Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics

Liste des GroupesRevenir à sp relativity 
Sujet : Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics
De : nospam (at) *nospam* de-ster.demon.nl (J. J. Lodder)
Groupes : sci.physics.relativity
Date : 17. Mar 2024, 12:45:50
Autres entêtes
Organisation : De Ster
Message-ID : <1qqjdh9.1pen0glzuxdjN%nospam@de-ster.demon.nl>
References : 1 2 3
User-Agent : MacSOUP/2.8.5 (ea919cf118) (Mac OS 10.12.6)
LaurenceClarkCrossen <clzb93ynxj@att.net> wrote:

I think non-Euclidean geometry is recognizable as necessarily involving
the reification fallacy, so it is not true. It is necessary to attribute
qualities to abstract space to suppose that parallel lines meet. Contrary
to Tom Roberts, in physics, one cannot use models that involve reification
fallacy because they cannot account for causation.

FYI, all this talk of // lines meeting at infinity is obsolete.
In modern presentations Euclidean geometry is defined
as that geometry in which the Pythagorean theorem holds.
The intersection at infinity, or better non-intersetction in the finite
can then be proven as a theorem.

The two definitions can be shown to be equivalent,

Jan
 

Date Sujet#  Auteur
16 Mar 24 * Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics28J. J. Lodder
16 Mar 24 +* Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics6LaurenceClarkCrossen
17 Mar 24 i`* Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics5J. J. Lodder
17 Mar 24 i `* Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics4J. J. Lodder
18 Mar 24 i  `* Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics3Ross Finlayson
18 Mar 24 i   `* Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics2Ross Finlayson
18 Mar 24 i    `- Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics1Ross Finlayson
16 Mar 24 `* Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics21LaurenceClarkCrossen
17 Mar 24  `* Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics20J. J. Lodder
17 Mar 24   +- Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics1LaurenceClarkCrossen
17 Mar 24   +* Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics6LaurenceClarkCrossen
17 Mar 24   i`* Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics5J. J. Lodder
17 Mar 24   i +* Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics3Athel Cornish-Bowden
18 Mar 24   i i`* Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics2J. J. Lodder
18 Mar 24   i i `- Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics1LaurenceClarkCrossen
18 Mar 24   i `- Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics1LaurenceClarkCrossen
19 Mar 24   `* Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics12LaurenceClarkCrossen
19 Mar 24    `* Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics11J. J. Lodder
19 Mar 24     +- Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics1LaurenceClarkCrossen
19 Mar 24     +* Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics3LaurenceClarkCrossen
19 Mar 24     i`* Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics2Ross Finlayson
20 Mar 24     i `- Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics1palsing
24 Mar 24     `* Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics6LaurenceClarkCrossen
24 Mar 24      `* Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics5J. J. Lodder
24 Mar 24       +- Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics1Ross Finlayson
25 Mar 24       `* Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics3LaurenceClarkCrossen
25 Mar 24        +- Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics1Kajal Kumari Choudhary
26 Mar 24        `- Re: New addition to the list of Relativity Critics/Skeptics1J. J. Lodder

Haut de la page

Les messages affichés proviennent d'usenet.

NewsPortal