Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?

Liste des GroupesRevenir à s logic 
Sujet : Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?
De : F.Zwarts (at) *nospam* HetNet.nl (Fred. Zwarts)
Groupes : comp.theory sci.logic
Date : 23. Mar 2024, 18:31:57
Autres entêtes
Organisation : A noiseless patient Spider
Message-ID : <utn05t$3o86u$2@dont-email.me>
References : 1 2 3 4 5
User-Agent : Mozilla Thunderbird
Op 23.mrt.2024 om 17:08 schreef olcott:
On 3/23/2024 9:43 AM, Fred. Zwarts wrote:
Op 23.mrt.2024 om 14:58 schreef olcott:
On 3/23/2024 4:38 AM, Fred. Zwarts wrote:
Op 22.mrt.2024 om 19:41 schreef olcott:
01 int D(ptr x)  // ptr is pointer to int function
02 {
03   int Halt_Status = H(x, x);
04   if (Halt_Status)
05     HERE: goto HERE;
06   return Halt_Status;
07 }
08
09 void main()
10 {
11   H(D,D);
12 }
>
H is a simulating abort decider that supposed to
correctly determine whether or not it needs to abort
the simulation of any pathological inputs that are
attempting to thwart this abort decision.
>
H must abort every simulated input that would not
otherwise halt to prevent its own non-termination.
>
It is a self-evident verified fact that every H(D,D)
that decides to abort its simulated D(D) is correct
in doing so because this does prevent its own
non-termination.
>
>
It is self-evident that when H is programmed to abort and return false, then [the simulated] D will
>
immediately stop running never having reached its last instruction to halt.
>
As can be seen above, if H returns false in line 03, then D will go to line 04 and line 06 and halt (unless aborted).
>
 You still do not understand that functions called in infinite
recursion never return to their caller, thus must have grossly
exaggerated your programming skill.
Even a beginner in C will see that if the simulated D, using the H that is programmed to abort and return false, will continue with line 04 then line 06 and halt (unless aborted).

When the simulated D calls its simulator this call cannot possibly
return to its caller. The relationship between the simulated D(D)
and its simulator makes a call D(D) to its own simulator isomorphic
to infinite recursion.
It is exactly the relation with the simulator that aborts, which makes that also the simulated H is programmed to abort and return false.
Olcott is again contradicting himself.

 That the directly executed D(D) is an entirely different instance
that does not have this same pathological relationship is summed
up in your own reply.
I am not talking about a directly executed D, but a simulated D!
I am not talking about a directly executed D, but a simulated D!
I am not talking about a directly executed D, but a simulated D!
This simulated D halts (unless aborted)!
It seems too difficult for olcott to see, what even a beginner sees, that H, programmed to return false, also returns false when simulated (unless aborted).

Date Sujet#  Auteur
22 Mar 24 * Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?93olcott
22 Mar 24 +* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?9wij
22 Mar 24 i`* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?8olcott
22 Mar 24 i `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?7wij
22 Mar 24 i  `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?6olcott
22 Mar 24 i   `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?5wij
22 Mar 24 i    `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?4olcott
22 Mar 24 i     `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?3immibis
22 Mar 24 i      `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?2olcott
22 Mar 24 i       `- Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?1immibis
22 Mar 24 +- Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?1wij
22 Mar 24 +* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?11immibis
22 Mar 24 i`* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?10olcott
22 Mar 24 i `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?9immibis
22 Mar 24 i  `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?8olcott
22 Mar 24 i   `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?7immibis
22 Mar 24 i    `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?6olcott
23 Mar 24 i     `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?5immibis
23 Mar 24 i      `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?4olcott
23 Mar 24 i       `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?3immibis
23 Mar 24 i        `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?2olcott
23 Mar 24 i         `- Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?1Richard Damon
23 Mar 24 +* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?7Richard Damon
23 Mar 24 i`* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?6olcott
23 Mar 24 i `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?5Richard Damon
23 Mar 24 i  `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?4olcott
23 Mar 24 i   `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?3Richard Damon
23 Mar 24 i    `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?2olcott
23 Mar 24 i     `- Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?1Richard Damon
23 Mar 24 +* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?60Fred. Zwarts
23 Mar 24 i`* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?59olcott
23 Mar 24 i +- Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?1Richard Damon
23 Mar 24 i `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?57Fred. Zwarts
23 Mar 24 i  `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?56olcott
23 Mar 24 i   +* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?54Fred. Zwarts
23 Mar 24 i   i`* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?53olcott
23 Mar 24 i   i `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?52Fred. Zwarts
23 Mar 24 i   i  +* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?50olcott
23 Mar 24 i   i  i+* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?10Fred. Zwarts
23 Mar 24 i   i  ii`* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?9olcott
23 Mar 24 i   i  ii +* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?7Richard Damon
23 Mar 24 i   i  ii i`* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?6olcott
23 Mar 24 i   i  ii i `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?5Richard Damon
24 Mar 24 i   i  ii i  `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?4olcott
24 Mar 24 i   i  ii i   `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?3Richard Damon
24 Mar 24 i   i  ii i    `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?2olcott
24 Mar 24 i   i  ii i     `- Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?1Richard Damon
24 Mar 24 i   i  ii `- Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?1immibis
24 Mar 24 i   i  i`* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?39immibis
25 Mar 24 i   i  i `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?38olcott
26 Mar 24 i   i  i  `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?37Richard Damon
26 Mar 24 i   i  i   `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?36olcott
26 Mar 24 i   i  i    `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?35Richard Damon
26 Mar 24 i   i  i     `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?34olcott
26 Mar 24 i   i  i      +* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?29Richard Damon
26 Mar 24 i   i  i      i`* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?28olcott
26 Mar 24 i   i  i      i `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?27Richard Damon
26 Mar 24 i   i  i      i  `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?26olcott
26 Mar 24 i   i  i      i   `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?25Richard Damon
26 Mar 24 i   i  i      i    `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?24olcott
26 Mar 24 i   i  i      i     `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?23Richard Damon
26 Mar 24 i   i  i      i      `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?22olcott
26 Mar 24 i   i  i      i       `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?21Richard Damon
26 Mar 24 i   i  i      i        `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?20olcott
27 Mar 24 i   i  i      i         `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?19Richard Damon
27 Mar 24 i   i  i      i          `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?18olcott
28 Mar 24 i   i  i      i           `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?17Richard Damon
28 Mar 24 i   i  i      i            `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?16olcott
28 Mar 24 i   i  i      i             `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?15Richard Damon
28 Mar 24 i   i  i      i              `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?14olcott
28 Mar 24 i   i  i      i               `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?13Richard Damon
28 Mar 24 i   i  i      i                `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?12olcott
28 Mar 24 i   i  i      i                 `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?11Richard Damon
28 Mar 24 i   i  i      i                  `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?10olcott
28 Mar 24 i   i  i      i                   `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?9Richard Damon
28 Mar 24 i   i  i      i                    `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?8olcott
29 Mar 24 i   i  i      i                     `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?7Richard Damon
29 Mar 24 i   i  i      i                      `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?6olcott
29 Mar 24 i   i  i      i                       `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?5Richard Damon
29 Mar 24 i   i  i      i                        `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?4olcott
29 Mar 24 i   i  i      i                         `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?3Richard Damon
29 Mar 24 i   i  i      i                          `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?2olcott
29 Mar 24 i   i  i      i                           `- Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?1Richard Damon
26 Mar 24 i   i  i      +* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?2Fred. Zwarts
26 Mar 24 i   i  i      i`- Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?1olcott
26 Mar 24 i   i  i      `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?2Fred. Zwarts
26 Mar 24 i   i  i       `- Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?1olcott
24 Mar 24 i   i  `- Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?1immibis
23 Mar 24 i   `- Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?1Richard Damon
26 Mar 24 `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?4Mikko
26 Mar 24  `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?3olcott
27 Mar 24   `* Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?2Mikko
27 Mar 24    `- Re: Can any pathological input thwart a simulating abort decider?1olcott

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal