Re: [SR and synchronization] Cognitive Dissonances and Mental Blockage

Den 27.08.2024 12:40, skrev Richard Hachel:

 In short, its abysmal bullshit to believe that light (electromagnetic interaction) occurs at speed c in all directions, without taking into account the POSITION of the observer and the PERSONAL REALITY of his hyperplane of present time is abysmal bullshit.
 What proves to me that the speed of light, of information, is the same in all directions, if I am based on a hyperplane of present time,
and by the same as that of the transmitter?
However, is it not obvious that in all cases, the transverse speed of light will be equal to c, in all directions of a frontal plane?
>

Well said, Richard!
One can but be impressed of your ability to clearly explain
your genial theory.
----------------
Remember this?
Den 24.08.2024 14:24, skrev Richard Hachel:

 What happens if I set two identical watches on my table and I slowly move one of them towards the moon.
(let's say in three weeks to avoid a v²/c² ratio very different from 1)?

We agreed that the watch on your table and the lunar watch
still would be synchronous.
Den 24.08.2024 14:24, skrev Richard Hachel:

 I notice in my telescope that when my watch marks
00:00'08" the lunar clock is desynchronized and marks 00:00'07".

When I asked why this mean that the clocks are
desynchronised, you explained:
Den 25.08.2024 14:34, skrev Richard Hachel:

 The beautiful thing is to say that "photons move at c".
The genius is to say that transactions are instantaneous, and that it is men's ignorance of the correct space-time that creates this illusion.
It is really 00:00'07" over there, at the very moment
when it is 00:00'08" here.

This made me ask:
Considering that transactions are instantaneous,
why do you say that the picture you see in the telescope
is 00:00'07", when it obviously should be 00:00'08"?
Den 26.08.2024 13:02, skrev Richard Hachel:

 Ah, but here is my explanation! Thank you sir!
There is a one-second time difference between 00:00:08 and 00:00:07", between my watch and the watch on the moon.
This is because of the speed of light, which is quite slow, and takes at least a second to reach me.
And so that explains everything.
It's magnificent, I understand better.
 

So we can sum it up:
Since the speed of light is slow (c), the light will use 1 second
to go from the Moon to Richards telescope.
So the picture of the watch in the telescope will show 00:00'07"
when the lunar watch shows 00:00'08".
But since the speed of light is infinite and the picture of
the watch in the telescope show 00:00'07", the lunar watch
is really 00:00'07" at the very moment when the watch on
Richard's table is 00:00'08".
Well explained, Richard!
It is all clear when we take into account the POSITION of
the observer and the PERSONAL REALITY of his hyperplane
of present time.
--
Paul
https://paulba.no/