Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?

Liste des GroupesRevenir à c theory 
Sujet : Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?
De : ldo (at) *nospam* nz.invalid (Lawrence D'Oliveiro)
Groupes : comp.theory sci.logic
Date : 04. Apr 2024, 07:54:00
Autres entêtes
Organisation : A noiseless patient Spider
Message-ID : <uulf9o$fl5c$1@dont-email.me>
References : 1 2 3
User-Agent : Pan/0.155 (Kherson; fc5a80b8)
On Thu, 4 Apr 2024 00:50:14 -0500, olcott wrote:

On 4/4/2024 12:18 AM, Lawrence D'Oliveiro wrote:
>
On Tue, 2 Apr 2024 11:50:50 -0500, olcott wrote:
 
A truth without a truthmaker is like a cake without a baker,
non-existent.
 
Where does the truthmaker come from?
 
An analytic truthmaker is any expression of language derived from
expressions that are stipulated to be true. These are usually the
definitions providing the semantic meanings of terms.

So “truthmaker” is a matter of definition? A set of “axioms of truth”, if
you like?

Date Sujet#  Auteur
2 Apr 24 * Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?49olcott
3 Apr 24 +- Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?1Richard Damon
4 Apr 24 +* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?45Lawrence D'Oliveiro
4 Apr 24 i`* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?44olcott
4 Apr 24 i `* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?43Lawrence D'Oliveiro
4 Apr 24 i  `* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?42olcott
5 Apr 24 i   `* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?41Lawrence D'Oliveiro
5 Apr 24 i    `* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?40olcott
6 Apr 24 i     `* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?39Lawrence D'Oliveiro
6 Apr 24 i      +* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?20olcott
6 Apr 24 i      i+* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?9Lawrence D'Oliveiro
6 Apr 24 i      ii+* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?6Fred. Zwarts
6 Apr 24 i      iii+- Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?1Richard Damon
6 Apr 24 i      iii`* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?4olcott
7 Apr 24 i      iii `* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?3Fred. Zwarts
7 Apr 24 i      iii  +- Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?1Ross Finlayson
7 Apr 24 i      iii  `- Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?1olcott
6 Apr 24 i      ii`* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?2olcott
6 Apr 24 i      ii `- Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?1Richard Damon
6 Apr 24 i      i+- Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?1Richard Damon
7 Apr 24 i      i+- Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?1olcott
13 Apr 24 i      i+- Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?1Ross Finlayson
27 Apr 24 i      i`* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?7Lawrence D'Oliveiro
27 Apr 24 i      i +- Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?1Ross Finlayson
27 Apr 24 i      i `* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?5olcott
27 Apr 24 i      i  `* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?4Ross Finlayson
27 Apr 24 i      i   `* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?3olcott
27 Apr 24 i      i    `* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?2Ross Finlayson
27 Apr 24 i      i     `- Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?1olcott
6 Apr 24 i      `* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?18Mikko
6 Apr 24 i       +* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?9olcott
6 Apr 24 i       i+- Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?1Richard Damon
7 Apr 24 i       i+* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?3Lawrence D'Oliveiro
7 Apr 24 i       ii`* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?2olcott
7 Apr 24 i       ii `- Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?1Richard Damon
7 Apr 24 i       i`* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?4Fred. Zwarts
7 Apr 24 i       i +- Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?1olcott
27 Apr 24 i       i `* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?2Lawrence D'Oliveiro
27 Apr 24 i       i  `- Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?1Ross Finlayson
7 Apr 24 i       `* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?8Lawrence D'Oliveiro
7 Apr 24 i        `* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?7olcott
7 Apr 24 i         `* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?6Fred. Zwarts
7 Apr 24 i          `* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?5olcott
8 Apr 24 i           `* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?4Fred. Zwarts
8 Apr 24 i            +- Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?1Richard Damon
8 Apr 24 i            `* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?2olcott
9 Apr 24 i             `- Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?1Richard Damon
10 Apr 24 `* Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?2olcott
10 Apr 24  `- Re: Can there be a truth without a truthmaker?1Richard Damon

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal