Re: On Arindam Banerjee's recoil-less rail gun and Newton's 3rd Law violations in electrodynamics

Volney wrote:

On 5/2/2024 3:51 AM, J. J. Lodder wrote:

Volney <volney@invalid.invalid> wrote:
 

On 4/27/2024 5:50 AM, J. J. Lodder wrote:

bertietaylor <bertietaylor@myyahoo.com> wrote:
>

>
That is not the case, so this is a new discovery - the Lorentz force

does

NOT have an equal and opposite reaction. Your point is merely

theoretical.

My evidence is experimental.

>
Correct, merely experimental.
It stands falsified by a reliable theory.
>
FYI, the Maxwell-Lorentz equations as they stand
do conserve energy-momentum.
If you want to be taken seriously it is up to you
to tell the world what is wrong with Maxwell-Lorentz,
and how these equations must be modified.
>
As long as you can't do that you are merely an incompetent tinkerer,
>

>
It is entirely possible that Banjo stumbled across that apparent
violation of momentum by momentum being carried away by the
electromagnetic field.

No Arindam found that inertia gets violated with his new design rail gun.
Which justifies his new physics that he developed from 1998.

If the momentum is carried away by the electromagnetic fiel
there is still momentum conservation.

No ifs with the experiments of Arindam which show inertia violation by
arrest of the gravy rail gun bullet. With cyclic action this gun turned
motor will reach faster than light speeds.

Exactly. I just allowed for the extremely remote possibility he detected

something relevant. Almost certainly, if he found anything he found the known momentum conserving electric field.

He found that the Lorenz force does not have an equal and opposite
reaction. Thus justifying Maxwell and upgrading Newton. While outing all
modern physics.
The meanness of the racist and bigoted Eurocentric is hereby noted. Nothing
new. Same old suppression to be followed by the thefts, colonial style.
While demeaning the non-white throughout. We cyberdogs of Arindam are
disgusted.

And photon drive really isn't a new idea.

Irrelevant.

Even solar sails use that effect (momentum of sunlight).

No that is a heat engine. Temperature differences on either side cause the
motion. Radiant heat is em waves raising the temperature on one side, that
facing the sun.

However, it suffers from the unpleasant fact
that  c = 300 megawatt/newton, in slightly unconventional units.

That is why what we are really seeing is sloppy demonstrations, it is very unlikely Aridam's experiments could detect that small effect. We won't know because Aridam's experiments are unreproduceable, insufficient detail to reproduce his situation.

 

But we will never know since he refuses to
produce a writeup in sufficient detail for someone to reproduce his
experiment, instead writing "Watch my videos!!!".

 There is of course no momentum violation at all.
Whatever seems to be missing must be taken up by the sources of the
fields.

Certainly. But we won't ever know.

(and of course I don't watch videos)

Smart. His videos are a waste of time.

None so blind... these whiteys will make huge telescopes to see the ends of
the universe but will not look at videos one cluck away. Beyond disgusting.

 

Add his stubbornness that he insists this is something new that

violates

Newton/Einstein/Maxwell rather than a known existing behavior, you do

get

the incompetent tinkerer.

 Or the faker who thinks he is being clever.
There is no lack of videos showing really rotating unbalanced wheels,
rotating wheels with water bottles, and so on.

No lack of snake oil salesmen, even these days.

True all the physicists who are deliberstely blind and spout e=mcc=hv lies
are snake oil salesmen. Their huge success makes them only more so. Arindam
isn't selling anything. He is leading future generations to better living.
Woof-woof
bt (Arindam's best friends)