculated
by Meitner.
Details in Arindam's links.
Quite. I had a look.
Arindam:
"The hydrogen bomb is said to be an atomic bomb using heavy water,
that contain the deuterium isotope. A deuterium isotope has an
additional neutron in its nucleus. It is thought that the enormous
temperature generated by the fission bomb, cause the deuterium isotopes
to join and become helium nuclei. And it is this fusion process, that
generates so much more energy than even the atom bomb."
So Arindam knows how the hydrogen bomb is "said" to work,
but he has his own story, of course:
Arindam:
"So could it be that there is actually no process like fusion
ever taking place – that fusion is a wrong explanation?
The extraordinary energy of the Hydrogen Bomb could arise with
the heavy water being used as a amplifier of the fission bomb.
The N value, then, effectively goes up! What may be likely is that
the deuterium nuclei in the heavy water - a necessary component of
the hydrogen bomb as it is supposed to fuse into helium - when
bombarded by the exploding fission components of the atom bomb that
has to be exploded first to create the high temperatures need for
fusion, take up very high speeds and thus act like an extension of
the fissionable components. In other words, they effectively add up
upon, or amplify upon as a catalyst, the radioactive material already
present in the bomb."
I can't see that he mention fission of deuterium.
But I can see that he states:
"there is actually no process like fusion"
And I can see that he states:
"the atom bomb that has to be exploded first to create
the high temperatures need for fusion"
And I can see that he doesn't make any sense at all.
Can you explain how the hydrogen bomb works, Bertitaylor?
-- Paulhttps://paulba.no/
…