Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies

Liste des GroupesRevenir à s logic 
Sujet : Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies
De : polcott333 (at) *nospam* gmail.com (olcott)
Groupes : comp.theory sci.logic
Date : 21. Jun 2024, 04:29:26
Autres entêtes
Organisation : A noiseless patient Spider
Message-ID : <v52oi7$2v5s6$2@dont-email.me>
References : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26
User-Agent : Mozilla Thunderbird
On 6/20/2024 8:55 PM, Richard Damon wrote:
On 6/20/24 6:52 PM, olcott wrote:
On 6/20/2024 5:48 PM, joes wrote:
Am Wed, 19 Jun 2024 21:25:31 -0500 schrieb olcott:
On 6/19/2024 9:17 PM, Richard Damon wrote:
On 6/19/24 10:02 PM, olcott wrote:
On 6/19/2024 8:39 PM, Richard Damon wrote:
On 6/19/24 8:44 PM, olcott wrote:
On 6/19/2024 7:23 PM, Richard Damon wrote:
On 6/19/24 9:00 AM, olcott wrote:
On 6/19/2024 3:08 AM, Fred. Zwarts wrote:
Op 18.jun.2024 om 18:26 schreef olcott:
On 6/18/2024 10:47 AM, Fred. Zwarts wrote:
Op 18.jun.2024 om 17:33 schreef olcott:
On 6/18/2024 10:20 AM, Fred. Zwarts wrote:
>
It is easier to understand because a print statement was added.
You proved that it halts, but H0 reports non-halting.
So, it produces a false negative.
So, now it has been proved that H, H0, etc produce false
negatives, when used to determine halting behaviour, please, stop
to call them halt-deciders, or termination-deciders.
They might be "simulation deciders". When returning true, the
simulation was correct, when false, the full simulation was not
possible.
>
Why does H0 NEED to be able to simulate its input?
Yeah, why? That just adds a contradictory requirement. Not that it were
possible otherwise.
>
Decider must compute the mapping from their finite string input to
the actual behavior that this finite string specifies.
If possible.
They are not free to imagine the behavior that the authors of
textbooks expect.
Nor crackpots.
>
The finite string input does not communicate the behavior that the
textbook authors expect it to communicate.
Bullshit. Your neither-decider-nor-simulator just can't handle it.
The direct execution of DDD is the measure of things. A simulation
must behave identically. Of course you may be able to do analysis
on whether it halts, but that's different. Simulation is dumb.
>
The finite string certainly DOES communicate what is needed to
determine the behavior, or it wasn't a correct representation.
Deflection follows:
There is no sequence of truth preserving operations from the finite
string machine code of DDD that can correctly ignore the pathological
relationship between H0 and DDD as an aspect of the behavior that this
finite string specifies.
Many other simulators or deciders work correctly with DDD, just not the
one it calls. But they each get a different one wrong.
What do you mean with "ignore the relationship"?
>
No one has noticed this before because no one ever thought to make every
single detail 100% concrete, thus leaving huge gaps in all prior
reasoning.
We have a proof.
>
>
You have dogmatic false assumptions.
It is an verified fact that the input to H(D,D) cannot
be mapped to the behavior of D(D).
  ????
 But the Halting Function does that map.
 
I ask you to show the detailed steps of that map and
you always dodge. This leads me to believe that you
know you are lying.
_DDD()
[00002093] 55               push ebp
[00002094] 8bec             mov ebp,esp
[00002096] 6893200000       push 00002093 ; push DDD
[0000209b] e853f4ffff       call 000014f3 ; call HH0
[000020a0] 83c404           add esp,+04
[000020a3] 5d               pop ebp
[000020a4] c3               ret
Size in bytes:(0018) [000020a4]
--
Copyright 2024 Olcott "Talent hits a target no one else can hit; Genius
hits a target no one else can see." Arthur Schopenhauer

Date Sujet#  Auteur
17 Jun 24 * Simulating termination analyzers for dummies115olcott
17 Jun 24 `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies114Fred. Zwarts
17 Jun 24  `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies113olcott
17 Jun 24   +* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies44Fred. Zwarts
17 Jun 24   i`* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies43olcott
17 Jun 24   i `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies42Fred. Zwarts
17 Jun 24   i  `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies41olcott
17 Jun 24   i   `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies40Fred. Zwarts
17 Jun 24   i    `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies39olcott
18 Jun 24   i     `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies38Fred. Zwarts
18 Jun 24   i      `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies37olcott
18 Jun 24   i       +* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies3Python
18 Jun 24   i       i`* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies2olcott
19 Jun 24   i       i `- Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies1Richard Damon
18 Jun 24   i       +* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies32Fred. Zwarts
18 Jun 24   i       i`* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies31olcott
18 Jun 24   i       i +* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies27Fred. Zwarts
18 Jun 24   i       i i`* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies26olcott
18 Jun 24   i       i i +* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies2Python
18 Jun 24   i       i i i`- Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies1olcott
19 Jun 24   i       i i `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies23Fred. Zwarts
19 Jun 24   i       i i  `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies22olcott
19 Jun 24   i       i i   +* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies5Fred. Zwarts
19 Jun 24   i       i i   i`* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies4olcott
19 Jun 24   i       i i   i `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies3Fred. Zwarts
19 Jun 24   i       i i   i  `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies2olcott
20 Jun 24   i       i i   i   `- Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies1Fred. Zwarts
20 Jun 24   i       i i   `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies16Richard Damon
20 Jun 24   i       i i    `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies15olcott
20 Jun 24   i       i i     `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies14Richard Damon
20 Jun 24   i       i i      `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies13olcott
20 Jun 24   i       i i       `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies12Richard Damon
20 Jun 24   i       i i        `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies11olcott
20 Jun 24   i       i i         +* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies3Richard Damon
20 Jun 24   i       i i         i`* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies2olcott
21 Jun 24   i       i i         i `- Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies1Richard Damon
21 Jun 24   i       i i         `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies7joes
21 Jun 24   i       i i          `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies6olcott
21 Jun 24   i       i i           +* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies2joes
21 Jun 24   i       i i           i`- Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies1olcott
21 Jun 24   i       i i           `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies3Richard Damon
21 Jun 24   i       i i            `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies2olcott
21 Jun 24   i       i i             `- Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies1Richard Damon
18 Jun 24   i       i +* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies2Python
18 Jun 24   i       i i`- Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies1olcott
19 Jun 24   i       i `- Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies1Richard Damon
19 Jun 24   i       `- Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies1Richard Damon
18 Jun 24   `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies68Richard Damon
18 Jun 24    `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies67olcott
18 Jun 24     `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies66Richard Damon
18 Jun 24      `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies65olcott
18 Jun 24       `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies64Richard Damon
18 Jun 24        `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies63olcott
18 Jun 24         `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies62Richard Damon
18 Jun 24          `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies61olcott
18 Jun 24           `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies60Richard Damon
18 Jun 24            `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies59olcott
18 Jun 24             +* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies57Richard Damon
18 Jun 24             i`* Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies56olcott
18 Jun 24             i +* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies54joes
18 Jun 24             i i`* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?53olcott
18 Jun 24             i i +* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?15joes
18 Jun 24             i i i+* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?5olcott
18 Jun 24             i i ii`* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?4joes
18 Jun 24             i i ii `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?3olcott
19 Jun 24             i i ii  `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?2joes
19 Jun 24             i i ii   `- Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- test of dishonesty1olcott
18 Jun 24             i i i`* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?9olcott
18 Jun 24             i i i `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?8Alan Mackenzie
22 Jun 24             i i i  `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?7olcott
22 Jun 24             i i i   `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?6Richard Damon
22 Jun 24             i i i    `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- criteria is met5olcott
22 Jun 24             i i i     +* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- criteria is met3Richard Damon
22 Jun 24             i i i     i`* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- criteria is met2olcott
22 Jun 24             i i i     i `- Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- criteria is met1Richard Damon
22 Jun 24             i i i     `- Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- criteria is met1joes
19 Jun 24             i i +* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?23Richard Damon
19 Jun 24             i i i`* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?22olcott
19 Jun 24             i i i +* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?17Richard Damon
19 Jun 24             i i i i`* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?16olcott
19 Jun 24             i i i i +* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?5joes
19 Jun 24             i i i i i`* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?4olcott
19 Jun 24             i i i i i `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?3joes
19 Jun 24             i i i i i  `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- the only reply until addressed2olcott
19 Jun 24             i i i i i   `- Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- the only reply until addressed1joes
19 Jun 24             i i i i `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?10Richard Damon
19 Jun 24             i i i i  `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?9olcott
19 Jun 24             i i i i   +* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?7joes
19 Jun 24             i i i i   i+* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?2olcott
20 Jun 24             i i i i   ii`- Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?1Richard Damon
19 Jun 24             i i i i   i`* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?4olcott
19 Jun 24             i i i i   i +* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?2joes
19 Jun 24             i i i i   i i`- Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?1olcott
20 Jun 24             i i i i   i `- Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?1Richard Damon
20 Jun 24             i i i i   `- Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?1Richard Damon
19 Jun 24             i i i `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?4joes
19 Jun 24             i i i  `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?3olcott
19 Jun 24             i i i   +- Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?1joes
20 Jun 24             i i i   `- Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?1Richard Damon
19 Jun 24             i i `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?14Fred. Zwarts
19 Jun 24             i i  `* Re: Simulating termination analyzers by dummies --- What does halting mean?13olcott
19 Jun 24             i `- Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies1Richard Damon
18 Jun 24             `- Re: Simulating termination analyzers for dummies1Python

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal