Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies

Liste des GroupesRevenir à s logic 
Sujet : Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies
De : mikko.levanto (at) *nospam* iki.fi (Mikko)
Groupes : sci.logic
Date : 01. May 2024, 11:06:44
Autres entêtes
Organisation : -
Message-ID : <v0t0n4$32utt$1@dont-email.me>
References : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32
User-Agent : Unison/2.2
On 2024-04-30 16:06:08 +0000, olcott said:

On 4/30/2024 7:01 AM, Mikko wrote:
On 2024-04-29 15:22:11 +0000, olcott said:
 
On 4/29/2024 10:04 AM, Mikko wrote:
On 2024-04-29 14:32:13 +0000, olcott said:
 
On 4/29/2024 4:24 AM, Mikko wrote:
On 2024-04-28 13:24:52 +0000, olcott said:
 
Translated into a syllogism:
 All A are True
No A are True
Therefore B
 Which inference rule of syllogistic logic permits that inference?
 
 (1) That is a correct translation from this POE argument:
Proposition A is True.
Proposition A is False.
Therefore B
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_explosion
 (2) That as a syllogism it is the non-sequitur error proves
that the POE was the non-sequitur error all along.
 What you call a "syllogism" isn't one as it has none of the forms
of valid syllogism as listed by Aristotle.
 
 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Categorical_proposition
 That page does not tell what a syllogism is. Instead, the page
   https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syllogism
does.
 
 This is the part of the page on syllogism that links to that link
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syllogism#Basic_structure
THat's right. That section says what the form of a syllogism is.
Your "syllogism" has not that form.
--
Mikko

Date Sujet#  Auteur
18 Apr 24 * Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2323olcott
18 Apr 24 +* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2262Richard Damon
18 Apr 24 i`* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2261olcott
19 Apr 24 i `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2260Richard Damon
19 Apr 24 i  `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2259olcott
19 Apr 24 i   `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2258Richard Damon
19 Apr 24 i    +* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V256olcott
19 Apr 24 i    i+* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V25Richard Damon
19 Apr 24 i    ii`* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V24olcott
19 Apr 24 i    ii `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V23Richard Damon
19 Apr 24 i    ii  `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V22olcott
20 Apr 24 i    ii   `- Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V21Richard Damon
20 Apr 24 i    i`* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V250Mikko
20 Apr 24 i    i `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--49olcott
20 Apr 24 i    i  +- Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--1Richard Damon
21 Apr 24 i    i  `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--47Mikko
21 Apr 24 i    i   `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--46olcott
21 Apr 24 i    i    +- Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--1Richard Damon
21 Apr 24 i    i    +- Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--1Richard Damon
22 Apr 24 i    i    `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--43Mikko
22 Apr 24 i    i     +* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--10olcott
22 Apr 24 i    i     i+* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--5Mikko
22 Apr 24 i    i     ii`* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--4olcott
23 Apr 24 i    i     ii `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--3Mikko
23 Apr 24 i    i     ii  `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--2olcott
24 Apr 24 i    i     ii   `- Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--1Mikko
23 Apr 24 i    i     i`* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--4Richard Damon
23 Apr 24 i    i     i `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--3olcott
24 Apr 24 i    i     i  +- Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--1Richard Damon
24 Apr 24 i    i     i  `- Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--1Mikko
23 Apr 24 i    i     `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--32olcott
24 Apr 24 i    i      `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--31Mikko
24 Apr 24 i    i       `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--30olcott
25 Apr 24 i    i        `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--29Mikko
25 Apr 24 i    i         `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--28olcott
26 Apr 24 i    i          `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--27Mikko
26 Apr 24 i    i           `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--26olcott
26 Apr 24 i    i            +- Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--1Richard Damon
26 Apr 24 i    i            +* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--7Ross Finlayson
26 Apr 24 i    i            i`* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--6olcott
26 Apr 24 i    i            i `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--5Richard Damon
26 Apr 24 i    i            i  `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--4Ross Finlayson
26 Apr 24 i    i            i   `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--3olcott
26 Apr 24 i    i            i    `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--2Richard Damon
26 Apr 24 i    i            i     `- Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--1Ross Finlayson
27 Apr 24 i    i            `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--17Mikko
27 Apr 24 i    i             `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--16olcott
28 Apr 24 i    i              `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--15Mikko
28 Apr 24 i    i               `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--14olcott
29 Apr 24 i    i                `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--13Mikko
29 Apr 24 i    i                 `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--12olcott
29 Apr 24 i    i                  `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--11Mikko
29 Apr 24 i    i                   `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--10olcott
30 Apr 24 i    i                    `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--9Mikko
30 Apr 24 i    i                     `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--8olcott
1 May 24 i    i                      `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--7Mikko
1 May 24 i    i                       `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--6olcott
2 May 24 i    i                        `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--5Mikko
2 May 24 i    i                         `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--4olcott
3 May 24 i    i                          `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--3Mikko
3 May 24 i    i                           `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--2olcott
4 May 24 i    i                            `- Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Mendelson--1Mikko
19 Apr 24 i    +* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V22olcott
20 Apr 24 i    i`- Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V21Richard Damon
19 Apr 24 i    `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Tarski Proof--199olcott
20 Apr 24 i     +* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Tarski Proof--3Richard Damon
20 Apr 24 i     i`* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Tarski Proof--2olcott
20 Apr 24 i     i `- Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Tarski Proof--1Richard Damon
20 Apr 24 i     `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Tarski Proof--195Mikko
20 Apr 24 i      `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Tarski Proof--194olcott
20 Apr 24 i       +* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Tarski Proof--3Richard Damon
21 Apr 24 i       i`* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Tarski Proof--2olcott
21 Apr 24 i       i `- Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Tarski Proof--1Richard Damon
21 Apr 24 i       `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Tarski Proof--190Mikko
21 Apr 24 i        `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Tarski Proof--189olcott
22 Apr 24 i         `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Tarski Proof--188Mikko
22 Apr 24 i          `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Tarski Proof--187olcott
22 Apr 24 i           `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Tarski Proof--186Mikko
22 Apr 24 i            +- Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Tarski Proof--1olcott
22 Apr 24 i            `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Tarski Proof--184olcott
23 Apr 24 i             `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Tarski Proof--183Mikko
23 Apr 24 i              `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Tarski Proof--182olcott
24 Apr 24 i               `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --Tarski Proof--181Mikko
24 Apr 24 i                `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --H(D,D)--180olcott
25 Apr 24 i                 +* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --H(D,D)--149Richard Damon
25 Apr 24 i                 i`* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --H(D,D)--148olcott
25 Apr 24 i                 i +* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --H(D,D)--10Richard Damon
25 Apr 24 i                 i i`* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --H(D,D)--9olcott
25 Apr 24 i                 i i `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --H(D,D)--8Richard Damon
25 Apr 24 i                 i i  `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --H(D,D)--7olcott
25 Apr 24 i                 i i   `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --H(D,D)--6Richard Damon
25 Apr 24 i                 i i    +* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --H(D,D)--2olcott
25 Apr 24 i                 i i    i`- Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --H(D,D)--1Richard Damon
25 Apr 24 i                 i i    +* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --H(D,D)--2olcott
25 Apr 24 i                 i i    i`- Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --H(D,D)--1Richard Damon
25 Apr 24 i                 i i    `- Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --H(D,D)--1Ross Finlayson
25 Apr 24 i                 i `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --H(D,D)--137Mikko
25 Apr 24 i                 i  `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --H(D,D)--136olcott
26 Apr 24 i                 i   +- Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --H(D,D)--1Richard Damon
26 Apr 24 i                 i   `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --H(D,D)--134Mikko
26 Apr 24 i                 i    +* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --H(D,D)--26olcott
26 Apr 24 i                 i    `* D simulated by H never halts no matter what H does107olcott
25 Apr 24 i                 `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V2 --H(D,D)--30Mikko
18 Apr 24 +* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V254olcott
18 Apr 24 `* Re: Undecidability based on epistemological antinomies V26olcott

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal